Mutual Adaptation: Japanese Automobile Transplants in North America and the Restructuring of Buyer-Supplier Relations (original) (raw)

Abstract

This paper,examines,how,the arrival and expansion,of Japanese,automotive assemblers in North America during the 1980s and 1990s, has been character- ized by a complex,process of mutual adaptation by both the transplant assem- blers and North American suppliers. It argues that despite the arguments,that globalization is necessarily associated with a convergence,in supply-manage- ment practices, Japanese assemblers generally remain more committed to long-term supplier development ,and ,technical assistance and ,are less price focused than their North American counterparts. Nonetheless, I argue that a hybrid system,is emerging in which the Japanese have modified some,of their strategies to the more,adversarial and price oriented systems,which character- ize North America. The second ,half of the ,paper ,examines ,Canadian-based supplier relations with the transplants and ,concludes ,that despite the emer- gence of a core of large R&D intensive Canadian suppliers, most remain smaller an...

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (47)

  1. Abo, T. 1996. The Japanese Production System: The process of adaptation to national settings. In States Against Markets: the limits of globalization, R. Boyer and D. Drache, eds., London: Routledge, pp. 136-154.
  2. Anderson, M. and J. Holmes. 1995. High-skill, Low Wage Manufacturing in North America: A case Study from the Automotive Parts Industry. Regional Studies 29(7): 655-671.
  3. Automotive Parts Human Resources Study. 1991. Report of the Automotive Human Resources Study. Toronto: Government of Ontario. Automotive Parts Manufacturers Association. 1999. Canadian Parts Manufac- turers' Sales to Japanese Vehicle Assemblers. Toronto: Automotive Parts Manufacturers Association.
  4. Bowe, C. 2000. Warning of a bumpy road ahead: Supplier consolidation. Fi- nancial Times, Dec 8, 2000.
  5. Edgington, D. 1995. Japanese manufacturing companies in southern Ontario and NAFTA. InThe Location of Foreign Direct Investment: Geographic and Business Approaches. M. Green and R. McNaugton, eds., Aldershot: Avebury, pp. 85-106.
  6. Edgington, D. 1997. Flexibility and corporate organization in Chukyo, Japan: A study of five industries. Regional Development Studies 3(Winter): 83-108.
  7. Ennis, P. 1995. Canada Set For a Bigger Share of Auto Investment. Canada- Japan Trade Council Newsletter (January-February): 5-8.
  8. Florida, R. and M. Kenney. 1991. Organisation vs. culture: Japanese automo- tive transplants in the US. Industrial Relations Journal 22: 181-196.
  9. Fujita, K. and R.C.Hill. 1995. Global Toyotaism and Local Development. Inter- national Journal of Urban and Regional Research 19(1): 7-22.
  10. Gertler, M. 1997. Manufacturing culture In Geographies of Economies, E. Arnold, R. Lee and J. Wills, eds., London, pp. 47-58.
  11. Government of Ontario. 1997. Ontario: The Future's Right Here -North Ameri- ca's Automotive Powerhouse. Toronto: Queen's Printer.
  12. Grabher, G., ed. 1993. The embedded firm: On the socioeconomics of indus- trial networks. London: Routledge.
  13. Helper, S. 1993. Changing buyer-supplier relations in The US auto industry. In The embedded firm: On the socioeconomics of industrial networks. G. Grabher, ed., London: Routledge.
  14. Holmes, J. 1983. Industrial Reorganization, Capital Restructuring and Locational Change: An Analysis of the Canadian Automobile Industry in the 1960s. Economic Geography 59: 251-71.
  15. Holmes, J. 1992. The continental integration of the North American automobile industry: from the Auto Pact to the FTA and beyond. Environment and Plan- ning A 24: 95-119.
  16. Holmes, J. 1996. Restructuring in a Continental Production System. In Canada and the Global Economy: The Geography of Structural and Technological Change, J. Britton, ed., Montreal: McGill-Queens, pp. 230-254.
  17. Holmes, J. and K. Kumar. 2001. The Dynamics of Restructuring and Industrial Competition in the Automotive Parts Industry in Canada, presented at the Department for Labour Studies, Hamilton, Ontario: McMaster University, November 12, 2001.
  18. Industry Canada. 1996. Sector Competitiveness Frameworks: Automotive In- dustry, Part 1 -Overview and Prospects. Ottawa: Industry Canada. Industry Canada. 1998. The Automotive Competitiveness Review. Ottawa: In- dustry Canada.
  19. Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO). 1994. Report on the 6th Survey of Japanese-Affiliated Firms in Canada. Toronto: Japan External Trade Or- ganization, October.
  20. Keenan, G. 1996a. More auto industry turmoil in sight. The Globe and Mail, 13 June.
  21. Keenan, G. 1996b. Auto parts sales to Japanese soar. The Globe and Mail, 11 July.
