Assessing construction innovation: theoretical and practical perspectives (original) (raw)
Innovation is key for productivity improvement and advancements in different sectors of the economy, including the construction sector. The criticism of the slow pace of innovation in construction industry may be unwarranted, considering the structure of the industry and nature of the construction business. The loosely coupled nature of firms, mostly Small and Medium Enterprises (SME's), delivering 'projects' through partial engagement, together with the distinction between the project innovation and firm innovation makes it difficult to extract innovations in a meaningful way. The problem also lies in conceptualising, defining, articulating and assessing innovation in construction. The literature is replete with research into construction innovation, however, there is limited research into understanding how innovation is perceived and narrated in practice. The paper aims to explore how innovation is assessed and narrated in construction, specifically analysing theory and practice perspectives. A theoretical model was constructed from a structured literature review illustrating existing discourse and narratives of construction innovation assessment. A qualitative analysis of 'Professional Excellence in Building' submission documents to the Australian Institute of Building was performed to identify the practice perspective of innovation. The findings suggest that internal organizational and process innovation account for the majority of improvements identified. Importantly a taxonomy of narrative is developed that articulates how the construction industry in Australia views industry innovation.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
Related papers
2009
The construction industry has often been considered a 'low innovation' sector. This research seeks to understand more deeply the manifestation of innovation at the construction workplace and raises questions as to whether there is really a dearth of innovative practices in construction. A series of 20 interviews were undertaken with manager and workers across a typical construction supply chain. The interviews were supplemented by participant observations in a single case organisation. The inquiry process sought the stakeholders' interpretation of what innovation meant for them in construction, and explored the implications 'innovation' had on practice. The findings revealed the existence of a (misguided) sense of orthodoxy in the way the extant literature defined the concept of innovation. Accepted measures of innovation mean very little for workers who have to deal with operational realities of making the construction project work. Managerial interviews have highlighted their tendency for offering idealised accounts of what innovation means to the business and how innovation works. Conversely, the differing explanations by the workers show a distinct lack of recognition and reward for innovative practices in the industry. This research makes the case for a need to broaden the way innovation is conceptualised and measured.
An Analysis of Construction Innovation Literature
2005
The importance of innovation in construction has been widely advanced. This paper analyses the most recent research in the field of construction innovation and offers an overview of what and how aspects of innovation have been studied in different construction contexts. Peer-reviewed journal articles from the last decade are coded and analysed to reveal the construction focus, innovation fundamentals and prominent research features of the literature. A research agenda based on the findings of the analysis and the future research suggestions of the journal articles reviewed is presented to extend and enhance construction innovation research.
The recent debate on innovation within an organizational setting has shifted focus toward discussing whether innovation is being adopted or being created. This shift is due to the failure of many innovation efforts and the fact that for each innovation creation or innovation adoption, different skills, resources, and cultures are needed to encourage each innovation. The objective of this article is to explore the type of innovation implemented by the construction participants. A conceptual model of innovation creation and innovation adoption was developed using four criteria: by justification of new ideas, by purposes, by activities involved, and by nature. Face-to-face questionnaires were conducted with developers, consulting firms, and contractors in Penang, Malaysia. The data were analyzed using descriptive analysis. Factor analysis was used to classify the innovation creation and innovation adoption. The results show that the construction participants in Malaysia are categorized as an innovation adopter. This result provides better understanding about the type of innovation implemented by the construction participants, in particular the contractors and the consulting firms. The results could also be used as a foundation for conducting future research to identify appropriate skills, knowledge, culture, and resources for such innovations.
Innovation in Construction: A Critical Review and Future Research
The construction industry has been recognized for its conservatism and lack of innovation. In order to improve the success rate of construction innovation, the implementation of innovations within the context of construction has been discussed and developed. Literature in this area focuses extensively on construction innovation, and yet does not contain a systematic review. This paper looks to fill this gap by providing a systematic review of construction innovation. The review synthesizes the conclusions and shows the implementation of construction innovation. Collaboration, culture, innovation process, and drivers are identified as critical factors to improve the performance of construction innovation. Finally, the limitations of prior studies in construction innovation are discussed and recommendations made for areas of future study.
Projecting Change through Construction Innovation
Summary In projecting change for the critical Australian construction industry, the CRC for Construction Innovation envisions a culture of self improvement through applied research and technology transfer. Construction Innovation is driving research outcomes into business practice in areas such as innovativeness, sustainability, procurement, project diagnostics and site safety. The group has also led the formation of an international alliance to ensure its activities are hitting the mark nationally and internationally. Through initiatives like these, the CRC for Construction Innovation is already providing a potent vehicle for change. This paper will briefly track the development of the CRC for Construction Innovation and highlight the collaborative processes in developing, managing and disseminating applied research; profile a number of its key outcomes to date; and discuss the future of applied research in Australia in the context of its Construction 2020 national initiative, its ...
Influences on innovation in small Australian construction businesses
Journal of Small Business and Enterprise …, 2010
Purpose -The purpose of this paper is to identify the major influences on innovation delivery in the context of small Australian construction businesses. Design/methodology/approach -An analysis was undertaken of peer-reviewed journal articles published between 1998 and 2008. Historical background to the current circumstances was included by reference to influential government reports and to literature on the economic theory underpinning the concept of innovation. Findings -The findings suggest that despite the recent trend to more cooperative business arrangements, the ingrained culture of aggressively competitive relations on a building project remains in place. This is particularly evident at the small and sub-contractor level. Such companies tend to operate with little spare capacity and can be restricted from participation in the benefits of the innovation strategies unless they receive outside assistance.
Construction innovation: a literature review on current research
2006
ABSTRACT: Innovation in construction is a subject being discussed during a considerable period of time. However current research and statistical data shows that construction is lagging behind other sectors in the aspects of productivity and efficiency for which lack of innovation is blamed. This paper is an effort to illustrate present status of construction innovation research and perceptions of researchers and practitioners based on a review of current literature.
A Review of Methods of Measuring Construction Innovation: a UK Perspective
2019
Innovation is a specific process to exploit change as an opportunity and is consistently found to be associated with organisational success In particular, the construction industry is widely perceived as being among the less innovative sectors, in part due to its project-based and fragmented nature This thesis will address a gap in the knowledge to which organizations systems measure the success of innovation projects and review which projects to select to realise value. The research is positioned in the wider context of the corporate objectives and principally asset management programmes of work. Following an initial review of innovation project selection systems, a set of research questions will be developed to investigate the potential for a new benchmark solely focused on Innovation Potential. It will deliver an original contribution to knowledge by developing an empirically validated conceptual model that consists of the main factors that have an influence, and are influenced b...
Demonstrating the benefits of construction innovation
2005
The construction industry needs to achieve greater efficiency and effectiveness. However, change is not readily embraced by the industry. This resistance to change compromises innovation performance, and negatively impacts client and industry goals. One of the key reasons for relatively poor construction industry performance is scepticism about the potential benefits of innovation, particularly among small and medium-sized businesses. This paper investigates the links between innovation and project performance, with a view to demonstrating the benefits that can be achieved. It offers case study evidence of the tangible, monetary benefits of innovation to businesses. The paper is based on innovation case studies in the Australian construction industry undertaken in 2003. It concludes with a discussion of the distribution of innovation benefits and the impact on incentive structures. In future research the results will be interpreted more widely, by undertaking a comprehensive integrative analysis of existing academic literature on construction innovation benefits.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.