Climate change as a ‘hyperobject’: a critical review of Timothy Morton's reframing narrative (original) (raw)
Related papers
Climate Crisis and Consciousness: Re-imagining our world and ourselves
Climate Crisis and Consciousness: Re-imagining our world and ourselves, 2020
Climate crisis disrupts the beliefs, values and behaviors of contemporary societies, sparking potential for radical changes in culture and consciousness. Drawing upon her experience as a Jungian psychotherapist and a researcher in the field of climate psychology, Sally Gillespie writes about the challenges, dilemmas, opportunities and transformations of engaging with climate and ecological crises. Many factors shape how we understand and respond to the existential threats of climate crisis. This accessible book with its discussions about worldviews, cultural myths, emotional resilience, social connectedness, nature relatedness and collective action explores consciousness change in those most engaged with climate issues. Calling upon the words and stories of many people, including Indigenous leaders, ecologists, campaigners, writers and philosophers, Gillespie encourages us to enter into climate conversations to forge emotional resilience, ecological consciousness and inspired action. With its unique focus on the psychological experience of facing into the climate crisis, this warm and supportive book offers companionship and sustenance for anyone who wants to be alive to our natural world and to the existential challenges of today. It is an essential resource for counsellors, psychotherapists, social workers and other helping professionals, as well as climate campaigners, policy makers, educators, scientists and researchers.
Archives of the Present-Future: Climate Change and Representational Breakdown (Avery Review, 2016)
Also in Climates: Architecture and the Planetary Imaginary (Columbia Books on Architecture and the City with Lars Müller Publishers, 2016): http://www.arch.columbia.edu/books/catalog/138-climates-architecture-and-the-planetary-imaginary , 2016
A dizzyingly convoluted phenomenon, climate change entails many (often correlated and at times seemingly contradictory) things happening in multiple places at once, at varying rates and scales, and with myriad types and degrees of consequence. In addition to certain unprecedented material-environmental conditions, it thus poses profound representational dilemmas. From what vantage point might we engage this multi-scalar/-temporal/-dimensional/-disciplinary “shadow that is no less ominous because it is formless and obscure,” to borrow Rachel Carson’s analogy for pesticide contamination from 1962? The existing visual culture of climate change—brimming with depictions of polar bears atop waning ice, apocalyptic landscapes, and satellite views from above—adheres largely to an illustrative mode, despite the incongruousness and even muteness of such a manner in the face of newly complex entanglements between the human and nonhuman, not to mention the kind of attritional, “slow violence” associated with climate change. Using the artist Amy Balkin’s ongoing A People’s Archive of Sinking and Melting (2011-) as a counter-model, this essay considers forms of representation that dwell in the “sticky materiality of practical encounters” (Anna Tsing), moving across scales and registers in order to forge not seamless perspectives, but rather, ones that are adequately fractured and muddy.
Climate Change and the Problem of Representation
Australian Humanities Review, 2009
How do we know climate change? How do we encounter its reality? This question brings to mind a history of scepticism and denial-those who ask 'where is the evidence?' against scientific efforts to model and map out predicted temperature rises. Yet the word prediction is telling here: how can you know something that is still unfolding? In order to respond to the manifesting consequences of environmental change, there is an imperative to capture and convey change in the midst of process. Somewhere between scepticism and prediction is the problem of representation-a concern that unites scientists and artists in the desire to say something of truth about the world. Signs of change obsess us and we look to science for orientation through these. Poetic representation is valued as a tool of communication and inspiration-to educate, warn and motivate responses. Yet as the consequences of climate change continue to manifest, representation sits ambiguously in a context of these materially-grounded concerns. This paper offers a rethinking of the role of representation in environmental discourse. It suggests that rather than representation's inability to access the real, the more pressing issue is the relationship between humans and the non-human environment that modes of representation assert. It is ultimately our ontological and epistemological traditions, and the work of representation within these, that determine our distance from or proximity to the elements of a transforming ecology.
Navigating Through Climate Change Beware of Metaphors
While by no means challenging the reality of the crisis, this author finds that Jackson and Jensen present an analysis of the origins and required response to the apocalyptic collapse of the earth’s climate that invoke key metaphors inappropriately. In agreement that the core response involves humanity acknowledging its ‘limits,’ but Jackson and Jenson treat limits only as imposing limitations on behavior. Furthermore, their account of ‘evolutionary adaptation’ is materialistically reductionistic and profiles humanity’s ‘carbon nature’ as a genetic condition driving the development of fossil fuel energy. Foremost, their materialistic reductionism treats ‘mind’ as merely a product of the brain’s synapses. The author claims that a more adequate understanding of, and response to, climate change requires careful attention to these key metaphors of ‘humanity’s limits,’ ‘environmental adaptation,’ and the ‘mind’ without succumbing to speciesism.
