The Early State and Its Analogues: A Comparative Analysis. The Early State, Its Alternatives and Analogues 2004. (original) (raw)

It is recognized widely enough that a pre-state society in order to get trans-formed into a state must have a certain size of territory and population, a necessary degree of sociocultural complexity and an ability to produce suf-ficient quantities of surplus. However, sometimes cultures significantly exceed required levels of those parameters without forming states. In addition to this, we know historically and ethnographically a considerable number of stateless societies not at all inferior to the early state societies with respect to their territory, population, sociocultural and/or political complexity. So, the question is: how to classify such societies? Compared to unquestionably pre-state societies, such as, for example, simple chiefdoms, they are not only larger in size but much more complex as well. In certain sense, they can be regarded as being at the same level of sociocultural development as early-state societies. And, since both types of societies faced similar problems and solved similar tasks, I denote (identify) complex stateless societies as early state analogues. This article is an attempt to analyze such analogues and compare them with early states.

Sign up for access to the world's latest research.

checkGet notified about relevant papers

checkSave papers to use in your research

checkJoin the discussion with peers

checkTrack your impact