Privacy: Primus Inter Pares - Privacy as a precondition for self-development, personal fulfilment and the free enjoyment of fundamental human rights (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Crisis of the Right to Informational Self- Determination
A. Vivarelli, 2020
This paper focuses on changes in data protection regulation and especially on the risks concerning informational self-determination and privacy created by technologies. The analysis starts from the growing ability to control informational flows-the beating heart of the informational self-determination principal-and goes on to examine consent as a 'tool' for managing personal data. In reality, the evolution of information and communication technologies affects consent, which becomes an 'instrument for building self-identity on the Internet'. There are several factors-with the advent of new tecnologies-that lead to the crisis of consent. The critical issues arise not only from the modern idea of privacy but also from current challenges to data protection regulation, such as the 'privacy paradox', 'datafication', profiling, and Big Data analytics. Starting from the impact these phenomena have on fundamental rights and freedoms, the research question is whether the GDPR's 'privacy by design' offers a satisfying solution or whether a more complex and global reflection is required.
Civilistica, 2023
The present article approaches the paradigm of valuing consent to treat personal data as provided on the General Law of data Protection (GLDP), due to confrontation with its effectiveness, based on informative self-determination. At this point, some insufficiencies of the model to the adequate adjustment in fundamental rights and in alternatives feasible to implement the idea of informative self-determination will be assessed based on the deductive methodology of literature review. It is pointed out that the merely formal consent cannot be enough to free consent protection due to cognitive limitations, asymmetry among powers, need of service usufruct, use of technical terms, time shortage and difficulty to manage future risks. On the other hand, some trends are highlighted to mitigate this insufficiency, be it through information systems such as privacy by design, accountability, offer of paid premium services without counterpart of the indiscriminate assignment of data and other contextual analyses.
Toward Informational Privacy Rights
In this paper I will offer several arguments in support of the view that individuals have moral claims to control personal information. Coupled with rights to control access to one's body, capacities, and powers, or physical privacy rights, we will have taken important steps toward a general right to privacy. In Part I, a definition of privacy is offered along with an account of the value of privacy. Simply put, privacy - defined as control over access to locations and information - is necessary for human well-being. In Part II, an attempt to move beyond claims of value to claims of obligation is presented and defended. Policies that sanction the capturing, storing, and trading of personal information about others is something we each have reasons to avoid. In the final part, the tension between privacy and security is considered. It is argued that privacy rights may be set aside only if specific procedural conditions are followed.
The legal significance of individual choices about privacy and personal data protection
This chapter looks into the security/privacy relationship through a legal prism. It is not about the legal acceptability of security measures, but rather about their legal- ity. Policy makers in the European Union (EU) taking security-related decisions are obliged to ensure all adopted measures are compliant with fundamental rights requirements. It is true that they might also, additionally, be interested in question- ing whether (some) individuals might perceive such decisions as impacting fundamentalrightsnegativelyornot.2 Thesearehowevertwodifferentissues,and should not be conflated: one regards compliance with fundamental rights, while the other is about perceptions of compliance. Whereas respect for fundamental rights is unquestionably a legal issue, perceptions of compliance might be described as a societal consideration, potentially addressed from an economic perspective in terms of a possible negative impact on the commercialisation of technological products.
What is Privacy? The History and Definition of Privacy
In: Keresztes, Gábor (ed.): Tavaszi Szél 2016 Tanulmánykötet I., Budapest, Doktoranduszok Országos Szövetsége, 2016
The protection of privacy cannot be separated from technological development: nowadays, due to the development of science and technology, the possibility to intrude into someone's privacy has increased. The law has to react to these changes, ensuring the legal protection of privacy. However, in order to ensure this protection, first of all it is necessary to determine the subject of this protection: privacy. Privacy itself is as old as mankind, however, it was not always a legally protected right. What is considered to be private and what is legally protected as private can differ. One of the most important issues concerning legal privacy protection is that -according to several privacy scholars and the European Court of Human Rights -it is not possible to give an exhaustive legal definition of the subject of privacy protection. The importance of privacy can be related to the fact that privacy has a very close connection with human dignity, freedom and independence of the individual, and it is more and more challenged in the age of the rapid technological development of the information society. The aim of the study is to present the historical development of privacy in order to better understand the concept of privacy and to find a solution to how privacy can be effectively protected in the information society. First, I am going to discuss the short history of privacy, then its already existing definitions, then the way international -especially European -legal regulations regulate the protection of private life, and finally I am going to outline the current challenges posed by the information society. As a result of my study, I will make some recommendations about how the existing regulations should protect privacy nowadays.
Online Privacy: Towards Informational Self-Determination on the Internet
"While the collection and monetization of user data has become a main source for funding “free” services like search engines, online social networks, news sites and blogs, neither privacy-enhancing technologies nor its regulations have kept up with user needs and privacy preferences. The aim of this Manifesto is to raise awareness for the actual state of the art of online privacy, especially in the international research community and in ongoing efforts to improve the respective legal frameworks, and to provide concrete recommendations to industry,regulators, and research agencies for improving online privacy. In particular we examine how the basic principle of informational self-determination, as promoted by European legal doctrines, could be applied to infrastructures like the internet, Web 2.0 and mobile telecommunication networks."
Protecting the Genetic Self from Biometric Threats
This chapter examines not only the history of the term privacy but also its international recognition as a fully protected right. Given the wide array of definitions of privacy, it can be said that the term seeks its identity. Depending on time and space, this right has had various traits, beyond the obstacles of a strict definition. The aspects or features of the term are those that lead to the necessity of its international recognition and protection, especially in the present digital and technological environment, where its foundation is reconsidered and internationally protected in an effective way.
A Brief Introduction to the Right to Privacy -An International Legal Perspective
Globalex, NYU School of Law, USA, 2022
After the invention of computers in the 19th century and the Internet in the late 1960s, the vast majority of our work is done online. The dependence on online platforms has increased over the years, and people have begun using diverse online platforms for various purposes, including learning, business, entertainment, socialization, etc. The growing advancement in information and communication technology (ICT) has brought a radical transformation in the communicating process making life easier, faster, and smarter. This landscape also poses tremendous challenges to privacy, as numerous actors collect, store, and share our personal data with numerous third parties, mostly without our knowledge. Over the last couple of decades, the collection, retention, use, and transfer of personal data have become rampant chiefly by government agencies and businesses. To indicate governments’ aptitude toward data processing, George Orwell once warned in his dystopian novel Nineteen Eighty-Four that Big Brother (government authorities) is always watching you. This trend of government-sponsored data processing has increased significantly over time, especially, after September 11, 2001. While business’s data processing has also become evident by new business models that are mostly grounded on personal data. In course of time, the personal data market has become global due to the constant increase of the access and use of the Internet. Eventually, personal data has evolved as the main fuel of the 4th Industrial Revolution era. In such an atmosphere, ordinary citizens, being private individuals, or consumers desire to have adequate legal protections for their privacy rights. Thus, the worldwide debate on privacy concerns has become apparent. Keeping this in mind, this article aims to explore some basic aspects of privacy, including the meaning, value, historical development, challenges, and legal protections as ensured in international, regional, and national legal frameworks.