Japan's Contested Memories: The ‘Memory Rifts’ in Historical Consciousness of World War II (original) (raw)
Related papers
A lost war in living memory: Japan’s Second World War
European Review, 2003
We examine the strata of memory in Japan’s recollections of the wartime experience and explore the shaping and releasing of memory in Japan, seeking to penetrate and recover individual Japanese experience. Individual memories that seemed tightly contained, when released were told with great emotional intensity and authenticity. That there has been little public discourse does not mean that individual Japanese have forgotten that war, but that the conflict – a war with no generally accepted name or firmly fixed start or end – seems disconnected from the private memories of the wartime generation. Japan was defeated thoroughly and completely, and in the history of memory we see no well-established narrative form for telling the tale of the defeated. In Japan's public memory of the war, War itself is often the enemy, and the Japanese its victims. Such a view is ahistorical and unsatisfactory to nations and peoples throughout Asia and the Pacific. The prevailing myths during Japan&#...
Warring memories: Japan’s battle between remembering and forgetting
2019
In 1945, Japan was bombed into submission by the dropping of two atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This ended a period in Japan's history notorious for aggression, atrocities, and the victimisation of East Asian and captive peoples. For seven decades, the country has navigated through the memories of a traumatic past. This has created a variety of collective memories which have been shaped and reshaped through places, symbols, museums, public debate, and politics. This study investigates the collective memories portrayed at Yasukuni Shrine and the Hiroshima Peace Memorial Park, with attention given to the associated Yūshūkan, and Peace Memorial museums. The two sites present markedly different narratives of the war and show evidence of historical revisionism by the altering of content in order to align with their respective objectives. This has produced significant collective forgetting of the unsavoury aspects to Japan's past, while creating an identity which is closely linked to the notion of nonviolence. Analysis of public debate surrounding Prime Minister Shinzo Abe's visit to Yasukuni in 2013, and President Barack Obama's visit to Hiroshima in 2016, showed that the collective memories represented at each site, while contested, are largely effective in producing a sense of national identity among Japanese people. The two sites thus function in tandem, despite contrasting displays of the war, in their forgetting and eliciting of sympathy and gratitude to the sacrifices of the war dead. While contestation of collective memory remains, the two versions analysed in this study show that they are both significant to the production of pride in being Japanese, and in shaping Japan's internal and external identity.
History : War memory and Japan’s ‘postwar’
2020
Press. Last, but very far from least, I would like to thank the two most wonderful Europeans in my life, my partner Anna Katharina Schaffner and our daughter Helena. The former's feedback on the manuscript was invaluable, leading me not only to reformulate but also to rethink parts of my argument. I dedicate this book to Anna Katharina and Helena, in love and gratitude.
Journal of Next Generation Forum, 2021
This article situates the animated film adaptation In This Corner of the World in a broader cultural context of popular memory and examines the creative process of telling stories of World War II by non-war victim contemporary artists. Contrary to existing research concerning the manga's adaptation and medium specificity, the article builds on the concept of "prosthetic memory" to suggest that the diegetic film re-embodies the Japanese practice of WWII storytelling by personalizing public history and rehistoricizes the truth of Japanese war survivors in a commodified form. The article then undertakes a comparative analysis of the film's depictions and the testimonies of hibakusha (atomic bomb survivors) to evince the paradigm shift in WWII narratives in Japan.
Situations, 2023
This article offers some broad-ranging investigations into forms of subversive knowledge production that continue to shape the global politics of memory surrounding the end of World War II and the collapse of the Empire of Japan. It pursues an inquiry into the conspiracy theories, alternative histories, and revisionist histories that have emerged in response to Japan's defeat, as well as representative works of science fiction and imperial nostalgia on social media that revisit, and sometimes lament, the demise of the Japanese Empire. It seeks to diagnose how imperial revanchism complements, or has been appropriated, by global far-right movements, which have of late achieved an unprecedented resurgence from the periphery of collective memory and ideological acceptability.
War memories and Japan's 'normalization' as an international actor: A critical analysis
European Journal of International Relations, 2011
The paradigmatic case in which an almost permanent impasse exists in coming to terms with a difficult war past and 'normalizing' its international relations is that of Japan. Although successive Japanese governments have apologized over the last few decades, these have been countered by periodic episodes within Japan revolving largely around history textbooks, the remembrance of war dead and the quest by nationalists to restore national pride in the past. Regional relations were especially strained during the premiership of Koizumi Juni'chirô and his immediate successor, Abe Shinzô. They improved under Fukuda Yasuo, a moderate on war memory issues, and remained steady under Asô Tarô. Japan's latest prime minister, Hatoyama Yukio, appears determined to address Japan's war past more openly and critically than previous LDP figures, no doubt with an eye to improving Japan's relations with its Asian neighbours. But whatever line he pursues, contestation over war memories will remain an issue. They are driven by deep divisions within Japan at the same time that political leaders seek a more prominent identity for Japan as a 'normal' actor in international affairs. This article analyses key aspects of the politics of Japan's war memories, using insights from collective memory studies and constructivist IR theory. We suggest that the quest for 'normality' has generated a set of tensions and contradictions over the issue of war memories, both domestically and internationally, for which there is no resolution in sight.
Reiterated Commemoration: Hiroshima as National Trauma
This article examines historical transformations of Japanese collective memory of the atomic bombing of Hiroshima by utilizing a theoretical framework that combines a model of reiterated problem solving and a theory of cultural trauma. I illustrate how the event of the nuclear fallout in March 1954 allowed actors to consolidate previously fragmented commemorative practices into a master frame to define the postwar Japanese identity in terms of transnational commemoration of “Hiroshima.” I also show that nationalization of trauma of “Hiroshima” involved a shift from pity to sympathy in structures of feeling about the event. This historical study suggests that a reiterated problem-solving approach can be efficacious in analyzing how construction of national memory of a traumatic event connects with the recurrent reworking of national identity, on the one hand, and how a theory of cultural trauma can be helpful in exploring a synthesis of psychological and sociological approaches to commemoration of a traumatic event, on the other.