The Role of Elites in Emerging Societies, or How Established Elites Deal with an Emerging Society: The Case of Business Elites in Contemporary Chile (original) (raw)

Abstract

In contrast to the diagnosis of order and continuity in which every social position seems to be fixed and uncontested, the year 2011 brought a novelty to Chile, hitherto the model of political stability and economic orthodoxy in an always turbulent subcontinent. What the different protests of students, environmental movements and regional vindications of 2011 (and beyond) have in common is the return of public concerns after decades of the hegemony and celebration of the private realm (Atria et al. 2013). Remarkable, too, is the fact that both the semantics and rhetoric of those protests are and were mainly moral in nature and revolved around the discourse of abuse. Apart from some radical expressions, the massive claims are not directed against the model itself or its foundations and promises. They are mainly against its excesses, including but not limited to the scandal involving the retailer " La Polar " , considered one of the biggest scams in the history of Chile, the big pharmacies' collusion to secure deliberate and sustained increases in the prices of medicines, Chile's pension system, which is harshly criticized because it does not assure workers decent pensions, the emergence of the profit system in higher education by using state credits for students, mega-investments in energy (hydropower and thermo-electrics) without providing for even minimal environmental regulations, etc. In a sense, the cleavage is not a classical political or ideological one (left-right or industrial and agrarian proletarians against conservative owners). The claim is mainly a moral one and has been made by the middle classes, students not socialized in the crucible and crossroads of Chilean politics since the end of Pinochet's dictatorship and regions abandoned by centralism in Santiago struggling for recognition and expressing the voice of the victims of abuses. Who is being held responsible for these kinds of repeated abuses? One need look no further than the business elites. Behind them, political elites are also scrutinized as possible accomplices, particularly the center-left Concertación which ruled Chile from the return to democracy until 2010 (or at least until the business elites themselves took control of the government again with Sebastián Piñera, one of the big millionaires in the region). These business and political elites represent the pillars of the neoliberal experiment introduced in Chile during Pinochet's dictatorship subsequent to the economic crisis in 1982.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (79)

  1. Aguilar, Omar (2011): "Dinero, educación y moral: el cierre social de la elite tradicional chile- na", en Joignant, Alfredo y Güell, Pedro: Notables, tecnócratas y mandarines. Elementos de sociología de las élites en Chile, 1990-2010, Santiago: Ediciones Universidad Diego Portales.
  2. Aguilar, Omar (2009): "Principios de diferenciación material y simbólica en la estratificación social", en Joignant, Alfredo y Güell, Pedro (Eds.): El arte de clasificar a los chilenos. Enfoques sobre los modelos de estratificación en Chile, Santiago: Ediciones Universidad Diego Portales.
  3. Aguilar, Omar (2013) "Agencia, estructura y habitus", en C.A. Charry & N. Rojas (Eds): La era de los individuos. Actores, política y sociedad actual, Santiago: LOM.
  4. Appiah, Kwame (2007): Cosmopolitanism: Ethics in a World of Strangers, Nueva York: Nor- ton.
  5. Archer, Margaret (Ed) (2010): Conversations about reflexivity, London and New York: Rout- ledge.
  6. Atria, Larraín, Benavente, Couso, Joignant (2013): El otro modelo. Del orden neoliberal al régimen de lo público. Santiago: Debate.
  7. Barozet, Emmanuelle y Espinoza, Vicente (2008): "¿De qué hablamos cuando decimos 'clase media' ? Perspectivas sobre el caso chileno". Expansiva No. 142. Santiago de Chile.