  22. Keenan, G. 1998. CAW head talks union with Magna. The Globe and Mail, 15 August.
  23. Kenney, M. and R. Florida. 1993. Beyond Mass Production: The Japanese System and Its Transfer to the United States, New York: Oxford University Press.
  24. Kester, W.C. 1996. American and Japanese Corporate Governance: Conver- gence to Best Practice? In National Diversity and Global Capitalism, S. Berger and R. Dore, eds., Ithica: Cornell University Press, pp. 107-137.
  25. Lieberman, M. and S. Asaba. 1996. Inventory Reduction and Productivity Growth: A Comparison of Japanese and US Automotive Sectors. International Motor Vehicle Program (IMVP) Working Paper, Cambridge, MA: Massa- chusetts Institute of Technology.
  26. Lieberman, M.B., S. Helper and L. Demeester. 1996. The Empirical Determi- nants of Inventory Levels in High Volume Manufacturing. International Motor Vehicle Program (IMVP) Working Paper, Cambridge, MA: Massa- chusetts Institute of Technology.
  27. Lung, Y., M. Salerno, M. Zilbovicius and D.Carneiro. 1999. Flexibility through modularity: Experimentations with fractal production in Brazil and Europe In Coping with variety: Flexible Productive Systems for Product Variety in the Auto Industry, Y. Lung, J. Chanaron, T. Fujimoto and D. Raff, eds., Ashgate, Aldershot.
  28. Mair, A. 1997. Strategic Localization: The Myth of the Postnational Enterprise, in Spaces of Globalization: reasserting the power of the local, K. Cox ed., New York: Guilford, pp. 64-88.
  29. Mair, A., R. Florida and M. Kenney. 1988. The New Geography of Automobile Production: Japanese Transplants in North America. Economic Geogra- phy 64(4): 352-373.
  30. McAlinden, S. 2000. Modular systems: Where are the economic efficiencies in the modular assembly concept? Ann Arbor, MI: The University of Michigan, Office for the Study of Automotive Transportation.
  31. Mueller, F. and R. Loveridge. 1997. Institutional, sectoral and corporate dy- namics in the creation of global supply chains. In Governance at work: The social regulation of economic relations. R. Whitely and P. Kristensen, eds. Oxford University Press: Oxford, pp. 139-170.
  32. Ontario, Ministry of Treasury and Intergovernmental Affairs. 1991. Ontario Eco- nomic Outlook. Toronto.
  33. Paget Consulting Group. 1996. Capitalizing on the cirriculum: The viability and long term plan for Automotive Parts Sectoral Training Council. Paget Con- sulting Group, F.J. Durndan and Associates, Ottawa.
  34. Parker, P., T. Rutherford and T. Koshiba. 2000. New Directions in Canada's Japanese Owned Automobile Plants. In Japan after the Economic Miracle: In Search of New Directions, P. Bowles and L. T. Woods, eds., Lancaster, U.K.: Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 85-103.
  35. Pritchard, T. 1992. Canadian makers playing a bigger part. The Globe and Mail, 19 May 1992.
  36. Reid, N. 1995. Just-in-Time Inventory Control and the Economic Integration of Japanese-owned Manufacturing Plants with County, State and National Economies of the United States. Regional Studies 29(4): 345-355.
  37. Rutherford, T., P. Parker and T. Koshiba. 2001. Global, Local, or Hybrid?: Evi- dence of Adaptation among Japanese Automobile Plants in Japan, the United States and Canada. Environments, this volume.
  38. Sadler, D. 1994. The Geographies of Just-in-Time: Japanese Investment and the Automotive Components Industry in Western Europe. Economic Ge- ography 70(1): 41-59.
  39. Sako, M. 1992. Prices, Quality and Trust: Inter-firm Relations in Britain and Japan. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
  40. Science Council of Canada. 1992. Sectoral Technology Strategies Studies: No. 2, The Canadian Automotive Parts Sector. Ottawa, Ministry of Supply and Services.
  41. Simison, R., J. White, N. Shirouzu. 1999. Nissan's suppliers face big price cuts. Wall Street Journal 22 October.
  42. Shirouzu, N. 1999. Toyota tightening grip on key parts suppliers. Wall Street Journal, 3 August.
  43. Storper, M. 1997. The Regional World: Territorial Development in a Global Economy. London: Guilford.
  44. Tezuka, H. 1997. Success as the Source of Failure? Competition and Coopera- tion in the Japanese Economy. Sloan Management Review (Winter): 83- 93.
  45. U.S. Department of Commerce and the Office of the U.S. Trade Representa- tive. 1997. Report to President William Jefferson Clinton of the Interagency Enforcement Team regarding the U.S.-Japan Agreement on Autos and Auto Parts. Washington.
  46. Warrian, P. and C. Mulhern. 2001 The New (Economy) Steel: Learning at the Regional and Firms Levels. Presented at the conference of the Ontario Network on the Regional Innovation System held at Windermere Manor, London, Ontario, December 13-14 th 2001.
  47. Womack, J., D. Jones and D. Roos. 1990. The Machine That Changed The World. Toronto: Collier-Macmillan.