Culturalism as Hegemonic Ideology and Liberating Practice (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Origins and Perspectives of ‘Culture’—Is it Relevant Anymore?
Human Arenas, 2020
This paper argues that ‘culture’ is a crucial element of humans’ mental developmental dynamics and traces various threads of explorations of the concept of ‘culture’ and aims to contribute to its systemic understanding. Culture has been represented predominantly as external to a person or as something that is at the same time inside and outside of the mind by the various streams of Cartesian social sciences. The latter theoretical stances led to the essentialization, ‘entification’ and objectification of the concept/phenomenon. The systemic approach is proposed in order to more adequately reflect the relational organization of individuals, societies and cultures. ‘Culture’ should be understood as an entirety of relational processes of sense-making of experiences that are self-centred, intentional and future-oriented, however, always rooted in historically constructed sociocultural systems. Cultural elements and individuals are indissolubly and meaningfully linked and defined in relation to each other. Interaction between people and cultural elements is dialogical and is organized in intransitive hierarchical structures. The systemic approach to the cultural and semiotic dynamics allows us to understand how patterns of signs, meanings and behaviours are constructed through the past historical process and in relation to the anticipated short-term and distant future. ‘Culture’ is everywhere wherever and whenever human relates to or anticipates real or imaginary ‘other’, or whenever s/he constructs or interprets any ‘objectified’ sign. It is considered as the systemic totality of the processes of meaningful relating to others that is the basis for affectively charged meaning-making processes. The self-definition is possible only through ‘Culture’.
1. The origins of the debate: " culture " vs " civilization " in the romantic criticisms of the Enlightenment. 2. The challenge of the " inter-textual " notion of culture vs the avant-garde in post-modernism. 3. The pluralist concept of culture in recent inter-culturalism. 4. The (pen)ultimate crisis in the dichotomy civic nationalism/ethnic-cultural nationalism " Culture is always composed of seriously contested codes and representations " James Clifford, Writing Culture " If the word " culture " is an historical and philosophical text, it is also the site of a political conflict… culture arises when civilization begins to seem self-contradictory " Terry Eagleton, The Idea of Culture
Complicating the concept of culture
Comparative Education, 2012
This essay argues against a simple, reified view of culture as a set of ideas and norms belonging to a group or nation and considers implications of a more complicated concept for discussion of world culture and the global/local nexus. Most anthropologists define culture as the making of meaning, with an emphasis on the process itself as contested. It follows that world culture is locally produced in social interaction, and that meaning are then reconstructed in the global/local nexus. Power matters, particularly the hidden power to make resources for meaning making widely available, and to make them attractive and scientifically persuasive. How actors succeed in claiming particular ideas as global and how the locals strategically respond are questions where anthropologists can contribute to understanding the global/local nexus and the exercise of power within the world polity.
2017
The first chapter highlights the confusing plurality of meanings attached to the notion of culture. While it is used in increasingly many contexts, giving rise to the idea of an ongoing ‘culturalisation’, a range of new materialists and antihermeneutic posthumanists have sought to undermine the centrality of culture, meaning, interpretation and mediation. The book structure is explained: Chapters 2– 5 in Part I summarising the main concepts of culture, presenting their meanings, uses and limitations; Chapters 6– 8 in Part II scrutinising the contestations in structuralism, science and technology studies and media archaeology; and Chapters 9– 11 in Part III reconstructing sustainable foundations for a ‘post-antihermeneutic’ concept of culture, defending the idea of meaning-making practices of communication and mediation, while attentively learning from the critiques.
Culture from the Perspective of Realistic Philosophy
Studia Gilsoniana, 2015
The article underlines the moments that define the metaphysical understanding of culture. According to this conception, culture in its most basic meaning is rationalization (intellectualization) of nature. The article is focused on the following areas: genetic-exemplarist analysis of cultural works and definition of culture from the perspective of realistic philosophy.