  8. Beck, Ulrich (2004): Der kosmopolitische Blick oder: Krieg ist Frieden, Frankfurt a.M.: Suhr- kamp.
  9. Beck, Ulrich / Giddens, Anthony / Lash, Scott (1994): Reflexive Modernization, Stanford: Stanford University Press.
  10. Boltanski, Luc y Chiapello, Eve (2002): El nuevo espíritu del capitalismo, Madrid: Akal.
  11. Bourdieu, Pierre (2007): El sentido práctico, Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI.
  12. Bremer, Helmut (2004): Von der Gruppendiskussion zur Gruppenwerkstatt, Münster: LIT.
  13. Bröckling, Ulrich (2007): Das unternehmerische Selbst, Frankfurt/M.: Suhrkamp.
  14. Chernilo, Daniel (2010): Nacionalismo y cosmopolitismo, Santiago: Ediciones UDP.
  15. Deutsch, Karl (1978): "Über die Lernfähigkeit politischer Systeme" in Lenk, Hans und Ropohl, Günter (Hrsg.): Systemtheorie als Wissenschaftsprogramm, Königstein: Athenäum.
  16. Diniz, Eli and Boschi, Renato (2004): Empresários, Interesses e Mercado: Dilemas do Desen- volvimento no Brasil. Belo Horizonte, Ed. UFMG.
  17. Dreizel, Hans (1962): Elitebegriff und Sozialstruktur, Stuttgart: Ferdinand Enke.
  18. Dryzek, John (2000): Deliberative Democracy and Beyond: Liberals, Critics, Contestations, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  19. Dubet, François (2011): Repensar la justicia social, Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI.
  20. Dupas, Gilberto (2005): Atores e poderes na nova ordem global, Sao Paulo, Ed. Unesp.
  21. Eder, Klaus (1999): "Societies Learn and yet the World is Hard to Change" in European Journal of Social Theory, Vol. 2 No. 2, 195-215.
  22. Eder, Klaus (1985): Geschichte als Lernprozess? Zur Pathogenese politischer Modernität in Deutschland, Frankfurt a.M: Suhrkamp.
  23. Fazio, Hugo (1997): Mapa actual de la extrema riqueza, Santiago: LOM-ARCIS.
  24. Field, G. Lowell und Higley, John (1980): Elitism, London.
  25. Fischer, Karin (2011): Eine Klasse für sich. Besitz, Herrschaft und ungleiche Entwicklung in Chile 1830-2010, Baden-Baden: Nomos.
  26. Ffrench Davis, Ricardo (2004): Entre el neoliberalismo y el crecimiento con equidad. Tres décadas de política económica en Chile, Buenos Aires: Siglo XXI-CEPAL.
  27. Fuentes, Claudio (2013): El Pacto: Poder, Constitución y Prácticas Políticas 1990-2010, San- tiago: Ediciones UDP.
  28. Gárate, Manuel (2012): La revolución capitalista de Chile (1973-2010), Santiago: Ediciones Universidad Alberto Hurtado.
  29. Giesen, Elisa (2010): Sobre la elite chilena y sus prácticas de cierre social, Tesis de Grado en Sociología: Universidad de Chile.
  30. Güell, Pedro (2012): "Chile 2011: del malestar difuso a la protesta social", in razonpublica.com [Web log post] Retrieved April 03, 2014.
  31. Harris, Jerry (2005): "Emerging Third World powers: China, India and Brazil", Race & Class, Vol. 46 No. 3, 7-27.
  32. Hartmann, Michael (1996): Top Manager. Die Rekrutierung einer Elite, Frankfurt a.M./New York: Campus.
  33. Hartmann, Michael (2003): "Nationale oder transnationale Eliten? Europäische Eliten im Ver- gleich", in Hradil, Stefan and Imbusch, Peter (Eds.): Oberschichten -Eliten -Herrschende Klassen, Opladen, Leske + Budrich (pp. 273-297).
  34. Hartmann, Michael (2013): Soziale Ungleichheit -Kein Thema für die Eliten?, Frankfurt a.M.: Campus.
  35. Held, David (2003): "Cosmopolitanism: Ideas, Realities and Deficits", in Held, D. and Mc Grew, A. (Eds.): Governing globalization, Cambridge: Polity Press.
