Knowledge-intensive collaborative decision support for design processes: A hybrid decision support model and agent (original) (raw)
Related papers
Customer-driven product design and evaluation method for collaborative design environments
2011
Product concept generation and evaluation in a product development environment has been identified as the two major activities needed for obtaining an optimal design scheme. Product conceptual design is of critical importance in design through customer involvement for the systematic and simultaneous consideration on the impact of design decisions on manufacturing and assembly leads to repeated and excessive changes in design and processes. This paper introduces a novel knowledge support approach for the organization and ranking of design feature knowledge towards an integrated product model that incorporates a feature-based representation scheme targeted to evaluate the impact of design on subsequent activities in the conceptual design phase, taking into account the presence of design information and user preferences. An uncertain linguistic multi-attribute decision-making evaluation model is proposed and discussed for obtaining an optimal design scheme during the evaluation and selection of product design alternatives in conceptual design. The focus of this paper is on the development of a knowledge-intensive support design scheme and a comprehensive systematic fuzzy evaluation methodology for product conceptual design generation, evaluation, and selection. A case study and the corresponding scenario of knowledge support for design alternatives generation, evaluation and selection are provided for illustration.
A Method for Interactive Decision-Making in Collaborative, Distributed Engineering Design
A decision support method is proposed for integrating distributed, collaborative design activities via mathematical coordination of the individual decisions of designers and other agents involved in the product realization process. This approach involves establishing a domain-independent decision model, expanding the scope of local decisions, and implementing a mathematical coordination mechanism based on game theory and approximate models of the information and strategies of designers. Using this approach, integration of computational models of design, manufacturing, and other portions of the product realization process into a single, large optimization problem is avoided, and the knowledge and expertise of each designer are fully utilized while keeping information transfer and computational requirements at a tractable level.
A Decision-making Help Tool in Innovative Product Design
Journal of Decision Systems, 2010
The aim of this article is to show how ergonomics allows the detailed specifications for a decision-making help tool in innovative product design to be produced. The first part describes the context, both industrial and scientific, of such a study. In part two, we will explore current knowledge and the theoretical models relating to design activity and the taking of design decisions. Part three describes the empirical study undertaken for the design of the 3D Child virtual reality tool. Having explained our methodology for the gathering and analysis of data, we set out the needs of future users in respect of the help with decisionmaking expected from the 3D Child software and finish with the collaborative aspect intrinsic in decision-making. In the next part we deal with the data available from published sources and that collected in the field. In conclusion we insist on the importance of validating these data in actual usage contexts, by setting out our approach to the work. 2 Journal of Decision Systems. Volume ? -No. ?/? RESUME. L'objectif de cet article est de montrer en quoi l'ergonomie permet de produire les spécifications détaillées d'un outil d'aide à la prise de décision en conception innovante de produits. La partie introductive dépeint le contexte aussi bien scientifique qu'industriel d'une telle étude. Dans la partie 2, nous explorons les connaissances actuelles et modèles théoriques relatifs à l'activité de conception et à la prise de décision en conception. La partie 3 relate l'étude empirique menée dans le cadre de la conception de l'outil de Réalité Virtuelle 3D Child. Après avoir expliqué nos méthodologies de recueil et d'analyse de données, nous exposons les besoins des futurs utilisateurs en ce qui concerne l'aide à la prise de décision attendue du logiciel 3D Child, en terminant par l'aspect collaboratif intrinsèque à la prise de décision. Dans la partie suivante, nous confrontons les données issues de la littérature et celles recueillies sur le terrain. En conclusion, nous insistons sur l'importance de valider ces données en contexte réel d'usage, en exposant nos perspectives de travail. KEYWORDS: innovative design, decision-making help tool, needs, ergonomic approach. MOTS-CLES: conception innovante, outil d'aide à la décision, besoins, approche ergonomique.
Collaborative Decision-Making in Product Design: An Interactive Multiobjective Approach
Journal of Industrial Engineering, 2013
This paper presents a new procedure to solve multiobjective problems, where the objectives are distributed to various working groups and the decision process is centralized. The approach is interactive and considers the preferences of the working groups. It is based on two techniques: an interactive technique that solves multi-objective problems based on goal programming, and a technique called “linear physical programming” which considers the preferences of the working groups. The approach generates Pareto-optimal solutions. It guides the director in the determination of target values for the objective functions. The approach was tested on two problems that present its capacity to generate Pareto-optimal solutions and to show the convergence to compromise solutions for all the working groups.
