The Economy-wide Impact of Better Governance: Cutting Informal Taxes in Indonesia (original) (raw)
Related papers
Bribes by firms in Indonesia arise principally from regulations --licenses and levies --imposed by local government officials. Regulations generate direct revenues (fees) plus indirect revenues in the form of bribes. The expected value of the latter is capitalized into lower salaries needed by localities to compensate public officials. Localities in Indonesia are hampered by insufficient revenues from formal tax and transfer sources to pay competitive salaries plus fund "demanded" levels of public services, because local tax rates are capped by the center and inter-governmental transfers are limited. Thus the direct and indirect revenues from local regulations are critical to local finances.
2004
Bribes by firms in Indonesia arise principally from regulations --licenses and levies --imposed by local government officials. Regulations generate direct revenues (fees) plus indirect revenues in the form of bribes. The expected value of the latter is capitalized into lower salaries needed by localities to compensate public officials. Localities in Indonesia are hampered by insufficient revenues from formal tax and transfer sources to pay competitive salaries plus fund "demanded" levels of public services, because local tax rates are capped by the center and inter-governmental transfers are limited. Thus the direct and indirect revenues from local regulations are critical to local finances.
Causes and Consequences of Corruption in Tax Administration: An Indonesian Case Study
2017
This article uses an Indonesian case study (the Gayus case) to explore critical issues in the relationship between tax and corruption. More particularly, it considers the causes and impact of corruption at tax administrative levels in Indonesia, and identifies and evaluates strategies the Indonesian revenue authority (the Directorate General of Taxation, or DGT) has adopted, or can adopt, to ensure opportunities for such corrupt activity are mitigated or eliminated. The article adopts a qualitative approach, utilising archival analysis supplemented by interviews and correspondence with key parties involved. After a broad introduction which outlines the nature, types and impact of corruption in revenue authorities, the article identifies the principles that typically underpin anti-corruption strategies in revenue authorities in developing countries, together with examples of some of the anti-corruption strategies employed. It then considers the nature of the corrupt activity exemplif...
Tax Evasion and Violation of Human Rights: The Case of Indonesia
Journal of Arts and Humanities, 2019
This article discusses the issue of tax collection from the public in order to finance state administrators in carrying out their duties to create a society that is just, prosperous, spiritual and material. However, the implementation of tax collection is highly loaded with the contents of the political interests of the authorities. As a result, tax less redistributed to the benefit of public as taxpayers. The good and bad of tax policy cannot be separated from the political will of the government because tax policy is a political product of the ruling government, even though in reality it is not entirely legal as a political product but partly a social, cultural, economic and legal product. Interest has a very close relationship with policies made by the government, regardless of whether the policy is pro-people or just the reverse. Corrupt taxation policies will lead to taxation policies that suppress the rights of taxpayers, while democratic taxation policies will provide welfare for the people through redistribution. The author will review tax policies in Indonesia that seem to be forced and depend on the willingness of legislators, the design of tax policies that are dominated by political power without public participation and very minimal in its distribution to the public. This paper discusses tax administration design and practice and tax law making process that are undemocratic, authoritarian and less useful for taxpayers in Indonesia.
TAX EVASION IN A CORRUPT ECONOMY by Edimon GINTING Centre of Policy Studiesiylonash
Tax evasion has been studied intensively in the context of developed countries in which the institutional environment assumes a pervasive respect for the rule of law. In many developing nations such an assumption is not warranted. The objective of this paper is to develop a model of tax evasion apposite to an institutional set up in which corruption is endemic. The services of corrupt intermediaries are required by otherwise legitimate producers in order to navigate the informal 'laws' put in place by rent seekers with good connections. The model developed here posits a service providing industry which produces legitimate public services and corrupt intermediation as joint products which exploit economies of scope available to senior bureaucrats. The model can be used in various ways; in this paper a cut in the tax rate on income from capital is examined. Under certain conditions such a cut can lead to increased government revenue, giving a new explanation of how a kind of Laffer curve may operate in economies with endemic corruption.
Topic: The Effect of Corruption and Governance on Tax Revenues
Developing countries face a number of institutional problems in the process of revenue generation. One of the main problems is corruption in tax administration. The second main problem of low revenue generation is low quality of governance. The study analyzes the effect of institutional and structural variables (corruption and governance) on tax revenues using panel data set for 25 developing countries during 1990-2005. The GMM regression results show that institutional variables have significant effect on all taxes. The results show that corruption has adverse effect on tax collection, while good governance contributes to better performance in tax collection.
Corruption, Public Finances, and the Unofficial Economy
Policy Research Working Papers, 1999
Johnson, Kaufmann, and Shleifer (1997) found that, in Wealthy OECD economies and some Eastern post-communist economies, the unofficial economy's European economies find themselves in the "good share of GDP is determined by the extent of control equilibrium" of relatively low regulatory and tax burden rights held by bureaucrats and politicians. (not necessarily low statutory tax rates), sizable revenue Exploring in detail the role of taxation and bribery, mobilization, good rule of law and control of corruption, and using data from an expanded data set of 49 Latin and a small unofficial economy. American, OECD, and transition economies, Johnson, Several countries in Latin America and the former Kaufmann, and Zoido-Lobat6n find that the unofficial Soviet Union exhibit characteristics consistent with a economy accounts for a larger share of GDP where "bad equilibrium": the discretionary application of heavy there is great bureaucratic inefficiency and discretion, regulatory and tax burdens, the weak rule of law, heavy and where firms experience a greater tax and regulatory bribery, and an active unofficial economy. burden, as well as more bribery and corruption. The In this large country sample (unlike in the earlier unofficial economy is also much larger where there is less framework for transition economies only), the authors state revenue and where the rule of law is weak. They find that it is the ineffective and discretionary application also find that countries with a larger unofficial economy of regulatory and tax regimes in many countriesnot tend to grow more slowly. Thus, this framework suggests higher tax rates by itselfthat increase the size of the an additional channel whereby corruption and ineffective unofficial economy. The tax burden reported by firms regulatory and tax administration can result in lower appears to be more a function of regulatory and growth: the unofficial economy. bureaucratic inefficiency and discretion rather than of tax rates alone. This papera product of the Governance, Regulation, and Finance Group, World Bank Instituteis part of a larger effort in the institute to improve our understanding of institutional issues and their effects on development and of building a major new database on institutional indicators. Copies of the paper are available free from the World Bank,
Decentralization and Corruption in Indonesia: Manufacturing Firms Survival under Decentralization
2006
The main purpose of the paper is to investigate the firm survival in Indonesia from 2003 to 2004. In particular we investigate factors beyond firm death. In the literature of firm survival, the death is defined as firms that are no longer in the 'list', which in the Indonesian context it means no longer in the BPS (Central Statistical Agency) manufacturing directory. But we found that the death firms may not necessarily die after all. In the context of the perceived worsening business climate in Indonesia some firms may choose to become less visible or less formal to avoid harassment from tax officials, to escape from labor regulation, and to avoid paying local tax and levies which become common after decentralization. In the subsequent round of the BPS manufacturing survey, firms whose size fall below 20 workers would likely disappear from the BPS list. Other firms choose less extreme strategy to undergo downsizing. For the central and local governments; point of view this could mean the loss of potential tax revenues. We estimate a probabilistic model where the firm likelihood of becoming smaller status is influenced by firm characteristics, district level variables like bureaucratic harassment, bribery, and the horizon of the local bureaucrats.