Distinction recapped: Digital news repertoires in the class structure (original) (raw)
Related papers
Class and everyday media use: A case study from Norway
Nordicom Review, 2021
In this article, we consider how contemporary media use is structured by social class, following the theoretical and methodical framework derived from Bourdieu's book Distinction, published in 1984, with a detailed study of everyday use of media platforms, brands, and content among Norwegian citizens (N = 2,064). First, we analyse how such media use varies in the overall social space using multiple correspondence analysis. Second, we independently explore the main differences and groupings of media practices, combining multifactor analysis and cluster analysis. While identifying important gender and generational differences, this study clearly shows how media use inside both younger and older generations are marked by class differences, which we argue demonstrates the fundamental and continuing importance of class for understanding mediated lifestyles.
‘It’s Something Posh People Do’: Digital Distinction in Young People’s Cross-Media News Engagement
Media and Communication, 2018
In this article, I analyse digital distinction mechanisms in young people’s cross media engagement with news. Using a combination of open online diaries and qualitative interviews with young Danes aged 15 to 18 who differ in social background and education, and with Bourdieu’s field theory as an analytical framework, the article investigates how cultural capital (CC) operates in specific tastes and distastes for news genres, platforms and providers. The article argues that distinction mechanism not only works on the level of news providers and news genres but also on the level of engagement practices—the ways in which people enact and describe their own news engagement practices. Among those rich in CC, physical, analogue objects in the form of newspapers and physical conversations about news are seen as ‘better’ that digital ones, resulting in a feeling of guilt when they mostly engage with news on social media. Secondly, young people with lower CC discard legacy news, which they s...
Transnational News Consumption and Digital Content Mobility: Insights from Sweden
Journalism Studies, 2018
Over the latest decade, the availability of news media from various countries of the globe has increased dramatically as both media production and consumption have been steered towards digital and social platforms. This de-territorialized news ecology has been widely researched in terms of content and distribution, while its broader consequences for news audiences have been less studied. Focusing on the case of Sweden, this article analyses social variations in transnational news consumption including platform selections, motivations, and attitudes connected to this news use. Results show that transnational news consumption is more widespread among people with a background in other countries than Sweden, but all together, more than a quarter of the Swedish population and nearly half of the younger generation are weekly consumers of news from other countries. Hence, transnational news consumption is no longer restricted to a specific elite- segment of society, which has been a common argument in scholarly debates around the globa- lization of news. Another central finding is that transnational news consumption is rooted in a will- ingness to understand the outside world through alternative perspectives, rather than in a dissatisfaction with the quality or trustworthiness of the news produced by Swedish outlets.
Battle of the Classes: News Consumption Inequalities and Symbolic Boundary Work
Critical Studies in Media Communication, 2020
Previous research has revealed a connection between news consumption and class, both in terms of how much and what kind of news is consumed. By deploying a cultural sociological perspective on how young people from different class positions make sense of their differences, this study breaks new ground in the study of news use and inequality. Focus group interviews with young working-class and middle-class people show how social groups mobilize differences in news consumption to draw symbolic boundaries between each other. The moral economy surrounding "productive" or "unproductive" approaches towards news and journalism is a venue that allows social groups to construct an other, over whom a sense of social, cultural, and moral superiority can be maintained. The study takes the understanding of news consumption inequalities beyond the standard concern with gaps in knowledge and participation by locating news consumption inequalities in relation to symbolic struggles between social groups.
ripeat.org
The paper presents the first report from a methodologically innovative study of people 's use and experience of news media, across the different public-service and commercial media platforms which offer the Danish public information about what goes on in society around them. The study relies fundamentally on the conceptualization of deliberative democracy that originates in Jürgen Habermas's theory of the public sphere (Habermas 1962), but it follows recent theoretical work in cultural studies and political science, according to which citizenship should be redefined as a wider cultural practice that includes sense-making, emotional and aesthetic communicative practices in the realm of the everyday, based on people's cultural identities, commitments and competences. The study observes the citizen-consumers' selection of news media and genres through the theoretical lens of 'perceived worthwhileness', because people's choice of news media is determined by what news media they perceive to be 'worthwhile'. This concept aggregates seven dimensions of media use: temporality, spatiality, materiality, textuality, economics, normativity, and participation.
Revisiting Digital News Audiences with a Political Magnifying Glass
Javnost - The Public, 2018
This paper argues that the emergence of digital audiences as members of the Polis have to be readdressed. First, it summarises the results of quantitative surveys and calls for more qualitative studies placing the social uses of news in a wider social context. Second, it hypothesises that the evolution of social classes plays a major role in the appropriation of news and in the digital participatory devices. Third, it examines paradoxes in the digital pubic sphere at a time when populist voices infiltrate the political debate. The article finally advocates interdisciplinary research and the practice approach as means to better understand social factors shaping these trends. KEYWORDS news social uses; social classes; practice approach; participative comments; populism; research protocols An Accumulation of Data and Ambivalent Results Most theories of democracy consider that information is essential to the proper functioning of political systems. It participates in what has been called the empowerment of citizens (Milner 2002): to be able to fully participate in the life of the city, it is necessary to be a
Introduction: News consumption as a democratic resource – News media repertoires across Europe
This article introduces the Special Section of Participations, in which audience researchers from twelve mostly European countries report on a joint comparative research project about repertoires of news consumption and their democratic implications. The first part outlines theoretical and analytical challenges for news audience research arising from the rapid transformations in current media landscapes, notably the emergence of digital, mobile and social media. We briefly describe our theoretical indebtedness to Jürgen Habermas’s theory of the public sphere, and the recent attempts to redefine the classical notions of democratic citizenship towards the everyday lifeworld. The second part describes the project’s anchorage in media systems theory, according to which national mediascapes can be compared not just on a one-to-one basis, but in terms of their potential membership of one of a finite number of supranational media systems defined in terms of shared structural and institutional characteristics. The third part describes the project’s unique fieldwork design, which followed a tailor-made version of Q-methodology for building audience news repertoires with greater transparency and reliability than is possible with traditional qualitative methods. This introduction thus provides the shared framework of understanding within which the Special Section’s contributions should be read: The first section includes ten articles, which each presents the findings from one national analysis of national repertoires of news consumption. The second section presents four articles, which in different ways embark on comparative analyses of news repertoires enabled by the Q- methodological framework.