The anti-politics of healthcare policy and its blurring effects on care work in Norway (original) (raw)
The aim of this article is to explore discourses of public healthcare sector transformation in Norway. These discourses are part of a wider European neoliberal discursive terrain shaped by policies that focus on competition, choice and 'integration' in healthcare. The method applied here is a combined Foucauldian and post-Marxian discursive approach with a political theoretical focus on how issues are given meaning in specific contexts, emphasising discourse as a situated social phenomenon that encompasses a materiality constituted by and constitutive of discourse. Person-centred care has emerged as a new trend in healthcare in Western countries over the past decade, and is in Norway articulated at policy level as 'the patient's healthcare service'. This article recognises person-centredness as a valuable ideal in care relationships and practices at the individual level. However, the article argues that the focus of person-centredness, embedded in a broader ideological trend of individualisation, may also mask a change in the relationship between the state and its citizens that has a depoliticising effect on healthcare at the institutional and structural level of society. As a result, in Norway one of the effects of recent healthcare policy and intervention has arguably been a depoliticisation of care work. Depoliticisation through the trajectory of naturalisation, has the effect of re-informalising care work, clouding its socioeconomic value and making it 'invisible'. This process is discussed as representing a potential challenge to the key societal value of gender equality, since care work is thereby domesticised and re-feminised. The contribution of this article regarding implications for practice development is to inspire professionals to reflect critically on both contemporary discourses and policies of healthcare and some of the potential effects on care work. Finally, the article also aims to provide practitioners with a framework for understanding policy and its articulations at various levels, and thus, it is hoped, contribute to their empowerment.
Sign up to get access to over 50M papers
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
Related papers
Care Work in Crisis. Reclaiming the Nordic Ethos of Care
Book edited by SIRPA WREDE, LEA HENRIKSSON, HÅKON HØST STINA JOHANSSON, BETINA DYBBROE Contents FOREWORD 11 INTRODUCTION 13 Care Work and the Competing Rationalities of Public Policy Sirpa Wrede, Lea Henriksson, Håkon Høst, Stina Johansson and Betina Dybbroe PART I DENMARK INTRODUCTION TO PART I 39 Crisis of Care in A Learning Perspective Betina Dybbroe ONE 47 A Crisis of Learning, Professional Knowledge and Welfare in Care Betina Dybbroe TWO 73 Neglected Opportunities for Personal Development: Care Work in a Perspective of Lifelong Learning. Helle Krogh Hansen THREE 95 A Crisis of Recognition in Care Work for Elderly People? Looking at Professional, Bodily and Gendered Hierarchies for Explanations Anne Liveng PART II FINLAND INTRODUCTION TO PART II 119 Care Work in the Context of a Transforming Welfare State Lea Henriksson and Sirpa Wrede FOUR 129 The Making of Medico-Managerial Care Work Culture in Public Home Care for the Elderly Lea Henriksson and Sirpa Wrede FIVE 151 Staffing Levels and Well-being of the Residents with Dementia Päivi Topo and Saila Sormunen SIX 177 Practical Nurses’ Work Role and Workplace Ethos in an Era of Austerity Laura Tainio and Sirpa Wrede SEVEN 199 Immigrant Nurses in Finland: Political Negotiations on Occupational Membership Suvi Nieminen and Lea Henriksson PART III NORWAY INTRODUCTION TO PART III 221 Care Work and Care Work Education in Norway: Problems of Modernisation Håkon Høst EIGHT 227 Reforming Auxiliary Nurse Education in Norway—A Story of Failed Modernisation Håkon Høst NINE 249 Social Capital in Public Home Care Services Karen Christensen PART IV SWEDEN INTRODUCTION TO PART IV 275 Focus on Knowledge Formation and Care Work Organisation Stina Johansson TEN 283 Academic strength and boundary work: contextualising elderly care Stina Johansson ELEVEN 303 To Organise for Care Work—Work Environment and Relational Aspects of Care Work in Sweden Petra Ahnlund TWELVE 323 Upper Secondary Health Care Programme as Means or Measure? On the Problem of Legitimacy and the View of Knowledge Petra Ahnlund and Stina Johansson THIRTEEN 341 The Neglect of Time as an Aspect of Organising Care Work Katarina Andersson EPILOGUE 363 The Unheard Voices of Care Workers and Care Researchers Kari Wærness
2019
This article puts public policy research in dialogue with gender and politics studies to enhance our understanding of the implementation of care policies. Care policies present interesting problems of implementation because of the multiplicity of aims, values, inequalities, actors and levels of governance involved. Nonetheless, previous research shows two important gaps: 1) the neglect of discursive factors in studies of implementation; and 2) the lack of attention to implementation processes in the analysis of care policies. This article suggests a general framework to address these issues which considers discourse as a transversal factor connecting actors and institutions engaged in policy implementation. The articles in this special issue demonstrate that including discourses in the analysis of care policy implementation makes visible the influence of gender+ norms and the dynamic and contentious processes surrounding them in a variety of institutional arenas, levels, and national contexts.
