Reframing Intersectionality in Critical Race Theory 30 Learning to Achieve: An intersectional analysis of black HE experiences (original) (raw)
Related papers
Polish Journal of Educational Studies
This paper explores the long-standing attainment gap between Black male students relative to other student populations, within Higher Education Institutions in the United Kingdom. This paper attempts to develop a contextual understanding of the parallel relationship between the social and academic culture at universities in the UK, as well as identifies the barriers which affect Black male students’ academic engagement. The purpose of this study is to answer the questions, “What is the Black male student experience at one university in the UK?” and “Which attitudes and practices at this university promote diversity and inclusivity and which hinder this?” The research was conducted via interview to gain a better understanding and acknowledgement of the multiple truths grounding this subject matter (Jones, 2015). The main participants were four Black male undergraduate home students, and four White academic staff members, at a University in the United Kingdom. This paper concludes by ...
2021
The coronavirus outbreak disproportionately affected ethnically minoritised groups in the UK and US. This health crisis coincided with mass Black Lives Matter (BLM) protests in response to the killing of unarmed African Americans by the police. Both event series brought awareness to the impact of racial inequality, systemic oppression and raised further questions about the treatment of minorities within the minority such as women of colour. Comparatively, the UK has a growing body of research that explores the role of systemic factors in the disproportionate exclusion rates for Caribbean boys and students with SEND. Adapting key Intersectionality Theory concepts, Dis/ability Critical Race Studies explore the intersections of race and ability to platform those whose experience may otherwise be invalidated and/or under-researched. This study aims to gain insights into students who experiences intersect of their race, ethnicity and ability in Further Education (FE). The study recruited...
The Black Student Experience in Higher Education
This paper is based on a talk given at an event at St Ann’s College, Oxford University and is focussed on the question of 'Race Equality in HE. Specifically, the paper examined the historical exclusion of black people and higher education and also the experiences of those that, especially in more recent times, have managed to enter the system.
ICERI2022 Proceedings
HE (Higher education) has the potential to break intergenerational poverty by bringing about social mobility and justice, thereby transforming the lives of many from disadvantaged backgrounds. In recent years, considerable progress has been made to widen the participation of black students in the UK HE sectors. It has been observed that candidates from black and minority ethnic groups go to university in good numbers, but they don’t achieve as well as their white counterparts. In the past few years alone, the Covid-19 pandemic and the Black Lives Matter movement have shone a stark light on the racial inequalities that exist throughout all sections of UK society, including within HE. Key obstacles remain to building on and sustaining the progress that has been made, ensuring the participation and success of deprived groups and delivering fair access. These groups experience a higher risk of poverty, social exclusion, discrimination, and violence than the general population and their constant struggle to secure top positions in the UK economy. In this study, IPA (Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis) has been used to explore the holistic experiences of students of African descent attending a post-1992 University in England through the lenses of Critical Race Theory (CRT) and Pierre Bourdieu’s tools. We evaluated their challenges and coping strategies to survive in largely white-dominated spaces. Findings reveal that students met a combination of psychological, academic, and financial difficulties relating to anxieties of adjusting to a new culture for international students, language difficulties, new ways of learning and assessment, and having to work alongside their studies. Moreover, substantial inequalities persist throughout their student lifecycle, exposing systemic discrimination and broader campus political, cultural, and social realities.
Within Higher Education, a substantial amount of research has explored black students’ experiences within post 1992 universities (Elevation Networks 2012; BITC 2010; RfO 2011; Leathwood 2004; Read et al. 2003). Research indicates that British African Caribbean men (BACM) are well represented in higher education (Richardson 2010). However, when the type of universities these students attend is examined, research indicates that substantially more black students attend post-1992 universities than ‘old universities’ (Bhattacharyya et al. 2003; Elevation Networks 2012). In 2010 less than one per cent of all Oxbridge students were black. Between 2010 and 2012 less than five per cent of all students entering Russell Group and Oxbridge universities were British African Caribbean (Boliver 2013). Only limited research has explored the outcomes of ethnic minority students studying at Russell Group universities (Fielding 2008; Richardson 2008) and much of this has been quantitative rather than qualitative. Furthermore, minimal research has explored the experiences of black students and black men in particular through their experiences of attending elite UK universities. This dissertation explores the counter-narratives of the few British African Caribbean men who have successfully attended and graduated from elite universities in England and Wales. This research examines these students’ recognised as well as unrecognised, resources and capitals to gain an understanding of the factors that have assisted them in their matriculation to, and graduation from, elite universities. It is hoped that these findings will be beneficial in helping staff involved in the admission processes at elite universities to gain a better understanding of areas that need improvement in order to increase the numbers of British African Caribbean male students attending elite universities. Lastly, this research hopes its findings will be beneficial in influencing more black men in future generations to aspire to attend elite UK institutions.
