Mining, conflicts and livelihood struggles in a dysfunctional policy environment: the case of Wassa West District, Ghana (original) (raw)
Related papers
Globally, land has significant socioeconomic value since it is a major source of livelihood for people who use it for farming. Yet, mineral mining is reducing people's access to their land. This paper employs the global land grabbing literature to examine the political economy of land dispossession in Ghana's mining sector, with a focus on the activities of two multinational companies. The argument is that is that the dispossession that occurs due to the proliferation of mineral extraction undermines the potential contribution of mining to sustainable livelihood outcomes for people in host communities. To augment this argument, the paper draws upon primary data gathered using two methods namely, semi-structured interviews and focus group discussions in addition to a plethora of secondary sources, on the community perspectives on dispossession and marginalization relative to land and livelihoods in Ghana's mining sector. Drawing upon such data, the paper also underscores the intersections of place (global and local) and agency (domestic and foreign) with the overall objective of using the case of Ghana to underscore how land dispossession remains an important driver of social injustice, marginalization, and poor livelihoods in mining communities.
Radical reforms and liberalisation in Ghana’s mining sector have stimulated increased investment with new multi-national mining companies coming on board as well as the rehabilitation of old mines. The cumulative effects are the intensification of mining activities and the expansion in operations across the mining zones in the country. With most rural livelihoods being heavily dependent on natural capital, expansions in mining operations means rural livelihoods would be substantially challenged. This study assesses peoples’ response to the changes in their major livelihoods as a result of loss of land to mining in the Asutifi District, and the role of stakeholders in ensuring livelihood security for the people. Using interview schedules, in-depth interview guides and observation, data for the study were gathered from 217 randomly selected household respondents and 10 purposively selected key stakeholders drawn from five settlements that are mostly affected by mining activities in th...
Changing Livelihoods in Response to Mining: Evidence from the Asutifi District, Ghana
Radical reforms and liberalisation in Ghana's mining sector have stimulated increased investment with new multi-national mining companies coming on board as well as the rehabilitation of old mines. The cumulative effects are the intensification of mining activities and the expansion in operations across the mining zones in the country. With most rural livelihoods being heavily dependent on natural capital, expansions in mining operations means rural livelihoods would be substantially challenged. This study assesses peoples' response to the changes in their major livelihoods as a result of loss of land to mining in the Asutifi District, and the role of stakeholders in ensuring livelihood security for the people. Using interview schedules, in-depth interview guides and observation, data for the study were gathered from 217 randomly selected household respondents and 10 purposively selected key stakeholders drawn from five settlements that are mostly affected by mining activities in the district. The study found that there have been significant changes in the livelihoods of the people since the introduction of mining in the district. Prominent among these changes in the livelihoods is the shift from agriculture to trading due to loss of agricultural land to mining. The relevant stakeholders have not been able to collaborate effectively to ensure livelihood security. The study recommends the adoption of a comprehensive national policy that promotes the interest of residents of mining-fringe communities and a revision of the country's mineral and mining laws as a means to secure and sustain the livelihoods of residents living in mining-fringe communities.
Journal of Sustainable Development Studies, 2014
The environm ent, its natural resources and developm ent capacity remains a contentious elem ent in the development process of human society. In Ghana, similarly as Africa and other developing countries, there is a huge dependence of environm ental resources for economic gr owth and development. Mining gold resources is directly engulfed in this environment and natural resource exploitation process. While mining companies capitalize on their contribution to developm ent and provision of social services, local communities refute and demand abrogation of large-scale gold mining on their "land". Through an informant data collection approach and secondary data collection, the study analyzes cases of com pany-community disputes over gold mining and the underpinning issues, the dispute resolution strategies, and the weakn esses in the existing fram ework. Cases of disputes centered on com pensation, resettlem ent packages, unfulfilled prom ises, mistrust and lack of alternative livelihoods for economically displaced groups. The dispute resolution strategy is also seen as being too bureaucratic, poorly connected to the cultural and social intricacies of local communities and primarily com pany oriented. The Study proposes the need for a new framework that considered communities as integral but not peripheral in the general national framework as well as sustaining and enhancing local alternative livelihoods and community led co-designed sustainable development plans.
Journal of Rural and Development, 2017
The study determines the effects of mining on rural livelihoods, adopted strategies and the role of stakeholder and regulatory institutions. The study achieves this by investigating the status of key rural livelihood indicators, what influence the choice of livelihood strategies in mining communities and the assessment of institutional performance. The role of institutions even though a key instrument in ensuring sustainable livelihoods is mostly not considered in livelihood studies of developing countries. The study employed both quantitative and qualitative methods of data analysis. The significant difference in the means of income, yield value and labour cost between non-mining and mining communities is an evidence of the threat posed on communities in the study area by mining and its activities. The multinomial logit result showed that farmers’ choice of livelihood in mining communities was influenced by gender, age, family size, leadership status of household head, labour cost,...
