2017 - EUROPEAN DISINTEGRATION - Catalonia case - Andreu Ginestet (original) (raw)
Related papers
Catalonia/Spain:the dangerous road towards authoritarianism
A referendum that is not contemplated it by the Constitution doesn’t mean an anti-democratic process and/or a no legitimate demand. It represents a cultural change in the society that is pushing for changes (within Spain or not). Even if there is not clarity of the opportunity for this demand it marks a new era for the Central government and an urgent need for a Constitutional change after a process of foreign Mediation. The failure to achieve results from the Central government has generated distrust and confrontation. When there is no room for dialogue, there is no leadership. MEDIATION from the European Union is that elephant with gross legs that may change and settle Catalonia-Central Government interests within a meadow of opportunities in which minorities are attend on their demands. Democracy.
Thinking about the Political Situation in Catalonia
IAFOR Journal of Cultural Studies 4, Issue 1, 2019
Catalan Separatism is, above all, a peaceful movement for self-government, defending the capacity for taking decisions as a nation, as a State, in an inclusive way. It defends sovereignty in all aspects, including income generated in Catalonia, and the distribution of wealth. The Spanish transition after 1975 failed to encourage the construction of a pluralist State, and the autonomic framework has proved to be unsatisfactory. The reluctance of some parties in the government to give more autonomy to Catalonia, especially in the last ten years, and to recognise it as a nation, has led to a significant increase in Catalan independence supporters. Extreme right-wing movements have emerged recently, defending the unity of Spain and attacking democracy, not only in Catalonia, and their sometimes violent riots are tolerated more permissively by Spanish authorities than actions in favour of Catalan prisoners on remand. The conflict is a challenge to the idea of Spain as it is now and also an occasion to think about what kind of political framework Europe offers to its members. Europe should perhaps offer more flexibility to communities having different languages and cultures, and therefore, the Catalan crisis is an opportunity to imagine a new European order.
International and European Institutions and Catalan Nationalism
Hague Journal on the Rule of Law, 2024
The exercise of public power by substate entities poses a challenge for international law. Although such entities lack international legal personality, their actions can have international significance and, because they are state organs, must always adhere to the international obligations assumed by the state. In Spain, the autonomous communities exercise broad powers, which, in the case of Catalonia (via the Generalitat), include education, healthcare, prisons and police. Research shows that the Generalitat has exercised-and, to some extent, continues to exercise-some of its powers in disregard of certain constitutional and legal obligations. This action by public authorities in disregard of the law can have international consequences, and various international organizations have expressed positions on it through their bodies. This paper examines these positions on the Generalitat's actions in connection with the secession process and other related policies, including both those that have been critical of this behaviour and those that have expressed direct or indirect support for it. The practice of the European Union, the Council of Europe, and the UN Human Rights Council through its Special Rapporteur on minority issues is analysed.
Separatism Today: The Geopolitically Significant Case of Catalonia
STRATEGIES XXI: The Complex and Dynamic Nature of the Security Environment, 2022
Catalonia’s national identity has its roots in the Middle Ages and Early Modern Times. In the 19th century, the Catalonian search for independence was encouraged by romantic and revolutionary concepts spread across Europe. After the First World War, we can notice a significant increase of political actions as regards the Catalonian nationalists-separatists, including violent episodes and riots in main cities. As for the contemporary period, the financial crisis in 2007-2008 acted as a new booster for nationalist-separatist ideas leading eventually to referendums in 2009 and also in 2017. The present study is exploring in a historical register the process of Catalonian’s independence. In doing so, I intend to identify and examine the Catalan’s main reasons in claiming complete political independence. The study tackles particularly recent interviews presenting opinions of several Catalonian citizens, some of them with political or administrative responsibilities, concerning regional i...
The Catalan crisis is about politics, not constitutional law – and it requires a political solution
EUROPP European Politics and Policy (London School of Economics and Political Science Blog) The Catalan crisis is about politics, not constitutional law – and it requires a political solution blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2017/10/01/the-catalan-crisis-is-about-politics-not-constitutional-law-and-it-requires-apolitical -solution/ The Spanish government regards the planned Catalan independence referendum as being unconstitutional, but supporters of the referendum have argued that Catalonia should have a legal right to hold the vote. Domenico Giannino states that although both sides have made legal arguments, it is a situation that can only be solved by political negotiations. The crisis also demonstrates a wider process under which national authorities are increasingly finding their powers constrained by the actions of both supranational and subnational actors.
2021
Astract: For several years now, Catalonia has been going through a serious political crisis, exacerbated by the independence referendum of 2017. The attempt by this autonomous region to separate from Spain with a view to creating a sovereign State has led to a fierce stand-off between the Catalan authorities and the Spanish Government. In this respect, it may be useful to shed some legal light both on the issue of human rights, from an international perspective, and on the issue of immunities, from the perspective of European Union law. Resumen: Desde hace varios años, Cataluña atraviesa una grave crisis política, agravada por el referéndum de independencia de 2017. El intento de esta comunidad autónoma de separarse de España con vistas a crear un Estado soberano ha provocado un fuerte enfrentamiento entre las autoridades catalanas y el Gobierno español. En este sentido, puede ser útil arrojar algo de luz jurídica tanto sobre la cuestión de los derechos humanos, desde una perspectiva internacional, como sobre la cuestión de las inmunidades, desde la perspectiva del Derecho de la Unión Europea