Nursing Inquiry, 2016
The Swedish welfare debate increasingly focuses on market liberal notions and its healthcare perspective aims for more patient-centered care. This article examines the new Swedish Patient Act describing and analyzing how the patient is constructed in government documents. This study takes a Foucauldian discourse analysis approach following Willig's analysis guide. The act contains an entitlement discourse for patients and a requirement discourse for healthcare personnel. These two discourses are governed by a values-based healthcare discourse. Neo-liberal ideology, in the form of New Public Management discourse, focusing on the value of efficiency and competition, is given a hegemonic position as laws and regulations are used to strengthen it. The new Swedish Patient Act seems to further strengthen this development. The Act underlines the increased entitlement for patients, but it is not legally binding as it offers patients only indirect entitlement to influence and control their care. To safeguard the patient's entitlement under the Patient Act, healthcare personnel should be made aware of the contents of the Act, so that they can contribute to the creation of systems and working methods that facilitate respect of the Act's provisions in daily healthcare work.
Care policies in practice: how discourse matters for policy implementation
Policy and Society
This article puts public policy research in dialogue with gender and politics studies to enhance our understanding of the implementation of care policies. Care policies present interesting problems of implementation because of the multiplicity of aims, values, inequalities, actors and levels of governance involved. Nonetheless, previous research shows two important gaps: 1) the neglect of discursive factors in studies of implementation; and 2) the lack of attention to implementation processes in the analysis of care policies. This article suggests a general framework to address these issues which considers discourse as a transversal factor connecting actors and institutions engaged in policy implementation. The articles in this special issue demonstrate that including discourses in the analysis of care policy implementation makes visible the influence of gender+ norms and the dynamic and contentious processes surrounding them in a variety of institutional arenas, levels, and national contexts.
Nursing Inquiry, 2017
The Danish health care sector currently undergoes changes that imply a gradual transition from an evidence based activity model to a value based quality model centered on patient involvement and value-based governance. The patient naturally occupies a central position in health care, and the transition therefore raises important questions about health care quality and how successive national health quality strategies value quality and ascribe roles and agency to patients. To explore the complexity of these quality strategies, we analyze and discuss how political discourse moments influence the contents of the national health quality strategies and how variation in the construal of patient roles and agency indicate discursive struggle in Danish national health care policy. Underlying theoretical concepts are informed by New Public Management, the welfare state, health communication and discourse theory. Our analytical approach is inspired by Critical Discourse Analysis and combines content analysis with linguistic analysis.
2012
Action research provides a framework for developing practice in healthcare. While developing practice typically implies a combination of patient centeredness, quality improvement and change, conflicts arise in how concepts such as patient centredness are defined. Developing practice invites attention to positionality and engagement with policy directives, trends in clinical care, and other disciplines each with their own language stratification reflecting particular sets of values and beliefs. Our process of engagement is value-based, requiring attention to different and often conflicting languages or worldviews. We understand practice development as responding to different calls from the system, our individual disciplines, patients and changing discourses in healthcare, each exerting different pressures at different times. This paper describes an action research project aimed at developing nursing practice through engaging with two conflicting philosophies of care. We illustrate the contribution made by a particular understanding of Bildung to engaging with positionality, different voices in healthcare and the context of care in a complex environment. Bildung, as self-cultivation, invites engagement with other as an underpinning for developing practice beginning with first person inquiry. The idea of Bildung drew attention to the local moral world of nursing and the experience of dual citizenship. Dual citizenship reflected engagement with conflicting care philosophies and notions of evidence.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.