PALEOCOMMUNITY AND EVOLUTIONARY ECOLOGY OF PALEOZOIC CRINOIDS (original) (raw)
Related papers
Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 2019
Integrating phylogenetic biology with paleoecology can provide a valuable context for understanding patterns of community structure and niche partitioning in ancient ecosystems. However, the lack of robust phylogenies for many fossil taxa precludes studies of this nature, particularly among marine invertebrates. Fossil Crinoidea (Echinodermata) comprise an ideal model system for phylogenetic community paleoecology for three reasons: (1) they preserve anatomical features that directly relate to feeding ecology, (2) assemblages of well-preserved specimens represent “ecological snapshots” in time, and (3) recent advances in resolving the crinoid tree of life have produced high-resolution phylogenies for Ordovician lineages. Here, we apply multivariate and phylogenetic comparative methods to investigate patterns of paleocommunity structure, niche partitioning, and ecomorphospace occupation in one of the earliest known complex crinoid paleocommunities, the Brechin Lagerstätte (Upper Ordovician, Katian). Results indicate niche differences among species were determined primarily by characters related to filtration fan morphology. Filtration fan density and body size distributions support phylogenetic niche conservatism, but traits related to the size of the feeding area are more labile and exhibit greater divergence than expected among closely related species. Finally, we compare changes in the shape and phylogenetic structure of niche distributions between the Brechin Lagerstätte and the Edwardsville crinoid fauna, a well-studied Mississippian (Viséan) paleocommunity, to examine patterns of community change across the Early to Middle Paleozoic Crinoid Macroevolutionary Faunas.
Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology, 2019
Integrating phylogenetic biology with paleoecology can provide a valuable context for understanding patterns of community structure and niche partitioning in ancient ecosystems. However, the lack of robust phylogenies for many fossil taxa precludes studies of this nature, particularly among marine invertebrates. Fossil Crinoidea (Echinodermata) comprise an ideal model system for phylogenetic community paleoecology for three reasons: (1) they preserve anatomical features that directly relate to feeding ecology, (2) assemblages of wellpreserved specimens represent "ecological snapshots" in time, and (3) recent advances in resolving the crinoid tree of life has produced high-resolution phylogenies for Ordovician lineages. Here, we apply multivariate and phylogenetic comparative methods to investigate patterns of paleocommunity structure, niche partitioning, and ecomorphospace occupation in one of the earliest known complex crinoid paleocommunities, the Brechin Lagerstätte (Upper Ordovician, Katian). Results indicate niche differences among species were determined primarily by characters related to filtration fan morphology. Filtration fan density and body size distributions support phylogenetic niche conservatism, but traits related to the size of feeding area are more labile and exhibit greater divergence than expected among closely related species. Finally, we compare changes in the shape and phylogenetic structure of niche distributions between the Brechin Lagerstätte and the Edwardsville crinoid fauna, a well-studied Mississippian (Viséan) paleocommunity, to examine patterns of community change across the Early to Middle Paleozoic Crinoid Macroevolutionary Faunas.
—Studies of crinoid morphology have been pivotal in understanding the constraints on the range of morphology within a clade as well as the patterns of disparity throughout the Phanerozoic. Newly discovered and described faunas and recent study of early Paleozoic crinoid diversity provide an ideal opportunity to reanalyze Ordovician through Early Silurian crinoid disparity with more complete taxonomic coverage and finer stratigraphic resolution. Using the coarse stratigraphic binning of Foote (1999), the updated morphologic data set has a similar disparity pattern to those previously reported for the early Paleozoic. However, with the more resolved stratigraphic binning used by Peters and Ausich (2008), a significant difference exists between the original and current data sets. Both data sets have a pronounced disparity high during the late Middle Ordovician. However, the updated disparity curve has a much higher initial disparity during the Early Ordovician and a pronounced rise in disparity during the Silurian recovery. Examination of differential sampling, proportions of the crinoid orders through time, and methods of coding characters indicate these factors have little effect on the pattern of crinoid disparity. The Silurian morphospace expansion occurs primarily within disparids and coincides with the origination of the myelodactylids. These findings corroborate the rapid expansion of morphospace during the Ordovician. However, crinoid disparity did not remain static and, although less frequent than during the initial radiation, new body plans evolved following the Ordovician Extinction (e.g., the myelodactylids). These results are consistent with the hypothesis of ecology constraining the limits on morphologic disparity at the class level.
