D3.3 Report on driving forces and actors facilitating persistence and change in cultural landscapes (original) (raw)

Abstract

One of the goals of Work Package (WP) 3 of HERCULES is to reconstruct and assess the shortterm changes and dynamics of cultural landscapes, using a case study approach. In this deliverable, we aim at describing and understanding how landscapes changed in six HERCULES Study Municipalities (SM) since 1850, i.e. Colmenar Viejo (Spain), Lenk (Switzerland), Börje (Sweden), Plomari & Gera (Greece), Alatskivi & Peipsiääre (Estonia) and Mobdury (Great Britain). Whereas the description is based on the map comparison presented in D3.2, additional sources of information were needed to better understand the so called driving forces of the changes determined. We used secondary literature, statistical information and oral history interviews to assess the local historical context, the changes perceived, but also to determine which actors were influential for the changes observed. Abandonment shows to be the most important process across all SMs included and it was especially dominant in the 20th century. Afforestation, deforestation, expansion of agriculture and intensification of agriculture were also widespread. Whereas afforestation shows an increasing trend, deforestation and expansion of agriculture show a moderate, and intensification of agriculture even a strong decreasing trend. The SMs differ greatly regarding their average rate of change, with the fastest SM (Colmenar Viejo) showing about seven times higher rates of change than the slowest SM (Modbury). However, all SMs depict great temporal variability of change in the course of the study period. Overall, it is interesting to note that the latest periods was in no SM showing the highest rates of change, but even included the least dynamic period in one SM (Lenk). We also evaluate if certain factors seem to be especially suitable to cause change or persistence across the different SMs. Infrastructural developments, (macro-) economic shifts and crises, and increasing population numbers seem to have the potential to trigger massive landscape changes. However, the specific context determines if and how such developments have an impact on the landscape. An economic crises triggering emigration, such as in the case of Lenk 1876 to 1914, might well lead to agricultural abandonment, which however in the case of pastures in harsh alpine environment might not immediately lead to forest expansion. Abandonment due to the conversion of a community structure from (subsistence) farming into commercial and industrial activities might however trigger rapid changes. Such changes can be largely facilitated by infrastructural developments, enabling easy commuting to nearby centers. Our study reflects the diversity and complexity of landscape change processes across Europe. The number of case studies does not allow to draw general conclusions, but enables to formulate further hypotheses for research and feedback to the local communities regarding their specific development.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (22)

  1. Anderson, J. 2004: Talking whilst walking: a geographical archaeology of knowledge. Area 36 (3): 254-261.
  2. Arístegui Cortijo, A. 2013: La cartografía histórica del Instituto Geográfico Nacional, fuente para el estudio de núcleos urbanos: el caso de Colmenar Viejo (Madrid). Instituto Geográfico nacional http://www.ign.es/ign/resources/actividades/sdg/articulo\_cartohistorica\_colmenarviejo. pdf. Departamento Interuniversitario de Ecología de Madrid, and Universidad Autónoma de Madrid 1991: La Dehesa del Colmenar. Ayuntamiento del Colmenar Viejo.
  3. Harley, J.B. 1989: Deconstructing the map. Cartographica 26 (2): 1-20.
  4. Helmfrid, S. 1961: The storskifte, enskifte and laga skifte in Sweden: general features. Geografiska Annaler 43 (1/2) Morphogenesis of the Agrarian Cultural Landscape: Papers of the Vadstena Symposium at the XIXth International Geographical Congress, pp. 114-129.
  5. Käyhkö, N. and H. Skånes 2006: Change trajectories and key biotopes: assessing landscape dynamics and sustainability. Landscape and Urban Planning 75 (3-4): 300-321.
  6. Käyhkö, N. and H. Skånes 2008: Retrospective land cover/land use change trajectories as drivers behind the local distribution and abundance patterns of oaks in south-western Finland. Landscape and Urban Planning 88: 12-22.
  7. Monmonier, M. 1991: How to Lie with Maps. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
  8. Palang, H., Ü. Mander and A. Luud 1998: Landscape diversity changes in Estonia. Landscape and Urban Planning 41 (3-4): 163-169.
  9. Peterson, U. and R. Aunap 1998: Changes in agricultural land use in Estonia in the 1990s detected with multitemporal Landsat MSS imagery. Landscape and Urban Planning 41 (3): 193-201.
  10. Sabau Bergamin, G. 2002
  11. Zariņa, A. 2013: Path dependence and landscape: initial conditions, contingency and sequences of events in Latgale, Latvia. Geografiska Annaler: Series B Human Geography 95 (4): 355-373.
  12. For each of these maps, please provide: 1. year of mapping / publishing: 2. scale of mapping: 3. purpose of mapping or map name:
  13. map legend (land cover classes, linear elements, point data depicted) (if possible, please send sample image of the legend):
  14. format of the map (analogue, digital, web, scan, rectified scan, vectorised -in which software):
  15. is there WMS (Web Map Service/Server) possibility and limitations for using that: 8. how easy / costly it is for you to get the map:
  16. are there any legal issues involved, e.g. for publishing it on web etc.: 10. if possible, please send sample image of the map. Cadastral maps -sometimes these are located in municipalities When was the first cadastral map composed: How many cadastral maps do you have since 1800: For each of these maps, please provide: 1. year of mapping / publishing: 2. scale of mapping: 3. map name:
  17. map legend (land cover classes, linear elements, point data depicted) (if possible, please send sample image of the legend):
  18. format of the map (analogue, digital, web, scan, rectified scan, vectorised -in which software):
  19. is there WMS (Web Map Service/Server) possibility and limitations for using that: 8. how easy / costly it is for you to get the map:
  20. are there any legal issues involved, e.g. for publishing it on web etc.: 10. if possible, please send sample image of the map. Aerial / ortophotos / satellite imagery For each aerial / ortophoto / satellite imagery, please provide: 1. year of mapping / publishing: 2. scale / flight height/altitude: 3. resolution (pixel size): 4. name: 5. format of the map (analogue, digital, web, scan, rectified scan, vectorised -in which software):
  21. is there WMS (Web Map Service/Server) possibility and limitations for using that: 7. how easy / costly it is for you to get the map:
  22. are there any legal issues involved, e.g. for publishing it on web etc.: 9. if possible, please send sample image of the map. Terrestrial photos / landscape photos / postcards L23 Pathways L22 Side roads Use the ArcGIS Basemaps -World street map. Those roads that are not in topographic maps categorised as L21 Main roads are L22 Side roads Annex 4: Legend for Switzerland -Obersimmental -Lenk with map examples 2013 1992 1968 1935 1914 1876 1840 A1 Urban / Built-up A31 Meadows and pastures A32 Wooded grasslands and shrubs L23 Pathways L3 Railways L4 Cable cars Dufour map Siegfried map