The New Challenges for the Public Regulator: The Local Agencies for the Public Services: The Italian Case (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Accountability Cycle in Public Agencies: Lessons from Italian Experiences
2010
The diffusion of Public Agencies seems to characterise the approach to public management in European countries. Under New Public Management, the role of politics is to provide strategic planning and economic policy target defini-tion, whereas the administration is responsible for the management of public services. Moreover, the separation between politics and administration is strengthened by downsizing and decentralizing the public
ACCOUNTABILITY IN ITALIAN LOCAL GOVERNMENTS: STATE OF THE ART AND FUTURE PERSPECTIVE
The theme of accountability has interested the world of public administrations following what happened in the private sector (Ball, 2004). However, public accountability in Local Governments has significantly evolved over the last 20 years. In Italy, many Local Governments fostered this process by publishing social reports. However, further research is still needed to understand if and how these administrations are using such tools to promote their public accountability. Are social reports actually used by Italian public authorities as means to deliver public accountability? This chapter aims at highlighting the state of the art and future perspective of social reporting practices within Italian Local Governments.
The recent evolution of governance systems of the Italian local public authorities underlines, besides a growing interest in the processes of measurement and control of performances, a widespread tendency toward logic of transparency in relations with stakeholders. Transparency is, in fact, a requirement of good governance which is a dominant quality of all the activities of the public institution whose relations with external stakeholders finds primary expression in the communication processes. Transparency in the governance of local public authorities finds significant regulations that have occurred since the last decade of the last century. The most important reform laws – laws 142 and 241 in 1990, Legislative decree n. 150 of 2009 and Legislative decree n. 235 of 2010 and the recent directives on the subject of social and gender reporting– stress, however, the connection between enlargement of the information necessary for a clear governance, content and channels of communication. The public dimension of municipalities also emphasizes the criticality of institutional communication, as an element of promotion of fiduciary relationships with different stakeholders for obtaining lasting consensus on the choices implemented in favor of the community. Consistent with the limited resources available, each municipality should have its own website in which to place a set of appropriate information to ensure the transparency of governance, on how to use the economic resources available and the results achieved in favor of reference community. This contribution is based on many years of research, which took into account a large number of Italian municipalities and has developed a detailed assessment of the effectiveness of external communication through the use of the Internet. Specifically, the empirical analysis covers the period 2007/2011 and considers – according to a joint role, dimensional situations, complexity and availability of resources – all the chief town of the Italian Regions, all the chief town of the Lombardy Provinces, all municipalities in the Province of Brescia (in total 260 municipalities). The research approach is empirical/inductive and is based on the provision of a convenient grids containing the necessary elements to enable one to evaluate the effectiveness of institutional communication. The definition of items considers: rules/guidelines and the essential requirements of transparency, also taking into account the latest contributions of management studies in the field of public communication. The aims of this paper are to highlight, in particular, the degree of use and the limits of the Internet for transparency and quality of communication implemented by the municipalities, the current evolutionary trends and its connection with the regulatory action, the relationship between formal and substantial transparency, the main areas for improvement in order to obtain optimal effectiveness in relations between municipalities/stakeholders.
Mechanisms and Public Administration Reform: Italian Cases of Better Regulation and Digitalization
Public Administration, 2011
This article applies a processual approach to the explanation of administrative reform in Italy over fifteen years. By carrying out a comparison between better regulation and digitalization policies it shows that the oscillation in the level of implementation over time and across policies can be explained by the intensity and direction of spillover and certification mechanisms and that in turn these mechanisms are activated by design features and contextual factors at different levels of analysis. Starting in the early 1990s, Italy entered a period of what has been called 'permanent reform' (Capano 2000), which makes it a excellent laboratory for the study of the factors that affect the intensity of the reform efforts and the extent to which reforms succeed. In particular, this article follows the evolution over fifteen years (1992-2006) of Italian administrative reform, focusing on two areas, better regulation and digitalization, that are crucial for the interaction between the citizens/users and the bureaucratic structure. These reforms conflict with the expectation that countries that belong, like Italy, to the Napoleonic administrative tradition should find it difficult to introduce 'citizen-focused' reforms (Peters 2008, p. 122). They also raise the question of the extent to which the reforms have been actually implemented, considering that a number of authors have concluded that reforms in Napoleonic countries in Southern Europe have failed (for example, for Italy, Capano 2003; for Italy, France and Spain, Kickert 2007) and that one of the features of the Napoleonic tradition, legalism, fosters an attitude of relative disregard for implementation compared to the passing of legal statutes (Gualmini 2008; Ongaro and Valotti 2008). Furthermore, like-and indeed more than-other Napoleonic countries Italy has, since the early 1990s, also been a prime example of a political system undergoing significant and continuous change in a number of contextual dimensions that are likely to affect reform, in particular with regard to the structure of the executive, the electoral rules, and the nature of electoral competition, the partisan orientation of the executives, the relationship between politics and bureaucracy, and the organization of the state (for a typology of contexts, see Barzelay 2003). In other words, in Italy's case we can rightly talk of a 'context in motion' that remains open to bargaining among the actors and that develops in different ways in different administrative areas (Ongaro 2009, 2011). This article aims to contribute to the processual literature on administrative reform by providing evidence for the connection between reform outcomes, mechanisms, and the conditions that facilitate the activation of these mechanisms. The article shows how the variation in the reform outcomes corresponds to variations in the orientation and intensity of the spillover and certification mechanisms across two policy areas and three time periods and how in turn these mechanisms were activated by a combination of actors' choices and process context at different levels of analysis.
Corporate Ownership and Control
The issue of accountability, particularly with regard to the use of public resources, represents one of the most significant and necessary aspects faced by a public administration. This work, therefore, focuses on the transparency of information with regard to the economic viability of a public administration, paying specific attention to the local and regional authorities which have been subject to major reforms in accounting systems. Harmonised accounting is the term given to the complex and multifaceted process of reforming public accounting, as provided by Italian Law No. 196, Article 2, December 31, 2009, and is aimed at unifying, comparing and aggregating the public administration financial statement, carrying out the operations with the same methods and accounting policies, and seeking to satisfy the necessity for information and accountability relating to the coordination of public finances. Several studies have analyzed the effects of accounting reforms on accountability. H...