Paleobiology of the oldest known articulate crinoid
Lethaia, 1992
The evolutionary and ecological recovery of benthic marine invertebrate faunas from the devastating Permian-Triassic mass extinction is poorly understood. In particular. Paleozoic crinoids were decimated, creating an evolutionary bottleneck, so that Early Triassic (Scythian) and Anisian representatives of the genus Ho/ocrinus may be considered the stem group for the monophyletic crinoid subclass Articulata, which includes all post-Paleozoic crinoids. Crinoid ossicles in limestones of the Scythian (Spathian) Virgin Limestone Member (Moenkopi Formation) of southern Nevada and southwestern Utah. identified as Holocrinus? smithi, respresent the oldest known Holocrinus. Limestone units of the virgin were deposited in nearshore and inner shelf environments of an arid epeiric seaway. Although these crinoids are generally completely disarticulated and occur commonly in storm-generated deposits. they are interpreted to have been deposited near their living sites in 'disturbed neighborhood' assemblages. Counts of ossicles in bulk samples indicate a relatively low number of individuals, suggesting that populations of H.? smithi occurred in scattered clumps or as isolated individuals. attached to hardgrounds or shell beds. Bivalves are the most common associates, and are commonly more numerous than the estimated number of crinoid individuals, although bivalve species richness is never greater than three. Virgin Limestone fossil assemblages probably represent the first redevelopment of relatively complex tiered epifiaunal communities in the Mesozoic.
The end-Katian (Late Ordovician) crinoid mass extinction triggered the change from the Early to the Middle Pa-leozoic crinoid evolutionary faunas (CEFs). This was a change from diplobathrid camerate-disparid-hybocrinid dominated faunas to faunas dominated by monobathrid camerate, cladid, and flexible crinoids. All clades suffered extinctions at the end-Katian event, but diplobathrid camerates, disparids, and hybocrinids suffered higher rates of extinction. The primary amount of diversification occurred in clades that would become dominant during the Silurian. However, the formation of the characteristic Middle Paleozoic CEF was protracted beyond the Late Ordovician extinction event. Monobathrid camerates and flexibles diversified through the Llandovery, but both dendrocrinid and cyathocrinid cladids did not diversify until later. Monobathrid camerate genera and families diversified, the flexible diversification was largely at the genus level, cyathocrine diversification was largely among families, and dendrocrinids did not diversify significantly until after the Llandovery. Overall disparity decreased during the end-Katian extinction by reducing the disparity within each clade. Disparity remained fairly constant during the Hirnantian but increased significantly during the Llandovery by both increasing disparity within clades and expanding the morphospace of the disparids due to the radiation of families with new morphologies. North America was the biogeographic center of origination for the families that survived to become dominant Silurian clades.
Crocodylian diversity peak and extinction in the late Cenozoic of the northern Neotropics
Nature Communications, 2013
are today's hotspots of crocodylian diversity with up to six (mainly alligatorid) and four (mainly crocodylid) living species respectively, of which usually no more than two or three occur sympatrically. In contrast, during the late Miocene, 14 species existed in South America. Here we show a diversity peak in sympatric occurrence of at least seven species, based on detailed stratigraphic sequence sampling and correlation, involving four geological formations from the middle Miocene to the Pliocene, and on the discovery of two new species and a new occurrence. This degree of crocodylian sympatry is unique in the world and shows that at least several members of Alligatoroidea and Gavialoidea coexisted. By the Pliocene, all these species became extinct, and their extinction was probably related to hydrographic changes linked to the Andean uplift. The extant fauna is first recorded with the oldest Crocodylus species from South America.
