Dursun-Ozkanca, Oya. "Turkey and the European Union: Strategic Partners or Competitors in the Western Balkans." Journal of Regional Security 11:1 (2016): 33-54. (original) (raw)
Related papers
Turkey and the European Union: Strategic Partners or Competitors in the Western Balkans?
2016
Since the 1990s, Turkey and the European Union (EU) have each increasingly pursued active foreign policies in the Western Balkans, aimed at establishing peace, stability, and security in the region. Over the past few years, Turkey's active foreign policy approach has been frequently labelled as 'Neo-Ottomanism'. Against this backdrop of deteriorating relations between the EU and Turkey, Turkey has been attempting to use its soft power potential to consolidate its political, economic, and cultural influence in the Western Balkans. The article explores the factors contributing to and hindering Turkish influence in the region. It then analyzes factors behind Turkey's renewed activism within the context of recent developments in EU-Turkey relations. Drawing on an extensive series of elite interviews conducted in Turkey, the United Kingdom, Serbia, and Bosnia from 2011 to 2013, the article concludes with an examination of whether Turkey and the EU may best be regarded as ...
Turkey and the EU: Partners or Competitors in the Western Balkans?
Southeast Europe in Focus, Südosteuropa-Gesellschaft, 2020
The article analyzes EU-Turkey relations in the Western Balkans (WB) in an attempt to uncover the cooperation and conflict potential between the two in the region. Specifically, it assesses the extent to which Turkey can be considered a partner of the EU versus representing a competitor or even an alternative to Brussels for the WB countries. It argues that positing Turkey as a proactive, alternative regional power seeking to expand its presence and influence in the region at the EU’s expense are overstated. Despite the EU’s damaged credibility in the pursuit of its enlargement policy, Turkey’s capabilities, incentives and foreign policy priorities simply fall short of producing a competitive “Turkish model/alternative” in the region. First, there are practical limits to Turkey’s regional power status, which is far from representing a realistic substitute for the WB countries’ Euro-Atlantic ties. In addition, despite the difficulties ahead, these countries still aspire for integration into European structures, which is also aligned with Turkey’s foreign policy interests. Second, limitations aside, gaining hegemony in the WB is not Ankara’s foreign policy priority given the urgency of multiple policy issues waiting to be tackled on all fronts. Third, from a Realpolitik standpoint, Turkey and the EU are expected to constructively engage to find solutions for common challenges such as migration, which concerns the WB as well.
Is Turkey a Rival to the European Union? Neo- Ottoman Influence in the Balkans
Claremont-UC Undergraduate Research Conference on the European Union, 2019
Turkey, under Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s presidency, has begun to re-animate some aspects of its predecessor, the Ottoman Empire. Many observers of Turkey speak of “Neo- Ottomanism,” both at home and in its foreign policy. With respect to the latter, aspects of neo-Ottomanism are very evident with Turkey’s engagement in the Balkans. As European Union (EU) accession seems more and more unlikely for Turkey, one might wonder if Turkish actions in the Balkans can be seen as trying to rival the EU for influence. This pa- per thus seeks to answer two questions. First, what factors are motivating Turkish foreign policy, and does Turkey’s neo-Ottoman influence in the Balkans make it a competitor or a partner to the EU? This paper will look at Turkish policies in the Balkan region, focusing particularly on Bosnia and Moldova, and analyze whether its growing influence is making it a competitor to the EU.
Journal of Balkan Research Institute, 2019
The EU, which is commonly referred as a soft power, is facing various challenges that limit its effectiveness in the international scene, most importantly in the Western Balkans. The transformative capacity of its soft power is not properly utilized in this region. This article explores the challenges to the EU’s soft power and evaluates possible ways for the Union to maintain its effectiveness adding new dimensions to its foreign policy in the area–specifically in the Western Balkans region. The primary issue addressed by this article deals with the immediate changes facing the EU as a soft power today. Given the fact that political mechanisms that EU utilized have proved to be ineffective in promoting stability, democracy peace in its area, alternatives should be considered. Meanwhile, a decade ago Turkey has proven its capacity to influence Western Balkan countries by creating and consolidating its soft power through various ways. However under the most present circumstances an economically weak Turkey is nothing but an actor which attempts to strengthen its relationship with Western Balkans countries.
Turkey in its quest for more power over Balkans
Polis
Turkey is currently a major player in the Balkans, as it is continuously trying to expand its sphere of influence. As part of its foreign policy strategy, Turkey is developing common interests in the region. European Union has changed its policy toward Turkey and, at the same time, Turkey constantly challenges Europe. As history tells us, Balkans have been battleground for clashes of different powers. Turkey is increasing becoming a powerful actor that has to be taken into consideration, even though in the Balkan area it is showing certain limits. The qualitative method is used in the study, referring to secondary data, as it relies on various critical journals entailing Turkish politics, foreign policy and international relations. The study focuses on two main areas: economic relationships and religious influence, through which Turkey is trying to project power into the Balkans. The paper tries to test the hypothesis that economic struggles and Balkans orientation toward European U...
Reconsidering Dilemmas of Turkey's Foreign Policy: The Case of the Balkans Summary
Südosteuropa Mitteilungen, 2019
Turkey has started to play a more active role in the Balkans since the early 1990s because of changes in both local agency and global structure. After coming to power in 2002, the Justice and Development Party AKP added further impetus to Turkish foreign policy towards the region by putting forward new actors and bringing in new issues. Business representatives, the Turkish Cooperation and Coordination Agency TİKA, Yunus Emre Cultural Centers, the Presidency for Turks Abroad and Related Communities, Diyanet, and Turkish cities have become new actors in Turkey’s ties with the region. The article examines changes and continuities in Turkish foreign policy towards the Balkans under the government of the AKP. It first analyses the dilemmas of Turkey’s regional policies based on a case study of the Kosovo conflict and then examines the connection between domestic and foreign policy, thereby evaluating new actors and issues. The paper argues that there are challenges ahead and limitations to Turkey’s appeal to the region, resulting from the tilt towards unilateral policies.
Political Influence in Southeast Europe in Current Turkish Foreign Policy
SOUTHEAST EUROPE in Focus, 2020
The gradual weakening of the EU and US presence in the Balkans in recent years has created a power vacuum, which was used by other foreign actors to establish, or re-establish their appearances and influences in the volatile region. Turkey was one of those countries, which used its historical links with the region - especially with its Muslim population - to (re)establish itself as an important actor and power broker. Today, Turkey is perceived by Bosniaks and other Muslims in the Balkans in the way how Russia is perceived by Serbs and other Orthodox Christians in the region, that is a historic friend and important ally at the times of rising global tensions and uncertainty. Unlike Russia - which is almost exclusively linked with selected top Serb leaders - Turkey has from the very beginning established a much broader group of contacts in the region, which as of recently even includes top Serbian officials. Unlike Russia, Turkey has over the past two decades, expanded its operations in the Balkans to include numerous business, cultural, educational, academic and religious programs and projects. Yet just like Russia, all these Turkish efforts are made in this way to corroborate and strengthen Turkey's regional and global political presence. This background paper provides a brief historical overview of the main phases of Turkish domestic and corresponding foreign policies in the region, as well as basic details of Turkish relations with and operations in key Balkan countries.