2014
For the last 40 years the number of international students aspiring to obtain a qualification in UK universities has been exponentially growing. However, such growth has been contested. What seemed to be a ‘golden’ opportunity for Black-African students to pursue their education in the UK is met with challenges that impact on the whole process of adjustment. This article examines these challenges using a qualitative empirical study of Black-African postgraduate students, carried out in three UK universities. The methods utilised were observations, focus groups, one-to-one interviews and a case study to help identify and analyse the issues. The participants reported significant financial pressures and difficulties in understanding and integrating into the culture of UK universities. In some cases these challenges left the students feeling disillusioned and cynical about the value of an international education. Universities must endeavour to tailor their recruitment, orientation and s...
2020
This thesis examines the lived experiences of Black women academics in South African universities, focusing on a case study from the University of Cape Town (UCT). Since the end of apartheid, scholars have questioned the disconnect between the goals and objectives of transformation strategies and the continued experiences of marginalization and oppression that Black women face. This study adds to this critical analysis by seeking to understand the main challenges that Black women experience in their careers and to assess how they view the transformation agenda, more commonly known outside of South Africa as equity, diversity and inclusion (EDI) initiatives. This thesis adopts an intersectional lens to study the experience of Black women, drawing on critical race theory and Black feminist thought. The analysis is based on semi-structured interviews with 10 Black women academics. Using the method of discourse analysis, I identify six common themes: experiences as a student, the strengths and limits of UCT's transformation agenda, stories of everyday racism experienced as a faculty member, identity as resilience, building communities of mutual support, and the effects of other forms of discrimination (e.g. age, citizenship and sexuality). This thesis argues that while there is evidence that the transformation agenda has been somewhat successful with respect to equity and diversity, efforts remain inadequate to reorder the deeply rooted structures of oppression and the diverse challenges faced by Black women. In particular, the third element of EDI initiatives-'inclusion'-remains a work-in-progress. Black women academics perceive that dominant institutional culture and norms prevent them from participating fully in spaces of higher education. v vi Definitions: BAC-Black Academic Caucusa platform at the University of Cape Town that prioritizes the challenges of black academics and students and advocates for diversity and inclusivity within the university. Black womana term used to describe the cultural identity and race of a woman. Used to describe a woman with African ancestral background. This study is not about non-binary individuals; all women interviewed are assumed to be cis-gendered. Double employmenta term used by interviewees to define the experience of being not only being a lecturer/professor but also having to take on the role of being a supervisor and the unspoken responsibilities of being a mentor or parent for students and the ones to be the diversity representative EDI-Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Equity-seeking groupsthose that experience marginalization and significant challenges in participating in society based on identifiers such as race, gender, age, disability, sexual orientation, class, etc. Participationthe act of accessing the academic space and being actively involved, taking part in, and included in the activities and practices of that space. Different from inclusion. Racedescribed as constructed ideology, beliefs and meaning attributed to the biological determinants of a person (Henry et al, 2018). Winant (1994, p.56) argues that the term is both based on "social structure and cultural representation."
2019
This thesis aims to address a paucity in the literature of the experiences of 'home' Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) students in postgraduate (PG) education in England, with a particular focus on Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM). This is done by (1) identifying institutional barriers to access to and progression through PG study, including the role of Widening Participation (WP) policy and (2) the factors facilitating educational success of BME students. This thesis uses a multi-faceted framework of intersectionality (Crenshaw, 1991), Critical Race Theory (CRT) (Gillborn, 2008), Bourdieusian thinking tools (Bourdieu 1997) and Yosso's (2005) community cultural wealth (CCW) capitals (aspirational, linguistic, social, navigational, familial and resistant). It argues for the addition of what is theorised as perspective capital to the CCW framework, which can be seen as a resource that allows people of colour to make contributions to the field, stemming...
An Investigation into African-Caribbean Academic Success in the UK
Race Ethnicity and Education, 2002
While, there is a history of academic under-achievement among African-Caribbeans in the United Kingdom, some African-Caribbeans progress successfully through under-graduate and on to postgraduate studies. This research investigates the factors contributing to such academic success.