20. Strained relations: a critical assessment of the mining conflict in Prestea, Ghana
Small-Scale Mining, Rural Subsistence and Poverty in West Africa, 2006
This paper examines the dynamics of the ongoing conflict in Prestea, Ghana, where indigenous galamsey mining groups are operating illegally on a concession awarded to Bogoso Gold Ltd. (BGL), property of the Canadian-listed multinational Golden Star Resources. Despite being issued firm orders by the authorities to abandon their activities, galamsey leaders maintain that they are working areas of the concession that are of little interest to the company; they further counter that there are few alternative sources of local employment, which is why they are mining in the first place. Whilst the Ghanaian Government is in the process of setting aside plots to relocate illegal mining parties and develop alternative livelihood projects, its efforts are far from encouraging: in addition to a series of overlooked logistical problems, the areas earmarked for relocation have yet to be prospected, and the alternative incomeearning activities identified have proved highly inappropriate. The key to resolving the impasse at Prestea rests on increased dialogue between the conflicting parties; restoring community trust, particularly in the government; and carrying out community-level research to identify and develop appropriate alternative livelihoods.
2018
The performance of the gold mining industry globally is in no doubt. However, the industry's susceptibility to the frequent rise and fall in the price of gold, coupled with the various negative impacts it generates in mining communities have made it reliability for economic growth and development questionable. These impacts have often been grouped under environmental, social and economic impacts. Using a case study of Goldfields Damang in Ghana, this study examined in detail how stakeholder communities within the catchment areas of Goldfields can be developed through sustainable mining practices. The study used political ecology theory to understand the powers of the various actors (multinational companies and government) and to further investigate how decisions taken by these bodies have led to a devastation of the local environment. The study revealed that while Goldfields Damang has been doing a lot in terms of development in the areas of education, livelihood programs and in...
Development-induced displacement and resettlement (DIDR) is a significant socioeconomic problem. Recent estimates suggest that approximately 20 million people are displaced every year to make way for the construction and operation of large-scale development projects, such as dams and mining. More than forty years of scholarship show that people displaced by these projects often experience worse levels of poverty and, in the majority of cases, struggle to recover from this impoverishment. International finance institutions have attempted to address project-induced impoverishment by putting forward resettlement policy frameworks and guidelines. These policy measures have been complemented by scholarly models for planning and implementing resettlement that aim to prevent impoverishment. However, despite numerous policies, impoverishment remains a predominant outcome in most displacement settings. This thesis focuses on mining-induced displacement and resettlement (MIDR). It engages scholarly works and literature on displacement and sustainable livelihoods and argues that continuing widespread impoverishment-in the face of 'improved' resettlement policy and practiceis a result of inadequate engagement with the human scale dimensions of household livelihood development. The thesis is based on an ethnographic case study from Ghana and examines a resettlement exercise as it occurred at the Akyem gold mine project. Based on constructivist perspectives, it uses a combined conceptual lens from the Sustainable Livelihoods Frameworks, Sen's (1999) Capabilities Approach, and concepts from industrial sociology to examine the human scale issues in MIDR. These issues are examined at three levels: household, policy platforms and institutional practices. Habermas' (1984) idea of "communicative action" is also deployed to conceptualise potential areas of intersection across these levels. Primary data is analyzed from interviews with a sample of 82 participants and informants, comprising twenty-five (25) randomly selected household participants and fifty-seven (57) key informants. Documents are analysed as primary sources for understanding the legal and regulatory instruments, policies and guidelines pertaining to MIDR within Ghana and the international context. At the household level, the findings from the research confirmed the established pattern of impoverishment and vulnerability resulting from MIDR. The pressures of being dispossessed, combined with the rapid transformations associated with industrial scale mining, were prominent and directly explained the impoverishment process facing the households. Attempts
ILLEGAL MINING AS THREAT TO SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN GHANA: A POLITICAL ECOLOGY APPROACH
Within the past few decades, Ghana's mining sector specifically the small scale mining subsector has been marred by controversies mainly due to its threat to sustainable development. This paper provides some insights into the inextricable linkage between sustainable development and illegal gold mining popularly referred to as " galamsey " and examines the effectiveness of political response and processes at the local and national level. While acknowledging the incommensurable role of the mining sector in poverty reduction through employment generation, the adverse impact on the environmental, economic and social fabric of society cannot be ignored. Notwithstanding this hard evidence at hand, successive governments are handicapped to reverse the devastating effects partly due to the complicated and multifaceted nature of the small scale mining sub-sector. Semi-structured interviews were conducted in three illegal mining communities comprised 12 illegal miners and officials task to monitor mining activities. We also extensively utilized official government reports and relevant academic literature to draw attention to the multiplicity and diversity of illegal mining. By examining livelihood strategies and reviewing successive government policies on mining and sustainability, we discovered gaps in the area of policy implementation and systemic marginalization of majority of communities where illegal mining occurs. In this paper, we advocate for a broader multidimensional and sectoral collaboration as a fundamental approach to confront illegal small scale mining activities.
Ghana experienced rapid liberalisation in the mining sector in the 1980s and 90s which led to the intensification of mining activities across mining zones in the country. This study therefore examined how operations of Newmont Ghana Gold Limited (NGGL) affect environmental justice in the Asutifi District. Using questionnaires, in-depth interview guides and observation checklist, data for the study were gathered from 217 randomly selected household respondents and 10 purposively selected key stakeholders. The results revealed widespread environmental injustices caused by mining that infringe on the rights of the residents of Asutifi District to live in safe and healthy environment they are entitled to. The paper recommends the application of international best practices by Newmont to reduce the adverse impacts of its activities on the environment and wellbeing of residents, and a revision of existing legislations on mining in Ghana in order to safeguard the wellbeing of communities a...