Historical analysis in environmental law (original) (raw)

2018, Oxford Handbook of Historical Legal Research (Markus Dubber & Christopher Tomlins, eds.)

Abstract

keywords: history of environmental law, history of environmental regulation, environmental law, environmental regulation, legal history, environmental history Environmental law has no history. This is not to say environmental law has no past; indeed, scholars are beginning to uncover its historical roots. What I mean by having no history is, first, that there is a general feeling, common to legal historians and environmental lawyers (particularly in the United States), that environmental law is something new under the sun. Modern environmental law lacks of connection both to earlier periods and to the great themes and trends of legal history. Environmental law has no history in a second, sense, too; it lacks history as a mode of argument or analysis. In legal cultures in which precedent and history are often what make a winning argument, the unavailability of historical analysis as a mode of legal discourse—as it is, for instance, in constitutional and property law (two fields in which environmental legal disputes are often entangled)—means that environmental values often are forced to retreat in the face of others. For these reasons environmental law needs both heightened historical analysis and a sense of its own historical roots. This essay aims to sketch current, possible, and desirable directions for future research into the history of environmental law. Before doing so, it notes a current scholarly pathology.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (44)

  1. 'Medieval Welsh Law and the Mid-Victorian Foreshore', (2014) 35 Journal of Legal History 172 ff.; Henning Schmidgen, 'Die Gletscher haben keine Zeit', (2007) 10 Rechtsgeschichte 74 ff.; Osvaldo Cavallar, 'The Wheels of Watermills and the Wheel of Fortune: A consilium of Donatus Ricchi de Aldighieris', (2008) 13 Rechtsgeschichte 80 ff.; Daniel Damler. 'Das Meer im Recht', (2010) 16 Rechtsgeschichte 258 ff.
  2. For example, see Stefania Barca, Enclosing Water: Nature and Political Economy in a Mediterranean Valley, 1796-1916 (2010);
  3. William M. Cavert, The Smoke of London: Energy and Environment in the Early Modern City (2016);
  4. William E. O'Brien, State Parks and Jim Crow in the American South: The Untold Story of Segregation in State Parks (2015).
  5. Joachim Radkau, The Age of Ecology: A Global History, transl. Patrick Camiller (2014) 52-53.
  6. See James Willard Hurst, Law and Economic Growth: The Legal History of the Lumber Industry in Wisconsin, 1836-1915 (1964). For Hurst as the founding father of the discipline in the U.S., see Kunal M. Parker, 'Writing Legal History Then and Now: A Brief Reflection', (2016) 56 American Journal of Legal History 168 ff.
  7. Garrett Hardin, 'The Tragedy of the Commons', (1968) 162 Science 1243 ff.
  8. For example, see Paul Warde, 'Imposition, Emulation and Adaptation: Regulatory Regimes in the Commons of Early Modern Germany', (2013) 19 Environment and History 313 ff. For an overview of the commons in recent historical writing, see Giacomo Bonan, 'Confronting Hardin: Trends and Approaches to the Commons in Historiography', (2018) 19 Theoretical Inquiries in Law (forthcoming).
  9. For commons, see ibid. 333. For water, see David Schorr, The Colorado Doctrine: Water Rights, Corporations, and Distributive Justice on the American Frontier (2012).
  10. See David M. Driesen, 'Distributing the Costs of Environmental, Health, and Safety Protection: The Feasibility Principle, Cost-Benefit Analysis, and Regulatory Reform', (2005) 32 Boston College Environmental Affairs Law Review 1 ff.
  11. See Antony Taylor, '"Commons-Stealers", "Land-Grabbers" and "Jerry-Builders": Space, Popular Radicalism and the Politics of Public Access in London, 1848-1880', (1995) 40 International Review of Social History 383 ff.; G. Shaw Lefevre, English Commons and Forests: The Story of the Battle During the Last Thirty Years for Public Rights over the Commons and Forests of England and Wales (1894);
  12. Gregory S. Alexander, 'The Sporting Life: Democratic Culture and the Historical Origins of the Scottish Right to Roam', (2016) University of Illinois LR 321 ff.
  13. See Klaus Bosselmann, The Principle of Sustainability: Transforming Law and Governance (2nd ed., 2017) 12-13; Peter Sand, 'Sustainability: Of Forests, Ships, and Law', (2007) 37 Environmental Policy and Law 210 ff.; Richard Keyser, 'The Transformation of Traditional Woodland Management: Commercial Sylviculture in Medieval Champagne', 32 (2009) French Historical Studies 353 ff.
  14. Richard H. Grove, Green Imperialism: Colonial Expansion, Tropical Island Edens and the Origins of Environmentalism, 1600-1860 (1996);
