Structure/process as ontology for critical systems thinking and practice (presentation, abstract) (original) (raw)
Related papers
An ontology for a critical systems paradigm
This research identifies and focuses on two intractable problems in contemporary systems thinking: 1) That the fracturing of the systems community is a reflection of the fact that the underlying body of systems theory is itself fragmented by incommensurable paradigms. 2) That mixed methods, although they offer a powerful potential for precision and effectiveness in systemic intervention, have no legitimate systems theory to guide their informed use and from which they can be derived.
What is a System? An Ontological Framework
Systems Engineering
Over the past decades, the definition of system has eluded researchers and practitioners. We reviewed over 100 definitions of system to understand the variations and establish a framework for a widely acceptable system definition or a family of system definitions. There is much common ground in different families of definitions of system, but there are also important and significant ontological differences. Some differences stem from the variety of belief systems and worldviews, while others have risen within particular communities. Both limit the effectiveness of system communities' efforts to communicate, collaborate, and learn from others' experience. We consider three ontological elements: (1) a worldview-based framework for typology of different system types and categories, (2) key system concepts that are fundamental to the various system types and categories, and (3) appropriate language for the target audience. In this work, we establish the ontological framework, list key concepts associated with different types of system, and point to a direction for agreeing on an integrated set of system definitions in a neutral language consistent with the framework. The definitions are compatible with both the realist and constructivist worldviews, covering real (physical, concrete) and conceptual (abstract, logical, informatical) systems, which are both human-made (artificial) and naturally-occurring, using language acceptable to a wide target stakeholder audience. The contribution of this paper is setting up an ontologically founded framework of system typologies, providing definitions for system, and identifying the issues involved in achieving a widely accepted definition or family of definitions of system.
2008
Systems analysis comprehends systems in terms of an ontology that relates any system, its elements, and its environment in terms of their functional, structural, and behavioral relations. At the heart of systems ontology is " design " , the combination of two interactive loops: one loop relating the system to its environment, the other loop relating the system to its parts. For systems analysis, e.g. intelligence analysis of remotely sensed facilities in denied territory, these loops consider structure, function, and process in the context of environment to develop information (what), knowledge (how), and understanding (why) of the system and elements being studied. This exposition presents the interactive loops of design in systems ontology, treating analysis of Soviet national missile defenses as an example of successful application of systems ontology.
Recursive Ontology: a Systemic Theory of Reality
The article introduces recursive ontology, a general ontology which aims to describe how being is organized and what are the processes that drive it. In order to answer those questions, I use a multidisciplinary approach that combines the theory of levels, philosophy and systems theory. The main claim of recursive ontology is that being is the product of a single recursive process of generation that builds up all of reality in a hierarchical fashion from fundamental physical particles to human societies. To support this assumption, I provide the general laws and the basic principles of recursive ontology as well as a semi-formalised model of the theory based on a recursive generative grammar. Recursive ontology not only actively promotes a multidisciplinary investigation of reality, but also can be used as a general framework to develop future domain-specific theories.
Towards an Ontology of Experience. Methodological REFLECTIONS1
2002
This paper attempts to throw some new light on the profligate globalization of the scientific and technological practices of present-day capitalist society by reckoning the specific ontology encoded in their procedures by means of which they operate. It is shown that the separating intervention in reality proper to these procedures, cognitive and empirical, can be traced back to the principles of the logical system underlying them since European Antiquity. This logical system allows for the generation of worldviews that, although at variance amongst themselves, share a fundamental feature: the separation between subject and object, between statical and dynamical, between man and world. The practices arising from such an externalized relation to the world then again amount to the imposition of an ontology upon reality that is not fit to it. In a subsequent movement, the argument leads to the question whether traces of a another intrinsical relation between man and world can be found,...
Meta-ontology and System Theory. Towards a logical and phenomenological approach to Complexity.
