Alice in Wonderland: from nonsense to nonsensical (original) (raw)
It has taken Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland a little over a century from being regarded as nonsense, to become nonsensical, as is so vividly highlighted by the book’s songs/poems. Kenneth Rothwell, in his History of Shakespeare on Screen, lists seven kinds of derivatives a film may take when a literary work is adapted for the screen, none of which presupposes ‘accuracy’ with the original text. While the Disney adaptation may take credit for much of the confusion in the modern mind (even to the point where David Crystal accredits the Mad Hatter with the concept of a Happy Unbirthday), we need to look further afield to understand the failure of present-day audience’s to connect with the aesthetic of Carroll’s book. Adaptation for subsequent generations of a book Carroll wrote for an audience who were well-versed in the songs he was parodying, and who were informed about the people and events to whom references were being made, demands interpretation. While visually, iconic images from Alice may still be employed to satirise people and events, the power of the songs/poems has been lost in transmission, such that they now bemuse rather than amuse. The paper draws upon resources outlining the reception of Carroll’s book in his time, and attempts to examine the failure of the songs to resonate with today’s ‘audiences’, while other works written at the same time, notably those of Gilbert and Sullivan, have continued to be relevant.
Related papers
The Fantastic and the Feminine Sublime of Carroll’s Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland
2022
The study presents a close analysis of the immersive yet disorienting textual space of Lewis Carroll’s Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland in order to explore its sublime aesthetics. As a piece of portal fantasy, the work enables readers to enter into the transcendent sphere of uncontrolled imagination via the adventures of the prophetic Dream Child, eliciting what David Sandner has defined as both a reformulation and an extension of the Romantic sublime: the fantastic sublime. A more favourable attitude towards the elusiveness of meaning in the text lies in Barbara Claire Freeman’s feminine sublime, which prefers the excessive and unrepresentable to exclusion and control.
As Above So Below? Madness and Nonsense in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland
Alice in Wonderland in Film and Popular Culture, 2022
This chapter studies the nonsensical nature of Lewis Carroll’s Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, but diverges from the bulk of nonsense theory in its inclusion of madness into our postulations on nonsense and meaning-making practices within the text. We begin by exploring the ways in which Western hegemonic societal discourses have defined nonsense and madness. We use this knowledge as a foundation from which to consider our primary thread of inquiry, which is the nature of interpretation. Interrogating binaric trends of normative hermeneutic practices offers insight into the ways in which madness and nonsense function as two dynamic phenomena. We end this chapter with a consideration of auto-theory as a respectful methodology of reading.
VIOLENCE IN THE POEMS IN THE ALICE BOOKS AND LEWIS CARROLL'S INTENDED AUDIENCE
Insight, 2014
Through a close reading of some of the major poems in Lewis Carroll’s Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Through the Looking Glass , this essay examines how the author subverts the Victorian educator’s notion that lessons must always offer a moral code by which children should live. Though originally intended for a child audience, the Alice books appear to have messages for an adult audience as well. The poems, especially, highlight the violence perpetrated by adults that children must become aware of in order to survive as they grow older. In his own way, Carroll was offering a didactic text that adults as well as children could learn from, even today.
Yesterday (14th Jan) was the day that was commemorated as the 125th anniversary of the death of Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, better known as Lewis Carroll. It's been 125 years since the passing of the English author, poet and mathematician, who is best known for his works 'Alice's Adventures in Wonderland' (1865) and 'Through the Looking-Glass' (1871). These two stories, filled with riddles, fascinating allegories and bizarre touchpoints, have permeated practically every aspect of popular culture and provided inspiration for countless films, series, songs, video games and various works of art.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.