  15. David B. Schorr, 'Forest Law in the Palestine Mandate: Colonial Conservation in a Unique Context', in Uwe Luebken, Frank Uekötter (eds.), Managing the Unknown: Essays on Environmental Ignorance (2014), 71 ff.
  16. E.P. Thompson, Whigs and Hunters: The Origins of the Black Act (1975);
  17. Nicholas A. Robinson, 'The Charter of the Forest: Evolving Human Rights in Nature', in Daniel Barstow Magraw, Andrea Martinez, Roy E. Brownwell II (eds.), Magna Carta and the Rule of Law (2015).
  18. See, for example, Kieko Matteson, Forests in Revolutionary France: Conservation, Community, and Conflict, 1669-1848 (2015).
  19. See Marc Raeff, The Well-Ordered Police State: Social and Institutional Change through Law in the Germanies and Russia, 1600-1800 (1983) 92 ff.
  20. For example in Markus D. Dubber, 'New Historical Jurisprudence: Legal History as Critical Analysis of Law', (2015) 2 Critical Analysis of Law 1 ff.
  21. See Heikki Pihlajamäki, 'The Westernization of Police Regulation: Spanish and British Colonial Laws Compared', in Thomas Duve, Heikki Pihlajamäki (eds.), New Horizons in Spanish Colonial Law: Contributions to Transnational Early Modern Legal History (2015), 97 ff.
  22. Morag-Levine (n. 19);
  23. Morag-Levine, (2011) 23 Journal of Environmental Law 1 ff.
  24. See Rosalind Malcolm and John Pointing, 'Statutory Nuisance: The Sanitary Paradigm and Judicial Conservatism', (2006) 18 Journal of Environmental Law 37 ff.
  25. For an example see David Schorr, 'A Prolonged Recessional: The Continuing Influence of British Rule on Israeli Environmental Law', in Dan Orenstein, Char Miller, Alon Tal (eds.), Between Ruin and Restoration: Chapters in Israel's Environmental History (2013) 218.
  26. See, for example, N. William Hines, 'Nor Any Drop to Drink: Public Regulation of Water Quality Part I: State Pollution Control Programs', (1966) 52
  27. Iowa LR 186 ff; Frank Uekoetter, The Age of Smoke: Environmental Policy in Germany and the United States, 1880-1970 (2009).
  28. See, for example, Christopher C. Sellers, Hazards of the Job: From Industrial Disease to Environmental Health Science (1999);
  29. Katrin MacPhee, 'Canadian Working-Class Environmentalism, 1965-1985', (2014) 74 Labour/Le Travail 123 ff.; Josiah Rector, 'Environmental Justice at Work: The UAW, the War on Cancer, and the Right to Equal Protection from Toxic Hazards in Postwar America', (2014) 101 Journal of American History 480 ff.
  30. See, for example, Erik Loomis, 'When Loggers Were Green: Lumber, Labor, and Conservation, 1937- 1948', (2015) 46 Western Historical Quarterly, 1937-1948 421 ff.
  31. Ben Pontin, 'Environmental Law-Making Public Opinion in Victorian Britain: The Cross-Currents of Bentham's and Coleridge's Ideas', (2014) 34 OJLS 1 ff.; Mario Prost and Yoriko Otomo, 'British Influences on International Environmental Law: The Case of Wildlife Conservation', in Robert McCorquodale and Jean-Pierre Gauci (eds.), British Influences on International Law, 1915-2015 (2016), 192 ff. 49 Purdy (n. 16).
  32. Alfred W. Crosby, Jr., The Columbian Exchange: Biological and Cultural Consequences of 1492 (1972);
  33. For examples of histories of environmental law in imperial contexts see, for example, Prost and Otomo (n. 48);
  34. Vinita Damodaran, 'Indigenous Agency: Customary Rights and Tribal Protection in Eastern India, 1830-1930', (2013) 76 History Workshop Journal 85 ff.; and my own work, Schorr (n. 30);
  35. Schorr (n. 39);
  36. David Schorr, 'Riparian Rights in Lower Canada and Canada East: Inter-imperial Legal Influences', in Roland Cvetkovski and Volker Barth (eds.), Imperial Co-operation and Transfer, 1870-1930: Empires and Encounters (2015), 107ff. Further reading
  37. Karl Boyd Brooks, Before Earth Day: The Origins of American Environmental Law, 1945-1970 (2012).
  38. Betsy Mendelsohn, 'Law and the Environment', in Michael Grossberg and Christopher Tomlins (eds.), Cambridge History of Law in America, vol. 3 (2008), 472 ff.
  39. Noga Morag-Levine, Chasing the Wind: Regulating Air Pollution in the Common Law State (2003).
  40. Ben Pontin, 'Integrated Pollution Control in Victorian Britain: Rethinking Progress Within the History of Environmental Law', (2007) 19 Journal of Environmental Law 173 ff.
  41. Jedidiah Purdy, 'The Long Environmental Justice Movement', Ecology Law Quarterly (forthcoming 2017).
  42. Pierre Claude Reynard, 'Public Order and Privilege: Eighteenth-Century French Roots of Environmental Regulation', (2002) 43 Technology and Culture 1 ff.
  43. E.P. Thompson, Whigs and Hunters: The Origins of the Black Act (1975).
  44. Steven Stoll, 'A Metabolism of Society: Capitalism for Environmental Historians', in Andrew C. Isenberg (ed.), Oxford Handbook of Environmental History (2014) 369.