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2006
This paper presents a rule-based intelligent design reasoning approach to support dynamic collaborative design. The architecture of the design knowledge base intends to assist product R&D, facilitate design verification and integrate collaborative efforts among members of the design team, which may include suppliers and customers. To avoid the drawbacks of the traditional sequential product development pattern, which often ignores the requirements in downstream product development and lacks of collaborative integration methodology, a conceptual architecture of Intelligent Reasoning Collaborative Design Platform (IRCDP) is developed. Finally, a design case (i.e. the motor design) is used to demonstrate the knowledge-based reasoning platform at work.
International Journal of Product Lifecycle Management, 2006
Most of the time, the innovative product concept identification is based on strategic and complex processes. Design actors' individual initiatives and development of new ideas emerge from conflicting contexts combining the technical, economical and social aspects. In this paper, we propose a new approach that aims at assisting design product from the early phases of the design process to the embodiment design phase. We suggest a combination of Product Lifecycle Management (PLM) system and specific developed tools (Meta-modelling techniques, Numeric-CSP solver and 'Innovation Development and Diffusion' (ID 2 ) system) to enhance cultural heterogeneity encountered within the team project and to take advantage of this aspect to foster design innovation and product quality.
Using knowledge-based intelligent reasoning to support dynamic collaborative design
This paper presents a rule-based intelligent design reasoning approach to support dynamic collaborative design. The architecture of the design knowledge base intends to assist product R&D, facilitate design verification and integrate collaborative efforts among members of the design team, which may include suppliers and customers. To avoid the drawbacks of the traditional sequential product development pattern, which often ignores the requirements in downstream product development and lacks of collaborative integration methodology, a conceptual architecture of Intelligent Reasoning Collaborative Design Platform (IRCDP) is developed. Finally, a design case (i.e. the motor design) is used to demonstrate the knowledge-based reasoning platform at work.
Design for manufacturing: application of collaborative multidisciplinary decision-making methodology
Engineering Optimization, 2007
Design for manufacturing is often difficult for mechanical parts since significant manufacturing knowledge is required to adjust part designs for manufacturability. The traditional trial and error approach usually leads to expensive iterations and compromises the quality of the final design. The authors believe the appropriate way to handle product design for manufacturing problems is not to formulate a large design problem that exhaustively incorporates design and manufacturing issues, but to separate the design and manufacturing activities and provide support for collaboration between engineering teams. In this paper, the Collaborative Multidisciplinary Decision-making Methodology (CMDM) is used to solve a product design and manufacturing problem. First, the compromise Decision Support Problem is used as a mathematical model of each engineering teams' design decisions and as a medium for information exchange. Second, game theoretic principles are employed to resolve couplings or interactions between the teams' decisions. Third, design capability indices are used to maintain design freedom at the early stages of product realization in order to accommodate unexpected downstream design changes. A plastic robot arm design and manufacturing scenario is presented to demonstrate the application of this methodology and its effectiveness for solving a complex design for manufacturing problem in a streamlined manner, with minimal expensive iterations.
A Decision Support Ontology for collaborative decision making in engineering design
2009 International Symposium on Collaborative Technologies and Systems, 2009
Complex products and increasing domain specialization have led to a collaborative design environment in which multiple partners are relied upon to successfully realize a product. In such an environment there is a need for computational frameworks that assist in communicating decision making knowledge. In this research a Decision Support Ontology (DSO) is developed to facilitate decision making within collaborative design. The structure of the information model developed reflects a priori knowledge of decision making and supports the communication of information independent of any specific decision method. Accordingly, the DSO includes decision-related information such as the design issue, alternatives, evaluation, criteria and preferences. It also includes decision rationale and assumptions, as well as any constraints created by the decision and the decision outcome. The DSO is built upon the Web Ontology Language (OWL), which facilitates the sharing and integration of decision-making information between multiple collaborators via the Web and Description Logic. Although the information model developed is based on engineering design literature, the DSO captures generic decision information, and therefore could be adapted to be used beyond the engineering design domain.
A fuzzy configuration multi-agent approach for product family modelling in conceptual design
Journal of Intelligent Manufacturing, 2011
Product modelling is an essential issue in the configurable product design. Many attempts have been made for modelling the configurable products. However, most of conducted research considers the configurable product modelling as an arrangement problem of a predefined set of components into a valid product structure. This paper considers configuration not only as a structural problem but also as a collaborative design problem. Product configuration must consider explicitly different actors and their perspectives influencing simultaneously the design of configurable products. Solving product configuration problems requires collaboration of actors from multiple distributed views. Therefore, from process and product point of views, engineering design of configurable products can be assisted by multi-agents systems. Following up this consideration, this paper proposes a Fuzzy Configuration Grammar based agents to assist collaborative and distributed design for configuration. Based on the distributed fuzzy models, fuzziness of interactions during the collaborative and distributed design for configuration, a computational approach for product configuration is developed. Modelling and implementation of an agent-based system, called G-APIC (Grammars based Agents for Product Integrated Configuration), is presented.