A Research on Comparison of Regression Models Explaining the Profitability Base on Financial Data (original) (raw)
Related papers
A COMPARISON OF ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORK AND DECISION TREE FOR PROFITABILITY IN TECHNOLOGY SECTOR
Profitability is always a main consideration for businesses. Business and academicians have researched in order to determine the factors affecting profitability due to the importance of this issue. In this study, return on assets is modeled and compared with two different methods. Artificial Neural Network and Decision Tree are established with financial Statements of technology sector on BIST (Borsa Istanbul). The two models were evaluated in the study. Their strengths relative to each other were determined. Copyright©2016, Mehmet Nuri İNEL et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Prediction of business failure: a comparison of discriminant and logistic regression analyses
Journal of the School of Business Administration Istanbul University, 2009
This paper investigates two predictive models of business failure and important financial variables detecting failure potential using the sample of 122 both publicly opened and closed firms from the period of 1999-2007. Discriminant and Logistic Regression Analyses are performed and their predictive accuracy are compared. The results demonstrate that most of the failed firms show the signs of financial distress long before the failure and no statistically significant difference between the prediction results and variable choice of the discriminant and logistic regression analyses.
Journal of Applied Finance & Banking, 2013
Risk of financial failure is defined as the inability of a firm to pay its current liabilities. Financial failure may lead firms to bankrupt or go into liquidation. This paper aims to develop reliable model to identify the financial failure risk of the firms listed on Istanbul Stock Exchange National-All Share Index. In line with this goal, we calculate 20 financial ratios to predict the financial failure of firms and develop the most reliable model by analysing these ratios statistically. As a result of the analysis using these 20 financial ratios, it is identified that there are 5, 3 and 4 important financial ratios in the discrimination of the successful and unsuccesful firms in 2009, 2010 and 2011, respectively. Thus the discriminant function is formed by using these variables. Capital adequacy and net working capital/ total assets ratios are seemed to be significant in all three periods. According to formed models, classification success are determined as 88,7% 90,4% and 92,2% in 2009, 2010 and 2011 years respectively. These high accuracy ratios indicate that the developed models for three years are efficient to determine the financial failure of the firms traded in Istanbul Stock Exchange.
Corporate Ratings and a Model Proposition for the Manufacturing Industry at Borsa Istanbul
Journal of Financial Research, 2015
In this study it is aimed to develop a model using logistic regression analysis for the forecasting the rating grade of a manufacturing firm that form the basis to expert evaluation. Under the scope of this study 35 financial ratios are used as the independent variables, which are calculated on the grounds of annual financial statements and their notes during the period of 2007-2013 which are disclosed by the 206 listed manufacturing firms on Borsa Istanbul, and the status of the firms being “good” or “bad” based on financial capability is used as the dependent variable. Percentage of correct classification of developed model is at acceptable levels. By using the developed model, probability of a firm being "good" or "bad" can be estimated and using the proposed scale rating grade can be appointed of the firm that rating wanted to be performed.
FINANCIAL INDICATORS AS PREDICTORS OF ILLIQUIDITY
The main objective of this study is the development of the model for predicting illiquidity, i.e. identification of financial indicators on the basis of which one can predict illiquidity. The research focus is on large companies in the Republic of Serbia. Bearing in mind the results of previous research and the assumptions underlying the logistic regression, the paper relied on logistic regression for drawing conclusions. For each of the 426 companies included in the sample, based on data from financial statements, financial ratios were calculated in respect of: liquidity, activity, solvency, profitability, and effectiveness, which were used as independent variables in the study. The research results show that in the prediction of illiquidity of large companies in Serbia, from a total of 23 financial indicators included in the model, the following distinguish themselves as significant: capital turnover ratio, inventory turnover ratio, fixed-asset turnover ratio, real asset coverage ratio, net profit ratio, return on total assets, return on equity, and effectiveness of main business activity.
International Journal of Economics and Finance, 2015
This study aims to develop a model using C5.0 and CHAID decision tree algorithms to estimate the financial failure and/or success of a given manufacturing company. Within the scope of this study, 35 financial ratios are used as independent variables calculated on the grounds of both company’s annual financial statements and notes from 2007 to 2013. The dependent variable is the successful or unsuccessful status in terms of financial capability of 206 manufacturing firms listed on the Borsa Istanbul. Qualitative criteria are used to categorize the companies as successful or unsuccessful. The rates of accurate classification for both models are found to be at acceptable levels. Although the CHAID algorithm’s general rate of accuracy and its rate for successful companies are greater than the rates obtained from the C5.0 algorithm for the same observations, the CHAID algorithm yielded much lower results than the C5.0 algorithm in predicting unsuccessful companies.
Predicting non-performing loans by financial ratios for small and medium entities in Lebanon
This study examines the ability of financial ratios in predicting the financial state of small and medium entities (SME) in Lebanon. This financial state can be either one of well-performing loans or one of non-performing loans. An empirical study is conducted using a data analysis of the financial statements of 222 SMEs in Lebanon for the years 2011 and 2012, of which 187 have currently well-performing loans and 35 have currently non-performing loans. Altman Z-scores are calculated, independent samples t-tests are performed, and models are developed using the binary logistic regression. Empirical evidence shows that the Altman Z-scores are able to predict well the solvent state of SMEs having well-performing loans, but are unable to predict accurately the bankruptcy state of the SMEs having non-performing loans. The independent samples t-tests revealed that five financial ratios are statistically significantly different between SMEs having well-performing loans and those having non-performing loans. Finally, a logistic regression model is developed for each year under study with limited success. In all cases accuracy results are inferred showing the percentage of companies that are accurately classified for being solvent and bankrupt, in addition to the two standard measures of error: the Type I errors and the Type II errors. Although a high accuracy is achieved in correctly classifying non-distressed and distressed firms, the Type I errors are in general relatively large. By contrast the Type II errors are in general relatively low.
Working capital refers to the funds required to undertake the day-today operations of a firm. To achieve business objectives, an investment of the firm's capital in current assets and the use of current liabilities to fund part of the investment are required. Therefore, sound working capital management is required in order for the firm to remain competitive in this information age. This study explores the impact of working capital management on the profitability of food complex manufacturing firms operating in and around Addis Ababa. The efficiency of working capital management has been measured by Inventory Turnover Period, Account Receivable Collection Period, Days Payables Outstanding, Cash Conversion Cycle, Current Ratio and Quick assets ratio; and Return on Assets was considered as proxy for profitability. Relevant data for this study has been collected from 10 food complex manufacturing firms' annual financial statements for the period 2009-2013 and analyzed through descriptive statistics, Pearson correlation and multiple regression analysis. Accordingly, the findings revealed that Return on Assets was found to be significantly and negatively related to average days in inventory, average days payable and cash conversion cycle, which would suggest that by shortening of cash conversion cycle food complex manufacturing firms can increase their profitability. The findings of the regression analysis show that average days in inventory, average day's receivable, and average days payable have a significant impact on Return on Assets. However, current ratio and quick asset ratio have insignificant and positive relation with Return on Assets. Therefore, managers of food complex business can increase the profitability of their firms by shortening the cash conversion cycle, inventory conversion period, and receivables collection period. However, they cannot increase profitability by lengthening the payables deferral period.