How shamanism and group selection may reveal the origins of schizophrenia (original) (raw)
Related papers
Evolutionary perspectives on schizophrenia
Canadian journal of psychiatry. Revue canadienne de psychiatrie, 2003
The theory of evolution may be relevant to psychiatric disorders. Evolution reflects changes in genes throughout time. Thus, evolutionary forces can shape any phenotype that is genetically rooted and that possesses a long history. Schizophrenia is likely an ancient condition with a substantial genetic component. Since the 1960s, several researchers have applied evolutionary principles to the study of schizophrenia. In general, schizophrenia is either viewed as an evolutionary advantageous condition or as a disadvantageous byproduct of normal brain evolution. This paper reviews major evolutionary explanations--historical and current--that speculate on the possible origins of schizophrenia.
Can the new epidemiology of schizophrenia help elucidate its causation?
The supposed universality of the incidence and prevalence of schizophrenia has been seriously challenged. It is now widely accepted that the life-time prevalence and incidence of this disorder vary considerably in time and place. As a result, there has been renewed interest in environmental causation of schizophrenia. There are few extant formulations that have successfully integrated the available new evidence into a coherent theory for its causation. The outgroup intolerance hypothesis is an attempt to integrate this evidence. It proposes that schizophrenia is the result of a mismatch between the social brain as shaped by evolution and the new social conditions of the post-neolithic. The hypothesis can provide an explanation for (i) the higher risk to migrants, (ii) the ethnic density phenomenon, (iii) the increased risk to individuals who have grown up in cities and (iv) the putative low risk in hunter-gatherer societies. Evidence is presented from a range of disciplines and sources including epidemiology, psychopathology, social psychology and clinical trials in support of this hypothesis. A range of testable predictions follow from the hypothesis.
Schizophrenia as one extreme of a sexually selected fitness indicator
Schizophrenia Research, 2004
Schizophrenia remains an evolutionary paradox. Its delusions, hallucinations and other symptoms begin in adolescence or early adulthood and so devastate sexual relationships and reproductive success that selection should have eliminated the disorder long ago. Yet it persists as a moderately heritable disorder at a global 1% prevalence—too high for new mutations at a few genetic loci. We suggest that schizophrenia persists and involves many loci because it is the unattractive, low-fitness extreme of a highly variable mental trait that evolved as a fitness (‘‘good genes’’) indicator through mutual mate choice. Here we show that this hypothesis explains many key features of schizophrenia and predicts that some families carry modifier alleles that increase the indicator’s neurodevelopmental sensitivity to heritable fitness and condition. Such alleles increase the extent to which high-fitness family members develop impressive courtship abilities and achieve high reproductive success, but also increase the extent to which low-fitness family members develop schizophrenia. Here we introduce this fitness indicator model of schizophrenia, discuss its explanatory power, explain how it resolves the evolutionary paradox, discuss its implications for gene hunting, and identify some empirically testable predictions as directions for further research.
Schizophrenia, Evolution and the Borders of Biology. On Huxley et al.'s 1964 Paper
History of Psychiatry, 2010
In October 1964, Julian Huxley, Ernst Mayr, Humphrey Osmond and Abram Hoffer co-published a controversial paper in Nature, in which they tried to explain the persistence of schizophrenia from an evolutionary perspective. This article will elucidate how the reputed authors composed this paper to make it a strong argument for biological psychiatry. Through a close reading of their correspondence, it will furthermore clarify the elements which remained unspoken in the paper, but which were elementary in its genesis. The first was the dominance of psychoanalytical theory in (American) psychiatry -a dominance which the authors wanted to break. The second was the ongoing discussion on the boundaries of biological determinism and the desirability of a new kind of eugenics. As such, the Huxley et al. paper can be used to study the central issues of psychiatry in a pivotal era of its history.
Schizophrenia Bulletin, 2020
The persistence of schizophrenia in human populations at a high prevalence and with a large heritability estimate despite reduced fertility and increased mortality rate is a Darwinian paradox. This may be likely if the genomic components that predispose to schizophrenia are also advantageous for the acquisition of important human traits, such as language and cognition. Accordingly, an emerging group of genomic markers of recent evolution in humans, namely human accelerated regions (HARs), since our divergence from chimpanzees, are gaining importance for neurodevelopmental disorders, such as schizophrenia. We hypothesize that variants within HARs may affect the expression of genes under their control, thus contributing to disease etiology. A total of 49 HAR single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were prioritized from the complete repertoire of HARs (n = 2737) based on their functional relevance and prevalence in the South Asian population. Test of association using 2 independent schi...
The ethology of psychiatric populations II: Darwinian neuropsychiatry
Clin Neuropsychiatry, 2006
This article gives an overview of how a knowledge of Ethology, the branch of Zoology that studies animals in their natural setting and is sometimes called the biology of behavior, can help the clinical and research psychiatrist in evaluation, treatment and treatment evaluation by reconnecting Psychiatry with its Neuro-Psychiatric roots as the medical specialty concerned with specific disorders of brain and voluntary muscle.
The diagnostic concept of schizophrenia: its history, evolution, and future prospects
Dialogues in Clinical Neuroscience, 2010
o the best of present knowledge, schizophrenia is a disorder with variable phenotypic expression and poorly understood, complex etiology, involving a major genetic contribution, as well as environmental factors interacting with the genetic susceptibility. Multiple genes and different combinations of their polymorphic variants provide the genetic background, with a proportion of the transmitted genotypes remaining clinically unexpressed. Schizophrenia occurs in diverse populations at comparable rates, 1 which is consistent with an ancient origin 271 S t a t e o f t h e a r t
Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2004
Schizophrenia is a worldwide, prevalent disorder with a multifactorial but highly genetic aetiology. A constant prevalence rate in the face of reduced fecundity has caused some to argue that an evolutionary advantage exists in unaffected relatives. Here, I critique this adaptationist approach, and review – and find wanting – Crow's “speciation” hypothesis. In keeping with available biological and psychological evidence, I propose an alternative theory of the origins of this disorder. Schizophrenia is a disorder of the social brain, and it exists as a costly trade-off in the evolution of complex social cognition. Paleoanthropological and comparative primate research suggests that hominids evolved complex cortical interconnectivity (in particular, frontotemporal and frontoparietal circuits) to regulate social cognition and the intellectual demands of group living. I suggest that the ontogenetic mechanism underlying this cerebral adaptation was sequential hypermorphosis and that it...