Fausto Fraisopi INTRODUZIONE 7 SEZIONE PRIMA STORIA MassiMo pulpito I TRE LIVELLI DELL'ONTOLOGIA PARMENIDEA 19 Cesare Catà TUTTO CIÒ CHE È NON PUÒ NON ESSERE (CONTRATTO). LA QUESTIONE ONTOLOGICA NELLA FILOSOFIA DI CUSANO 69 Dan arbib INDÉPENDANCE, INFINITÉ ET PUISSANCE DE DIEU. LES ÉTAPES DE L'ÉMERGENCE DE LA CAUSA SUI DANS LE CORPUS CARTÉSIEN 95 JoCelyn benoist PERCHÉ NON C'È UN'ONTOLOGIA FORMALE IN BOLZANO 119 Carlo sCognaMiglio NICOLAI HARTMANN: DALLA FONDAZIONE ALLA COSTRUZIONE DELL'ONTOLOGIA 137 gregory lanDini RUSSELL ON WHAT THERE ISN'T 163 FranCesCo saverio trinCia FENOMENOLOGIA E ONTOLOGIA A PARTIRE DA EDMUND HUSSERL 205 sebastiano galanti grollo L'ONTOLOGIA NEI BEITRÄGE ZUR PHILOSOPHIE DI HEIDEGGER 227 MarCo Filoni L'ONTOLOGIA DI KOJÈVE IL DUALISMO DIALETTICO E LO SCARTO FRA HEGEL E HEIDEGGER 257 anDrea antonelli ONTOLOGIA DELL'INCONTRADDITTORIO. LA STRUTTURA DELLA VERITÀ NEL PENSIERO DI EMANUELE SEVERINO 269 SEZIONE SECONDA PROSPETTIVE ClauDio Calosi MEREOLOGIA 295 roberto poli CATEGORIE 335 FranCesCo berto METAFISICA DA NULLA MONDI IMPOSSIBILI E OGGETTI FINZIONALI 351 FranCesCo arMezzani ONTOLOGIA E FILOSOFIA DELLA MENTE 373 Carola barbero LE ENTITÀ FITTIZIE 389 paolo valore NOTHING IS PART OF EVERYTHING 407 tiMothy taMbassi ONTOLOGIA E SISTEMI CATEGORIALI. LOWE E IL DIBATTITO CONTEMPORANEO 421
Process Structural Realism, Instance Ontology, and Societal Order
2008
Whitehead's cosmology centers on the self-creation of actual occasions that perish as they come to be, but somehow do combine to constitute societies that are persistent agents and/or patients. "Instance Ontology" developed by D.W. Mertz concerns unification of relata into facts of relatedness by specific intensions. These two conceptual systems are similar in that they both avoid the substance-property distinction: they differ in their understanding of how basic units combine to constitute complex unities. "Process Structural Realism" (PSR) draws from both of these approaches in developing an account of how combinations of processes may produce ontologically significant coherences. When a group of processes achieves such closure that a set of states recurs continually, the effects of that coherence differ from what would occur in the absence of that closure. Such altered effectiveness is an attribute of the system as a whole, and would have consequences. This indicates that the network of processes, as a unit, has ontological significance. The closed network of processes, together with the conditions that prevail, constitute the form of definiteness of the coherence. That form continues to obtain as long as the coherence persists. Constituents contribute to, rather than share, that characteristic. Aspects of some recent research in systems biology, microeconomics, and social psychology illustrate the application of PSR.
Collected Philosophical Essays: Ontology and the Conceptual Social Subject-Object
Seventeen years in the making, this collection of philosophical essays traces the subject from its objectifying state as a presence in the world through its objectivization and recreation through the technological age in order to allow subjectivity to return to a state of conceptual and social awareness. Well founded on principles dating back to ancient Greece and tracing the footing of reason through its evolution in the post-industrial age towards a subsequent emancipatory merge through technology and media, being once again will regain its footing as a response to the underpinning and overdeterminations proposed by post-industrial capitalism— to a ground state that allows the subject-object to find its place through society, nature, technology, and existence as a being-in-the-world. Representations and projections of identity mark this venture and move it forward, and therewith we shall determine ourselves the pursuit of what is within our grasp—the Real.