INTERNAL AUDIT EFFECTIVENESS THROUGH RISK-BASED AUDITING: AN EMPIRICAL STUDY IN THE MALAYSIAN PUBLIC SECTOR SITI AISAH BINTI YUSOFF FACULTY OF BUSINESS AND ACCOUNTANCY UNIVERSITY OF MALAYA FEBRUARY 2015 (original) (raw)
Related papers
The effectiveness of internal audit in Malaysian public sector
Internal audit in Malaysian public and private sector organizations underwent a steady organic growth since gaining a foothold in the management process in the 1970s. The management of the Malaysian public sector is continuously maturing in facilitating foreign input in national development, echoing similar advances expounded by the internal audit units of private sector organizations. The main difference being the public sector addresses the interest of a much wider group of stakeholders. Rapid development in infrastructures and industries positioned Malaysia on the fringes of globalization and the world market. This enlarges the crucial role of internal auditing to ensure transparency, integrity, quality and improved service delivery; among myriad positive aims, remain the end point of any process area. This study explored the significance of internal auditing in the Malaysian public sector, and its subsequent extent and influence in public sector hierarchy and decision making. Data was collected from responses to a questionnaire distributed to head of internal auditors, internal auditors and other staff of internal audit departments from various categories of public sector departments and agencies in Malaysia. The study concluded that the internal audit function in the public sector in Malaysia is curtailed by understaffing and hampered by inadequate support from top management while, the auditors seldom extend their full cooperation. The auditors themselves lack appropriate knowledge and training on effective auditing approaches. The negative perception accorded to internal audit led to inaction by management on recommended remedies which only serve to nullify the positive contribution internal audit potentially holds to elevate the service delivery quality of the public sector.
2018
The recurring issues of corruption, malpractices, poor public service delivery, financial irregularities and fraud always attract widespread attention. Unfortunately, although many policies and regulations have been implemented, these issues are still ongoing which make the efficacy of internal audit in the government sector even more critical than before. However, to date, it is still questionable whether this audit is efficient and effective due to the increasing trend in reported frauds in government departments. The objective of this paper is to examine the scope of audit that is associated with the effectiveness of internal audit. The uniqueness of this paper is to examine a new determinant, namely the practice of whistleblowing, on its effect in mediating the effectiveness of internal audit. The usefulness of this paper is to overcome the increasing rate of fraud in Malaysian public sector and encourage the whistleblowing practice in public sector agencies. It is undeniably ve...
THE ROLE OF RISK BASED INTERNAL AUDIT IN IMPROVING AUDIT QUALITY
IAEME PUBLICATION, 2020
This research was conducted with the aim of identifying the internal auditor's understanding of Risk Based Internal Audit (RBIA), identifying the application of risk assessment and risk matrix in the Government of North Sumatra Province. Produce driving and inhibiting factors for the application of risk based internal audit in the Government of North Sumatra Province. This research was conducted using quantitative approaches. The research population is internal auditors in the local government, while the informants in this study are people who understand the problems of implementing Risk Based Internal Audit. The variables that are thought to affect the successful implementation of risk based internal audit are the role of the internal auditor function, top management commitment, training, policy framework, and communication processes. The results showed that top management commitment, training, policy framework had a significant effect on the success of risk management implementation, while the role of the internal audit function and the communication process had no significant effect on the application of risk based internal audit. The results showed that the application of risk based internal audit has a significant effect on the quality of internal audit. JEL Codes : M42
Until now, financial management at local level is currently showing less satisfactory results. This is evident from results of the Local Government Financial Report audit. Poor financial management at local level in Indonesia can also be seen from various cases of corruption that occurred. Nowadays, in Indonesia the eradication of corruption becomes a very crucial and important focus. Even, the absence of corruption sets a benchmark for successful governance within a country. Therefore, to create good and healthy governance, it is necessary to apply risk management by having audits conducted by auditors, particularly internal auditors. A risk-based internal audit approach is an alternative to performing the audit function in order to run effectively and efficiently. Findings of this research suggest that successful implementation of risk-based audit is determined by several factors, such as the role of internal auditors, commitment of the top management, and professional development. Based on the research findings, it is expected that local governments will start considering the role of the internal audit function and there is a need for commitment of the top management, especially local heads, local government organization heads, and inspectorate heads.
… of Accountability and …, 2009
Internal audit is supposed to help members of organizations to improve their business activities. But the findings from in-depth interviews with internal auditors from a total of 40 federal government ministries, departments and agencies in Malaysia, conducted in the middle of 2004, have revealed a number of serious shortcomings. Most notable of these shortcomings are that many internal audit units have a shortage of staff, and that the audit staff lack internal audit skills. In addition, a majority of the audit units still employ outdated audit practices, and have failed to get the right level of support and assistance from the Treasury. Worse still, their operational effectiveness and efficiency is threatened by the high-handed conduct of the National Audit Department which arbitrarily and unilaterally shuffles staff between the body and internal audit units. With national and pubic sector surrounding leaving much to be desired for in regard to transparency and public accountability of the major actors and the fact that Malaysia is a large power distance society, it may not be too far fetch to expect the internal audit quagmire to continue to take place into the foreseeable future.
Internal audit in the state and local governments of Malaysia
Southern African Journal of Accountability and Auditing Research, 2007
Internal audit is supposed to help members of organizations to improve their entity’s effectiveness and efficiency. But the findings from in-depth interviews conducted with internal auditors from 35 State and Local Governmental Bodies (SLoGBs) located in Peninsular Malaysia in the third quarter of 2003 show that the audit function faces numerous challenges. This is in addition to the fact that a mere 35 out of the then 202 SLoGBs had an internal audit capacity. The politics of accountability theory, power distance, and a Malaysian social context that is replete with cases that display a lack of transparency and public accountability from its major actors, help to explain these facts and predict a bleak future for internal audit. However, a rosy future may yet be achieved through the involvement of key parties and if specific measures are put in place. This is the crucial role that the federal government in particular should play so that the audit function may fulfill its potential a...
Internal audit in the state and local governments of Malaysia: problems and solutions
International Journal of Accounting and Finance, 2010
In Malaysia, a growing catalogue of organisational failures and mismanagement in both the public and private sectors highlights the need for effective internal audit. Interviews conducted with internal auditors working in State and Local Governmental Bodies (SLoGBs) located in Peninsular Malaysia highlighted numerous problems faced by the audit function. The problems range from staff, skills and training shortages to premeditated obstruction of the auditors in their attempts to perform their duties, and are similar to what is found in many other countries. The way forward towards an improved internal audit function begins with having the right kind of organisational head in the organisations. Other moves include the setting up of audit committees in the organisations and an internal audit monitory body at either the state or the federal level. Improvement in the audit function may also
This paper is part of the third and final study conducted on the state of internal audit in the public sector of Malaysia. The first study was concerned with the internal audit operations in the state and local governments found in Peninsular Malaysia (Azham et al 2007a), while the second study was concerned with internal audit in the nation"s federal government ministries, departments and agencies . This third study covers 47 organizations at the federal government level, comprising 27 statutory bodies and 20 government-linked companies. From the face-to-face interviews conducted with internal auditors over the three year period 2005 to 2007, several notable audit features emerged as common to all 47 organizations. Some are depressing, while a few others are encouraging. All in all, however, the internal audit function in a majority of the organizations still leaves much to be desired. Also, it is notable that these findings are very much like those of the previous two internal audit studies , and to make sense of the dismal state of the internal audit function in the public organizations, there is perhaps a need to look at the bigger context within which the internal audit function is found.