Ecology, Psychoanalysis and Global Warming: Present and Future Traumas [Editorial]
2020
The Coronavirus crisis links to the climate crisis in ways that challenge humankind to demonstrate an unprecedented creativity and adaptability to change. This article discusses, both in content and style, this need for creative change and what that might look like. It asserts that the current discourse, with its linear rationality and logic system will fail in the face of the enormity of such epistemological and ontological disturbance. Using the example of social dreaming as a different form of thinking, the article encourages the reader to radically reconsider thought, feelings, reason and creativity as a means to rethinking solutions for a shared future.
Narratives of climate change: introduction
Journal of Historical Geography, 2009
This paper introduces a special feature on narratives of climate change, containing papers by Richard Hamblyn, Sverker So¨rlin, Michael Bravo and Diana Liverman. The feature reflects the rising cultural profile of climate change in the public sphere, as represented, for example, by Al Gore's documentary film, An Inconvenient Truth, and art exhibitions devoted to the subject.
English Studies, 2024
Despite arguments to the contrary, this article contends that climate realism both is and is yet to become a useful and valuable genre for aestheticising an environmentally threatened and threatening present. It conceptualises Jessie Greengrass’s The High House as a contemporary novel that mobilises climate realism through the “everyday Anthropocene” paradigm to convey the affective experience of living through and with climate crisis for a Western Global North populace. This affective climate is most typified by a paralysing ecological grief that implicates the novel’s characters in wider political inertia. As such, I argue that The High House deploys climate realism to scrutinise the structures of feeling that directly or indirectly contribute to this inertia, intimating that a living with and through climate crisis – what can, after Lauren Berlant, be called climate crisis ordinariness – might in effect equate to political quiescence if not indirect complicity in ecocide.
Interférences littéraires/ Literaire interferenties, 2022
It was on June 28th and 29th, during the first months of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020, that an international group of researchers from the humanities, environmental studies, psychology and urban studies came together – necessarily online – for the workshop “Narratives & Climate Change”. The workshop was organized by the Dutch Open University and originated from the universities’ research project Imaginaries of the Future City: Envisioning Climate Change and Technological City Scapes Through Contemporary Speculative Fiction. We, literary scholars, initiated this interfaculty project in 2018, from the observation that narrative fiction – and the genre of speculative fiction in particular – plays an important role in imagining the implications of climate change on urban environments [...].
Call for papers: Reading and Writing the World: Perception and Identity in the Era of Climate Change
5-6 April 2019 Paul-Valéry Montpellier 3 University. Montpellier, France Keynote speakers: Thomas Dutoit, Lille U, France Bénédicte Meillon, Perpignan VD University, France In collaboration with: Sylvère Petit (film producer, photographer), France This conference will attempt to trace and analyze modes of reading and writing that are not based on human mastery and exceptionalism, but rather make room for different possible viewpoints, while also questioning our identity as well as the objectivity and limits of human perception. The conference is built around the necessity to adopt a different way of reading and writing that shakes the foundations of our thinking about Earth and its various inhabitants, and forces us to see anew a landscape whose very form has been defamiliarised by the forces that traverse it. Such reading and writing might have to come to terms with what Timothy Morton calls “the symbiotic real” – the interconnectedness between species. Today, going beyond ourselves requires learning to reread ourselves and our current environment to understand our vulnerability while assuming responsibility for the endangered planet and non-human species. From encounters with diverse forms of non-human otherness (the planet, animals, forests, ...) and one’s otherness within, would emerge an ethics of alterity. We welcome papers for 20-minute presentations in English on writing and reading (not limited to literature or to humanities only) the Earth/the world/ worlds.
The Adaptation of Disaster: Representations of Environmental Crises in Climate Change Fiction
Komparatistik Online, 2018
Adaptation is a crucial practice, both materially and epistemologically. But especially in regards to the latter, the impact of adaptation processes has not yet received the attention it demands. Knowledge production is a central concern of the so-called Anthropocene, because it lays out the frames in which adaptation to climate change and other global environmental crises are realized (or not). By comparing adaptations of climate change in Michael Crichton’s State of Fear (2004) and Roland Emmerich’s The Day After Tomorrow (2004) as well as Solar by Ian McEwan (2010) and Freedom by Johnathan Franzen (2010), this paper aims at demonstrating how narrative adaptation and material adaptation to climate change are intertwined. In fact, these contrasting narratives share a conviction that the gap between the sciences and the humanities and the ensuing failure of communication (within and outside of academia) plays a crucial part in the failure to understand and adapt to the changing conditions on planet Earth. By regarding adaptation as a negotiating practice that is part of knowledge production and representation, this paper aims to revisit expectations and bias on both sides and to point out that neither science nor fiction is entirely determined by scientists or literary scholars. It will show how analyzing the adaptation of climate change can give insight into the cultural framework necessary for an adaptation to global disaster.