Lincoln, Colonization, and Evidentiary Standards: A response to Allen C. Guelzo (original) (raw)
"In the Winter 2013 issue of the Journal of the Abraham Lincoln Association, historian Allen C. Guelzo of Gettysburg College took vigorous exception to my scholarship on Abraham Lincoln’s involvement with the colonization movement, including two prior articles I have written for the same journal and my 2011 book, co-authored with Sebastian N. Page, Colonization after Emancipation: Lincoln and the Movement for Black Resettlement. Colonization is an admittedly controversial subject matter owing to its racially charged legacy, and one that frequently generates discussion where Abraham Lincoln is involved. As a frequent contributor to that discussion, I have also invited open scrutiny of my work and historical interpretations including by sharing an extensive collection of original source material on this website. Many historians have since contributed a number of constructive insights to the ongoing colonization dialogue in the time since I first published my initial findings on this subject. Unfortunately Professor Guelzo’s recent commentary in the JALA offers little new to the discussion while heaping much scorn in the direction of my work. As a number of Guelzo’s charges cross the boundaries of professional and scholarly behavior, turning instead to personal insinuations of intentional scholarly transgression in the aforementioned volume of research, I felt it necessary – along with Sebastian Page – to offer a written response."
Related papers
Benjamin Butler's Colonization Testimony Reevaluated
Journal of the Abraham Lincoln Association, 2008
This paper presents a case for reexamining Gen. Benjamin F. Butler's controversial "colonization interview" with Abraham Lincoln, which reportedly occurred only days before the president's assassination in 1865. Historians have long disputed Butler's reliability as a source, all the while cognizant of the implications of his story for our understanding of Lincoln's views on race and emancipation. This article presents new evidence demonstrating conclusively that Butler's interview with Lincoln took place on April 11, 1865, though the claimed conversation remains an open question of inquiry. In examining this conversation as Butler related it, the article presents and evaluates new evidence that Lincoln pursued colonizationist policies much later into his presidency than previously thought.
Lincoln and Chiriquí Colonization Revisited
American Nineteenth Century History, 2011
Rewrites an ostensibly well-known episode of the Civil War by thinking beyond the United States. https://doi.org/10.1080/14664658.2011.626160
Civil war book review, 2009
Your latest book is titled "What Shall We Do with The Negro?": Lincoln, White Racism, and Civil War America. Now in this book, you attempt to revise what is really a celebratory depiction of Abraham Lincoln as the great emancipator by noting his reticence in many ways to ending the institution of slavery by force. How have historians, in your opinion, erred in chronicling Lincoln's record on the slavery issue?
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.