REASON AND WILL: REMARKS ON AUGUSTINE’S IDEA OF POWER (original) (raw)
Related papers
Sovereignty under trial: crisis in Augustine of Hippo's political theology, between
Argumentos. Revista de Filosofía, 2023
In this paper I will argue that the concept of crisis is at the heart of Political Theology by focusing on the major work of Augustine of Hippo, The City of God. Augustine's strategy is to gather both medical and theological meanings of crisis to argue for the unique sovereignty of the One God, the only one that decides and judges over the critical course of history and the One that will bring everything to an end by His Final Judgement. The focus on Augustine's treatise will also show how the Political Theology quarrel between Carl Schmitt and Erik Peterson should be examined once again, mainly to redefine the concept of sovereignty by the concept of crisis, for to be considered a sovereign is in itself something to be decided on.
Augustine’s Introduction to Political Philosophy: Teaching De Libero Arbitrio, Book I
Book I of Augustine's work On Free Choice (De Libero Arbitrio) offers a helpful introduction to some of the most important themes of political philosophy. The paper makes a case for teaching this text in introductory courses on political thought, theology of social life, and similar topics, alongside or even in place of the more usually assigned excerpts from City of God. The text is written as a dialogue in which Augustine seeks to introduce a student of his to reflection on the ways in which our moral outlook is profoundly shaped by our political citizenship. It invites all of us, whether Christian or non-Christian citizens, to enter into the dialogue ourselves as Augustine's students and so to reflect on the moral significance of our own citizenship.
Three Variants of the Concept of Power: A Comparative Analysis through Theological inquiry
Pharos journal of theology, 2023
This article endeavors to embark on a comprehensive exploration of the multifaceted concept of power, employing a comparative and critical lens to examine its various theological underpinnings. The central objective of this study is to discern the affirmative elements inherent in three distinct variants of the concept of power, with the ultimate intention of incorporating these constructive facets into an encompassing integral theory of power.The following are chosen as the subject of analysis: 1) the concept of M. Heidegger (the first option), 2) the concept of M. Foucault (the second option) and 3) the concepts of N. Luhmann and E. Giddens (the third option). The study uses a cultural-historical approach, textual analysis and a comparative method. It has been established that Heidegger, who adopted the concept of the will to power from F. Nietzsche and combined power and being (the main category of his philosophy), could not establish harmony between them. It is noted that the ontological interpretation of power cannot be accepted as adequate. In this respect, Foucault, Luhmann, and Giddens are more correct, since they interpret power as an exclusively social phenomenon. However, their concepts cannot be recognized as fully consistent. Foucault interpreted power as an all-social phenomenon, which is not true. Luhmann and Giddens interpreted power as a social phenomenon, albeit in different ways. The first considers it as a means of communication, and the second-as an active ability to transform. At the same time, both are interpreted by them very primitively. The article concludes that a more adequate concept of power should be sought from other researchers. At the same time, some positive points contained in the analyzed concepts can be included in the integral theory of power. The study and the results obtained in it can be applied primarily in the development of an integral theory of power, and secondly, in the practice of teaching philosophy, political science, political psychology and theology.
CATEGORY OF 'POWER': HISTORICO-PHILOSOPHICAL ASPECT AS A PROLEGOMENON TO IDEA OF BALANCE
Zhadiaiev, D. (2023). CATEGORY OF ‘POWER’: HISTORICO-PHILOSOPHICAL ASPECT AS A PROLEGOMENON TO IDEA OF BALANCE. European Science, 4(sge18-04), 78–85. https://doi.org/10.30890/2709-2313.2023-18-04-029, 2023
The article attempts to trace the roots of what idea of power means from Aristotle to Locke and to Kant. This is the first part that considers idea of power in light of physical and mental poles (borrowed from process philosophy).
Augustine in a Time of Crisis: Politics and Religion Contested
2021
This volume addresses our global crisis by turning to Augustine, a master at integrating disciplines, philosophies, and human experiences in times of upheaval. It covers themes of selfhood, church and state, education, liberalism, realism, and 20th-century thinkers. The contributors enhance our understanding of Augustine’s thought by heightening awareness of his relevance to diverse political, ethical, and sociological questions. Bringing together Augustine and Gallicanism, civil religion, and Martin Luther King, Jr., this volume expands the boundaries of Augustine scholarship through a consideration of subjects at the heart of contemporary political theory.
This paper will delve into this issue and discover many aspects of what Augustine of Hippo advocated on this topic by examining his writings and activities. There is a difference of opinion among scholars as the degree to which he advocated state coercion and his underlying motivations for doing so.
Freedom by Coercion: Augustine's Limitation of Coercion by the State
Religions, 2024
Despite the tendency of some modern scholars to mark Augustine as the father of religious coercion, the Second Vatican Council (1962–65) cites him as a principal source for freedom of conscience. This essay presents evidence from Augustine’s letters and anti-Donatist writings to show that he both upheld freedom of conscience and maintained a vital role for state force. The essay shows that far from simply providing a Christian justification for the use of state force against non-Catholics, Augustine most notably imposed the limits of Christian charity on a long history of state-sponsored religious persecution. Only by the charitable and paternal application of discipline by the state would many Donatists be truly free to follow their conscience. In this way, those persecuted for being in schism could attain freedom by coercion.
Governmentality meets theology: 'The King reigns, but he does not govern'
2012
While this 'extraordinary' book appears as an intermezzo within the Homo Sacer series , it supports two fundamental theses with its own philological, epigraphic, liturgical and religious-historical research, and a close reading of figures such as Ernst Kantorowicz and Marcel Mauss. These theses concern political power first as an articulation of sovereign reign and economic government and, secondly, as constituted by acclamations and glorification. These can be approached theoretically through its author's engagement with Michel Foucault's genealogy of governmentality and with the Erik Peterson/Carl Schmitt debate on the closure of political theology. Agamben's reformulation of power and his derivation of liberal governmentality from the theological oikonomia prove convincing. A renewed analytics of power and politics of resistance should be possible, however, without recourse to a project seeking to deactivate all profane powers including those of public bureaucracies.