The Guardians of the Internet? Politics and Ethics of Cyberactivists (and of their Observers) (original) (raw)
Related papers
Perverting Activism: Cyberactivism and Its Potential Failures in Enhancing Democratic Institutions
In this paper we will analyze the impact of new technologies on a range of practices related to activism. In the first section we show how the functioning of democratic institutions can be impaired by scarce political accountability connected with the emergence of moral hazard; in the second section we display how cyberactivism can improve the transparency of political dynamics; in the last section we will turn specifically to cyberactivism and isolate its flaws and some of the most pernicious and self-defeating effects.
DIGITAL DEMOCRACY: CONSTRUCTING A CITIZENS' HISTORY ON CYBERSPACE
— It has been argued that " ... the digital text, with its democratic architecture, allows for the possibility of constructing a citizen's history that is inclusive and diverse, where a multiplicity of viewpoints becomes relevant " (Anon., cited in Perera, 2015, P.1). This suggests that cyberspace with its potential to enable multiple stories from various subjectivities has become a site of cultural agency and citizenship (Goode, 2010), radical collaboration, convergence and a tool of democratizing the construction of knowledge. Thus, the digital becomes a new political space which in turn politically charges the 'real' practices and spaces that become the subject of digital narratives. In the light of these observations, this paper critically analyses the construction and content of a Wikipedia entry on 2014 anti-Muslim riots in Sri Lanka. A critical reading of the content indicates that user-generated content of a platform such as Wikipedia which is known for community participation and radical collaboration indicates the possibility of web-based texts being rather hegemonic 'citizen's' histories/ stories rather than democratic and that of 'citizens''. Therefore, with a view to elucidating the intersections between various ideologies, power, strategies of storytelling and the digital in its fluidity as well as rigidity, this paper also discusses possible tools and strategies to produce alternative digital texts that interrupt existing hegemonic narratives in an attempt to harness the strengths of cyberspace for the purpose of activism and consciousness-raising.
Political activism in the era of the Internet
individualization processes, the crisis in the ideological frameworks which structured political life in the 20 th century, the weakening of political parties -date from before the emergence of communication via the Internet, which is influenced by these preexisting trends, while at the same time modifying them. 3. The bibliography on the effects of the virtual world counterposes "pessimists" and "optimists". The optimists stress that the communication technologies open up new possibilities for horizontal communication among citizens, diminish communication transaction costs in the public space, accelerate communication and eliminate physical distance enabling people and groups to issue opinions and establish dialogues on an unprecedented scale, reducing the relative importance of the old communication media and opening up new alternative information channels for citizens. The pessimists believe that impacts of the Internet are the impoverishment and polarization of political culture and debate, the destruction of privacy -providing the State and companies with access to databanks which enable the manipulation and control of individuals -, and the illusion of Country Case studies Argentina Ni Una Menos Change.og Partido de la Red Brazil Internet Civil Framework Avaaz June 2013 Protests Mídia Ninja Online/off-line: the new fabric of political activism Online support campaigns Online support campaigns for specific causes represent the continuation of a long democratic tradition of support for manifestos or petitions requesting changes in legislation. The use of signatures collected online is still not recognized legally in any of the countries in the region. Alternative ways of using this means of online participation to obtain effective results, must, therefore, be explored. In subsequent chapters , we present three case studies of online support campaigning organizations: Avaaz in Brazil, Change.org in Argentina and YASunidos in Ecuador. Avaaz in Brazil and Change.org in Argentina are global organizations of foreign origin and have existed for a number of years. In these countries they have the largest number of followers (people who have signed at least one petition), in absolute numbers in the case of Brazil and relative to the size of the population in Argentina. YASunidos is an isolated experience related to a specific problem.
Democracy, Action, and the Internet after 9/11
American Behavioral Scientist, 2009
This study examines the role of the Internet in challenging the state after 9/11. Drawing on interview data with members of the Internet-based group MoveOn.org and participant observation data collected at MoveOn events, the authors argue that the Internet provides citizens an opportunity to lodge democratic challenges against the state during hostile political climates. There are at least three features of the Internet that make it a useful tool for challengers after political shocks such as 9/11: (a) it provides a free space for challengers to form oppositional points of view away from dominant groups; (b) it allows individuals to participate anonymously and, thus, buffers challengers from the high costs of activism; and (c) it moves challenges from the virtual to the real world by engaging citizens in intermediary forms of activism. In short, the Internet engages individuals in a broader range of activities-and this has important implications for democratic processes.
The latter half of the twentieth century witnessed an upsurge in mobilization and collective action by a wide range of activists and groups engaging in social and political protest, all over the world, which continues to this day. New media are not only greatly facilitating the ways in which activists communicate and protest, but are also altering the relation of the movements to territorial boundaries and localities. Scholars from a wide range of disciplines have tended to focus on questions about the internet's role in protest, without attempting to answer the changing meaning of what it means to be a citizen within such movements and through their practices. This article responds to this need by developing an analytical framework for studying the connection between citizenship and ICT-mediated social movements, drawing on existing scholarship on social movements, citizenship and ICTs. Specifically, using citizenship studies as a starting point, it brings together elements that are necessary for a two-level analysis: a) the tangible aspects that are seen as the concrete practices of movements and their participants and b) the ideational aspects that are seen as the abstract practices of movements and their participants. This provides a theoretical structure that facilitates connections between different disciplines that might otherwise be difficult to discern, so that the construction of citizenship can be studied on an interdisciplinary basis.
Cyber-Activism Within the Global Digital Divide
2014
The following thesis wants to explore if and to what extent cyber-activism is possible in a developing country such as Peru, in the context of the global digital divide. In order to do that, it will investigate Peruvians" perception of online activism; it will take into account recent cases of online activism from Peru; and it will put into discussion several concepts such as alternative media, the democratic divide and the global digital divide. The interest for this subject has emerged from my contact with news regarding the social movements taking place in Peru, in order to protect indigenous communities against resource depletion and exploitation. In order to conduct the research, I have used qualitative unobtrusive research methods such as media content analysis and netnography.
Parliamentary Affairs, 2006
This paper explores the importance of radical political uses of Information Communication Tecnologies (ICTs) over the last decade in Britain. Using examples from peace, social justice, environmental and anti-capitalist movements the moments of experimentation, innovation and creativity are documented. From these it is possible to identify several emerging trends: the importance of democratic tendencies, representation and image construction, the threat of increased surveillance, and the vital role ICTs play in building transnational networks of solidarity. The central argument of the paper is that ICTs have been used to facilitate what Mouffe has called a politics of dissensus, a celebration of difference rather than a quest for consensus.