A revised macroevolutionary history for Ordovician–Early Silurian crinoids
Paleobiology, 2005
Much of what is known about the long-term history of biodiversity and rates of taxonomic evolution in the fossil record derives from literature-based compilations of fossil stratigraphic ranges. It has been suggested that taxonomic and stratigraphic errors in these compilations are randomly distributed and, therefore, introduce no significant bias to macroevolutionary patterns. Here we compare a new, comprehensive global database of Ordovician and Early Silurian crinoids to Sepkoski's global genus compendium. Approximately 44% of the crinoid genera resolved to substage in Sepkoski's compendium are taxonomically inaccurate (i.e., invalid, nomina dubia, or column genera) or have incorrect first and/ or last occurrences. Errors in Sepkoski's compendium result from incomplete coverage of existing taxonomic work and incorrect stratigraphic correlations that, in some cases, are propagated throughout the taxonomic literature. Stratigraphic range errors are nonrandomly distributed among substages in Sepkoski's compendium. The result is underestimated richness in the Early Silurian and significantly overestimated rates of extinction in the Late Ordovician. There is no similar bias in Sepkoski's substage origination rates for crinoids. At the stage-level of temporal resolution, Sepkoski's crinoid data are more accurate. In this case, only 32% of the compendium's crinoid genera contain some stratigraphic or taxonomic inaccuracy. However, errors still result in incorrect macroevolutionary patterns, particularly with respect to rate of origination in the Ashgill, which is significantly underestimated in Sepkoski's compendium. Genera described since the completion of Sepkoski's compendium have had relatively little effect on estimated rates of evolution at both stage and substage resolution. These results suggest that macroevolutionary patterns among some taxa in Sepkoski's compilation may be significantly influenced by nonrandomly distributed taxonomic inaccuracies and stratigraphic range errors. In the case of the apparent end-Ordovician mass extinction among crinoids, the revised history reveals a dramatically reduced role for extinction at the substage-level of temporal resolution. At the stage level, Sepkoski's original compilation strongly exaggerates the excess of extinction over origination in the Ashgill. Although biases inherent in the stratigraphic record remain unaccounted for, removing taxonomic and stratigraphic errors in Sepkoski's compendium substantially changes our understanding of the nature of large-scale biotic change for an important Paleozoic taxon during the end-Ordovician.
Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology, 1997
Filtration models make several predictions concerning the distribution of crinoids among benthic habitats: (1) generally, higher energy shoreward settings should contain crinoid assemblages dominated by taxa with dense mesh filtration fans; (2) generally, lower energy offshore settings should be dominated by crinoids with open mesh filtration fans; (3) diversity should be highest in nearshore settings, which generally contain low energy microhabitats within high energy settings where both dense fan and open fan forms can co-occur, whereas offshore assemblages should be dominated by open fan taxa; thus, open fan forms should be more eurytopic than dense fan forms. Also, previous empirical models for crinoid distribution patterns note that nearshore assemblages are dominated by large forms whereas offshore assemblages are dominated by small forms. Filtration fan morphology and body size interact significantly to determine how and where crinoids feed and thus are used here as criteria for distinguishing late Paleozoic crinoid guilds. The distribution patterns of crinoid taxa and guilds among the benthic paleocnvironments of the Upper Pennsylvanian (Missourian) Stanton Formation were used to test the predictions of the filtration models.
Substrate type and palaeodepth do not affect the Middle Jurassic taxonomic diversity of crinoids
PeerJ, 2021
Crinoids are largely considered as good indicators for determining environmental conditions. They are robust proxies for inferring changes in salinity and sedimentation rate and for inferring substrate type. Some crinoid groups (e.g., certain comatulids, cyrtocrinids, millericrinids) have a depth preference, thus, making them useful for palaeodepth estimation. The hypotheses that crinoid distribution is substratedependent (rock type) or palaeodepth-dependent is tested here based on (a) archival Bathonian-Callovian (Middle Jurassic) crinoid occurrences from Poland and (b) newer finds from five boreholes from eastern Poland. Qualitative data suggests that isocrinids and cyclocrinids occur in both carbonate and siliciclastic rocks. The cyrtocrinids and roveacrinids occur within carbonate rocks, whereas the comatulids are exclusive to siliciclastics. In terms of palaeodepth, most crinoid groups dominate in shallow environments with the sole exception of cyrtocrinids, that are ubiquitous and occur in both shallow (near shore and shallow marine) and slightly deeper (deeper sublittoral to open shelf) settings. The occurrences of the cosmopolitan taxa, Chariocrinus andreae and Balanocrinus subteres (isocrinids), is independent of both substrate type and palaeodepth. Quantitative analyses (Analysis Of Variance; ANOVA) based on substrate type, i.e., substrate-dependency (claystones, sandstones and limestones), and palaeodepth i.e., palaeodepth-dependency (near shore, shallow-marine, midramp and offshore), corroborate qualitative results. Statistical analysis suggest that the distribution of crinoids shows a strong substrate-dependency but not for palaeodepth, although very weak significance (low p value) is noted for near shore and shallow marine settings and crinoid distribution.