Islamic Banks and Financial Stability: An Empirical Analysis of the Gulf Countries (original) (raw)
Related papers
Financial Stability of Islamic Banks: Empirical Evidence
The present paper seeks to analyze the financial stability of Islamic banks in Malaysia. Using the time frame of 2008 to 2012, the paper adopts Z-score analysis, Liquidity ratio, Nonperforming financing as well as Credit risk ratio to assess financial stability of Islamic banks. The relevant data were collected from the annual reports of sixteen Islamic banks in Malaysia as obtainable in the bank-scope data base. The finding of the paper reveals that the Z-score is relatively high and thus suggests that Islamic banks at the moment are on the whole financially stable. The paper however finds that Islamic banks at present grant excessive financing while the total assets they invest on financing are on the increase. This therefore portrays an impending financial crisis for Islamic banks if their current financing mechanism is not revisited. The implication of this paper is that Islamic banks have the potentials of absorbing shock and are not likely to experience financial mess in the immediate term provided their liquidity ratios and loan to deposit ratios are regularly kept under check.
Journal of the Knowledge Economy, 2017
The objective of this study is to determine the stability of Islamic and conventional banks of 13 countries during the current subprime and the eurozone crisis. In this study, we used a sample of 69 Islamic and 88 classic banks over the 2003/2012 period. The method of the ordinary least squares is applied to examine the stability of both financial sectors. Our results show that the stability of Islamic banks is a little higher than that of conventional banks.
– The global economic crisis has caused many drastic changes in operation of the global banking system. However, Islamic banking considered to be an emerging force presenting stability and growth. Purpose of this study are the measurement of stability and comparison of Islamic and conventional banks in Gulf Cooperation Council's (GCC) and the Middle East & North Africa's (MENA) countries. New evidence about determinants of performance and risk of Islamic banks vs. conventional banks exists. The research is based on financial data of 144 banks from 16 countries where Islamic and conventional banking institutions operate, for the time period 2003 – 2012, which is divided into two sub-periods: pre-crisis (2003-2007) and post-crisis (2008-2012) in order to investigate the effect of the economic crisis on the stability of Islamic banking institutions.
Islamic and Conventional Banks Stability: A Comparative Analysis
Proceedings of the International Conference, Integrated Microfinance Management for Sustainable Community Development (IMM 2016), 2016
This paper attempts to measure the financial stability for Islamic and conventional banks and compare the result of financial stability between the two kinds of banks. In this study, financial stability will be measured using z-scores. The data sample used in this study include four Indonesian Islamic banks and four Indonesian conventional banks, which is represent by two larger banks and two smaller ones. After z-score is calculated, descriptive statistic and stationarity tests were also conducted to compare the stability results for both banks. A comparative study shows that conventional banks is maybe more stable than Islamic banks. Regression analysis using fixed effect model were conducted to investigate the factors influencing banks stability. Regression result shows the factor which have a significant influence to banks stability are Islamic dummy, size of banks and cost to income ratio. Although other variables such us credit to asset ratio, income diversity and Islamic banks income diversity have no significant effect to banks stability, they have the correct signs.
Islamic and conventional banks' soundness during the 2007–2008 financial crisis
The recent global financial crisis has induced a series of failure of many conventional banks and led to an increased interest in the Islamic banking business model. This paper attempts to answer empirically the following question: What was the effect of the 2007–2008 financial crisis on the soundness of Islamic banks and their conventional peers? Using the Z-score as an indicator of bank stability, our regression analysis (covering a matched sample of 34 Islamic Banks (IBs) and 34 conventional banks (CBs) from 16 countries) shows that there is no significant difference in terms of the effect of the financial crisis on the soundness of IBs and CBs. This finding reveals that IBs are diverging from their theoretical business model which would have allowed them to keep the same level of soundness even during the crisis.
Financial Stability of Conventional and Islamic Banks: Empirical Evidence
International Journal of Accounting and Financial Reporting, 2020
The aim of this paper is to study the stability of Islamic banks vs. conventional banks. Unlike previous works on this topic, we used profitability, solvency, productivity, investment and risk indicators, as well as macroeconomic indicators. Likewise, we used effectiveness and efficiency indicators, determined via the SFA and DEA method respectively. The banks in our sample were selected based on their contribution to the total assets of both types of finance. This selection method allowed us to have a global idea on the effectiveness, efficiency, risk and stability of the two banking sectors. This empirical investigation revealed that Sharia-compatible banks are more efficient than conventional banks. In contrast, Islamic banks are less efficient and riskier than conventional banks. They lose on average 5.795% and 3.9413% of their assets, respectively, as credit risk and operational risk. In terms of market risk, Islamic banks are less risky than conventional banks. They lost 3,214...
Islamic Banks and Financial Stability in the GCC: An Empirical Analysis
2012
Since the inception of Islamic banking in the late 1970s, it has grown rapidly all over the world, especially in the GCC where Islamic banking has rapidly become a substantial part of the financial system. The ongoing turbulence in global financial markets highlights the importance of financial stability for broader economic developments. It is argued that Islamic banking is a viable alternative to promote economic growth and is better-suited to absorb macro-financial shocks because structural advantages over the traditi onal banking. Given the recent political uprisings in the GCC, the financial stability in these countries has become a major concern not only for countries themselves but also for the rest of the world. This study aims to empirically analyse the financial strength of Islamic banks based on the data covering individual Islamic and commercial banks in the GCC, including Turkey. It reveals that the financial stability of the large commercial banks is more stable than t...
Financial Stability of Islamic and Conventional Banks in Saudi Arabia
Islamic banks are characterised by the compliance to Islamic laws and practices, the main ones being the prohibition of interest and loans trading. Remarkably, during the 2008-2009 …nancial crisis, when a large number of conventional banks have announced bankruptcy, no single Islamic bank failure has been reported. However, there is no clear consensus in the literature on question of whether Islamic banks are more or less stable than conventional banks. We study a sample of Saudi banks over a period centred on the 2008 …nancial crisis. The main conclusions are: (i) the variables typically used in …nancial stability studies may be non-stationary, a feature ignored in the literature; (ii) individual heterogeneity may matter more than the conventional or islamic nature of the banks.
2015
The financial crises are considered the major challenges facing the prosperity and stability of the banking system and menace its stability. Several studies on the financial and banking sector have demonstrated that Islamic banks have shown more financial robustness and stability compared to conventional banks, over periods of financial crises. This research aims to measure the stability extent of the Saudi Arabia banks including Islamic banks and conventional banks using quarterly data from 2005 to 2011. This period is characterized by the global financial crisis shocks (2007-2008). The sample used is composed of six banks including two Islamic banks (AlRajhi Bank and AlBilad Bank) and four traditional banks (Riyad Bank, Saudi Investment Bank, Saudi British Bank and Saudi American Bank). This sample represents an important part of 64% of the Saudi banking sector and covers close to two-thirds of banks whose shares are traded on the Saudi stock market. The research focuses on three ...