  36. Transcience (2014) Vol. 5, Issue 1 ISSN 2191-1150
  37. Imbusch, Peter (2003): "Konjunkturen, Probleme und Desiderata sozialwissenschaftlicher Eli- tenforschung", in Hradil, Stefan and Imbusch, Peter (Hg.): Oberschichten -Eliten -Herr- schende Klassen, Opladen, Leske + Budrich (pp. 11-32).
  38. Joignant, Alfredo (2011a): "Las élites gubernamentales como factor explicativo de un modo político y económico de desarrollo: el caso de Chile (1990-2009)", Fundación Carolina, Avances de Investigación No. 58.
  39. Joignant, Alfredo (2011b): "El reclamo de las elites: desencanto, desafección y malestar en Chile". Revista UDP No. 9. Santiago de Chile.
  40. Kanter, Rosabeth Moss (1995): World class: thriving locally in the global economy, New York: Simon & Schuster.
  41. Krysmanski, Hans (2004): Hirten & Wölfe. Wie Geld-und Machteliten sich die Welt aneignen -oder: Einladung zum Power Structure Research, Münster: Westfälisches Dampfboot.
  42. Lafer, Celso (2002): A identidade internacional do Brasil e a politica externa brasileira, Rio de Janeiro: Perspectiva.
  43. Larraín, Jorge (2001): Identidad Chilena, Santiago de Chile: LOM.
  44. Lasch, Christopher (1995): The Revolt of the Elites and the Betrayal of Democracy, New York: W.W. Norton.
  45. Lenger, Alexander, Schneickert, Christian and Florian Schumacher (2010): "Globalized Natio- nal Elites", Transcience. A Journal for Global Studies Vol. 1, No. 2, 85-100.
  46. Luhmann, Niklas (1986): Ökologische Kommunikation, Opladen: Westdeutscher Verlag.
  47. Mac-Clure, O. (2012): "Las nuevas clases medias en Chile: Un análisis de cohortes". Revista de la Cepal No. 108.
  48. Montero, Cecilia (1997): La revolución empresarial chilena, Santiago: Cieplan-Dolmen.
  49. Nederveen Pieterse, Jan (2012): "Twenty-First Century Globalization: A New Development Era", Forum for Development Studies, 1-19.
  50. Nederveen, Pieterse, Jan y Rehbein, Boike (2008): "Emerging Powers", Futures, Vol. 40 No. 8 (Special Issue on Emerging Futures, Pieterse und Rehbein Hg.), 703-706.
  51. OECD (2014): "Society at a Glance 2014: OECD Social Indicators", OECD Publishing. http: //dx.doi.org/10.1787/soc_glance-2014-en
  52. Ossandón, José y Tironi, Eugenio (Eds.) (2012): Adaptación. La empresa chilena después de Friedman, Santiago: Ediciones UDP.
  53. Paul, Axel/ Pelfini, Alejandro/ Rehbein, Boike (Eds.) (2010): Globalisierung Süd, Leviathan Sonderheft 26, Berlin.
  54. Pelfini, Alejandro (2011): "Global and National Political Elites in South America: Limited Transnationalization Processes and the Persistence of Inequality" in Rehbein, Boike (Ed.): Globalization and Inequality in Emerging Societies, Basingstoke: Palgrave-MacMillan (pp. 194-210).
  55. Pelfini, Alejandro (2009): "Der Mythos der globalen Eliten. Beschränkte Transnationalisie- rungsprozesse am Beispiel aufstrebender aktiver Minderheiten in Südamerika", en Jain, Anil y Schneider, Dietram (Eds.): Weltklasse für Unternehmen, Staat und Gesellschaft: Fiktionen und Realitäten, Munich: Edition Fatal (pp. 108-129).
  56. Pelfini, Alejandro (2005): Kollektive Lernprozesse und Institutionenbildung. Die deutsche Kli- mapolitik auf dem Weg zur ökologischen Modernisierung, Berlin: Weissensee.
