Understanding Computer-Mediated Discussions: Positivist and Interpretive Analyses of Group Support System USE1 (original) (raw)
Related papers
Using group support systems to facilitate the research process
1992
Abstract Group support systems (GSS) and their effects on group processes and outcomes have been an object of intense study over the past ten years (1982-92). The purpose of the authors is to take a different perspective with respect to GSS research. Rather than discussing research about GSS, they discuss the capabilities of GSS tools to support the process of doing research.
An analysis of communication mode in group support systems research
Decision Support Systems, 2004
Group support systems (GSS) have been the subject of many investigations and meta-analyses over the past decade. This study presents, summarizes, and analyzes the results of 145 experiments that used communication mode as an independent variable. The results show that the modal outcome for GSSs compared to Face-to-Face (FtF) methods is ''no difference,'' while the overall percentage of positive effects for results that compare GSS to FtF is 29.2%. The results suggest that the use of a GSS improves decision quality, depth of analysis, equality of participation, and satisfaction over manual methods. Additionally, more detailed analysis suggests that task type, GSS type and the interaction of both have a moderating effect on adaptation and outcome factors. Specifically, groups working on idea generation tasks using GSS decision room technology improve to 39.6% (GSS>FtF) effect. Conversely, asynchronous computer-mediated communication (CMC) groups working on decision making tasks improved to 46.4% (GSS>FtF) effect. FtF groups show higher levels of consensus and perceived quality, communicate more, and are more efficient (requiring less time to complete the tasks). No differences are observed between FtF and GSS groups on satisfaction and usability. D
Measuring the educational value of the online discussion groups : a gender analysis
2019
Social media technologies provide various forms of educational support. Online discussion groups have been created by educators to maintain a closer relationship with the students. Although the online discussion groups are widely used in universities, the research on this topic has been carried on mainly by qualitative studies. There are few approaches measuring the educational support provided by the online discussion groups. The main objective of this paper is to analyze the gender differences in the perception of the educational support provided by the online discussion groups. The educational support has been conceptualized as a global factor that manifests along three dimensions: support for teaching, support for personal development and support for professional formation. An invariance analysis has been carried on that showed a metric invariance of the model. The gender analysis results show that both female and male students consider that the discussion groups stimulate the c...
Relational Development in Computer-Supported Groups
MIS Quarterly, 1996
This study examines how group attitudes and outcomes evolve over time with repeated use of a group support system. Social Information Processing (SIP) theory, which suggests that relational intimacy may take longer to develop in computer-supported groups, was used as the basis for testing a temporally bounded model of group behavior. The basic argument underlying this model is that computer-supported groups, given adequate time, will exchange enough social information to develop strong relational links. Thus, while computer support was expected to limit group interactions initially, the model predicted that, over a period of time, such constraints would dissipate. The results show evidence of such shifts among computer-supported groups. Attitudes of GSS users changed over time from highly negative to somewhat positive; outcomes improved more slowly. The turnaround in attitudes of usersutoward each other and the interaction process--support the SIP perspective that repeated use of computer supportdespite some inherent initial restrictions--can help groups affiliate.
Computer-Mediated Group Interaction Processes
2009 International Conference on Complex, Intelligent and Software Intensive Systems, 2009
The use of computer-mediated groups has become common particularly in international organizations and global companies. In light of this growing phenomenon, the traditional group interaction should be re-observed. The research questions deal with the interaction between the computer-mediated group members, trying to figure whether (and how) the media change the way people interact, in hope of improving the group interaction using group structure. Based on Bales' IPA model we present an experiment in which subjects, who were grouped, had to share information in order to complete an intellective task. The findings indicate that the positive level of the computermediated unstructured group discussions is significantly lower than the positive level of the faceto-face unstructured group discussions. The structure seem to act as a partial solution, since structured group discussions is positive than unstructured group discussions.
IEEE Transactions on Professional Communication, 2006
Firms that are trying to stay competitive in the current business environment often require the use of groups. The popularity of group work is tied to the promise of improved productivity via the pooling of information, knowledge, and skills. In recent years, group work has been expanded to virtual or distributed environments. However, there are questions about how aspects of group workspecifically group size and social presenceimpact group members' ability to voice opinions. This study examines groups of two sizes in three distinct social presence settings: face-to-face, face-to-face groups using collaborative software, and virtual using collaborative software. This study finds that both group size and social presence impact individual instrumental voice, value-expressive voice, and the group interaction process. The results show that by increasing social presence through the use of collaborative software, it is possible to lessen the negative impact of increasing group size. These results should be of interest to the increasing number of organizations that are implementing virtual group environments.
Sharing and constructing perspectives in web-based conferencing
Computers & Education, 2006
This study investigates the quality and nature of virtual interaction in a higher education context. The study aims to find out variables that mediate virtual interaction, particularly the emerging processes of sharing and constructing perspectives in web-based conferencing. The ...
Making use of online discussion groups
Australian Educational Computing, 2000
Witmer, D. (1998). Introduction to computer-mediated communication: A master syllabus for teaching communication technology.