  57. Portes, Alejandro and Hoffman, Kelly (2003): "Las estructuras de clase en América Latina: composición y cambios durante la época neoliberal", CEPAL, Serie Políticas Sociales No.
  58. Pries, Ludger (2011): Die Transnationalisierung der sozialen Welt, Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
  59. Rehbein, Boike (2013): Kaleidoskopische Dialektik, Konstanz: UVK. Transcience (2014) Vol. 5, Issue 1 ISSN 2191-1150
  60. Savage, Mike and Karel Williams (2008): "Elites: remembered in capitalism and forgotten by social sciences" en Savage y Williams (Eds.) (2008): Remembering Elites, Londres: Blackwell.
  61. Schneickert, Christian (2013): "Transnationale Eliten aus dem 'globalen Süden'. Wirtschaft- liche und politische Eliten in Brasilien und Indien", in Jürgen Gerhards/Silke Hans/Sören Carlson (eds.): Globalisierung, Bildung und grenzüberschreitende Mobilität. Berlín: Sprin- ger VS.
  62. Schwengel, Hermann (2004): "Auf dem Wege zu globalen Eliten. Neue politische Machtkon- stellationen im Entstehen", in Hitzler, Ronald (Ed.): Elitenmacht, Wiesbaden: VS.
  63. Schwengel, Hermann (2008): "Emerging powers as fact and metaphor: Some European ideas", Futures, Vol. 40 No. 8 (Special Issue on Emerging Futures, Pieterse und Rehbein, Eds.), 767-776.
  64. Scott, John (2001): Power, Cambridge: Polity Press.
  65. Sfez, Lucien (1988): Critique de la Communication, Paris: Ed. du Seuil.
  66. Sklair, Leslie (2001): The Transnational Capitalist Class, Oxford: Blackwell.
  67. Solimano, Andrés (2012): Capitalismo a la chilena, Santiago: Catalonia.
  68. Souza, Jessé (2010): Os batalhadores brasileiros: Nova classe média ou nova classe trabalha- dora?, Belo Horizonte, Editora Universidade Federal de Minas Gerais.
  69. Souza, Jessé (2008): Die Naturalisierung der Ungleichheit, Wiesbaden: VS Verlag.
  70. Thumala, María A. (2007): Riqueza y Piedad. El catolicismo de la élite económica chilena, Santiago: Debate
  71. Tironi, Eugenio (2012): "La elite empresarial ante la democracia y la globalización", Revista UDP No. 9, (pp. 26-31).
  72. Tironi, Eugenio (1999): La irrupción de las masas y el malestar de las elites, Santiago: Gri- jalbo.
  73. Torche, F. and G. Wormald (2004): "Estratificación y movilidad social en Chile: Entre la adscripción y el logro". Serie Políticas Sociales, No. 98 (LC/L.2209-P), Santiago de Chile: CEPAL.
  74. Undurraga, Tomás (2011): "Rearticulación de grupos económicos y renovación ideológica del empresariado en Chile 1980-2010", Working Papers ICSO-UDP.
  75. Vester, Michael (2003): "Culture and Class in Germany" Sociología, problemas e práticas. Nr. 42 (pp-25-26).
  76. Vester, Michael, Peter von Oertzen, Heiko Geiling, Thomas Hermann and Dagmar Müller (2001): Soziale Milieus im gesellschaftlichen Strukturwandel, Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.
  77. Weiß, Anja (2006): "Vergleichende Forschung zu hochqualifizierten Migrantinnen und Migran- ten. Lässt sich eine Klassenlage mittels qualitativer Interviews rekonstruieren?" in Forum Qualitative Sozialforschung, Vol. 7, No. 3, Mai 2006.
  78. Zeitlin, Maurice and Ratcliff, Richard (1988): Landlords and capitalists. The dominant class in Chile, Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press.
  79. Ziegler, Sandra and Gessaghi, Victoria (Eds.) (2012): Formación de las elites. Investigaciones y debates en Argentina, Brasil y Francia, Buenos Aires: Manantial-FLACSO.