“The “Fierce People” in the Context of US Foreign Politics: An Historical Anthropology Approach to Napoleon Chagnon’s Interpretation of the Yanomami” (original) (raw)
Related papers
Thoughts on Violence and Modernity in Latin America
2020
A history without violence would, for us at least, be unrecognizable as history. Yet, paradoxically, violence as phenomenon appears to exist apart from the history in which it is omnipresent. Violence seems, almost unconsciously, to found the historical imagination itself and at the same time to exist apart from it, as a moral or metaphysical absolute. In the final analysis this no doubt has to do with the impossibility of disassociating the idea of violence from that of death as physical annihilation. Taken to its extreme, violence could end history by destroying virtually all historical agents. Indeed, it must rank as one of the great historical feats of modernity that is has actualized what was before this merely theoretical possibility and even learned to make us accommodate ourselves to it in our daily lives. Alongside the abstract repugnance it universally merits in the language of official 'values,' violence as means and as sheer adaptation advances at a sure and accelerating pace. Whatever they may convey on the level of official historical sanctions, the stories and images of catastrophic violence-whether of
The enduring legacy of the fighting stick among rural Venezuelans has led me to examine the persistence of stick, machete and knife fighting in Venezuela and what it has to say about modernity. I look at one example of a global tradition of living civilian combative traditions still practiced and transmitted to protect one's body, command respect or protect ones property from expropriation at the same time the student is taught a respect for life and the values of the community. One element missing or downplayed in the scholastic literature of many combative systems is a consideration of the emotional commitment needed to succeed in combat. Among those who practice martial arts as a survival tool there is the recognition that a fighter must develop both insensitivity to the suffering of others as well as an emotional detachment to analyze the situation. In what I call the 'Warriors Habitus' I suggest these types of aggressive and pitiless dispositions are not purely biologically based but are often culturally mediated and shift through time and space in relations of apprenticeship with skilled combative teachers through the transmission of new ways of holding and moving the body in conjunction with material technology. The material for this study arises from a long-term project looking at the extent and role of stick fighting in rural Ven-ezuela. Between 1998 and 2013, 4 trips ranging between 2 weeks and 7 months were made. Data collection relied on semi-formal and informal interviews as well as apprenticeships. Archival research and a literature review of relevant works were also employed to set stick fighting in a broader context. A common response to the question of what qualities does it take to become a good stick fighter is the idea that a love of stick fighting should 'be in the blood' , or 'one must like it' suggesting an inherent trait. However, the willingness of teachers to train and socialize students in the intricacies of garrote suggests this trait may be open to modification. The ability or willingness to 'go to the dark side' or deliberately target vital or vulnerable areas of an opponent's body in order to quickly and efficiently end a combative encounter and the way this disposition is cultivated and managed through training is seen as vital part of training. In conjunction with the desire to close in and engage an opponent, equally valued is the ability to maintain a sense of emotional detachment in order to seek out and exploit any weakness in the opponent's defense. The successful domination of an opponent often results in overwhelming feelings of elation or joy that can lead to the active seeking out further combative encounters to test one's skills and access the intense feelings of power and joy that comes from winning. In order to prevent a student from becoming a threat to their own community the ability to mediate one's response depending on the modality of combat is treated almost as importantly among garroteros. Discussion. Traditional warrior arts are concerned with technical efficiency first and foremost and morality last. The training of the body and the emotions for combat while retaining a sense for the humanity of others is what I call the 'Warriors Habitus'. I find this a useful concept to explore how different combative systems over time and through space have wrestled with and tried different solutions to deal with the realities of violence facing communities on an everyday basis while at the same time cultivating a sense of the importance of human life without which a community would destroy itself. As it took shape in Venezuela, this type of 'emotion work' or learned restraint acts as a type of 'civilizing processes for garroteros. Students are exposed to sets of locally developed bodily movements in conjunction with a range of available weapons to channel their desire for high risk acts as well as a sense of emotional detachment when fighting as well as the ability to turn away from the pleasures associated with victory.
In 1968, Napoleon Chagnon published his best-selling ethnography The Fierce People , which established the Yanomami as a violent people in the public eye for decades to come. Indeed, in 1976, Time described the Yanomami as a " rather horrifying " culture which can only be described in terms of animal behaviour akin to baboons [Time 1976: 37], and over the coming decades, horror films like Canibal Holocausto would continue to fuel public imagination, declaring the Yanomami people as lovers of sadistic orgies [Ramos 1987: 296]. These examples mark but fragments in a convoluted puzzle, and at its centre lies one of anthropology's most divisive debates, the Fierce People controversy. The controversy began with Chagnon's book, and later with his infamous Science article, where he presented the argument that the Yanomami who kill the most do so out of evolutionary reasons to gain reproductive advantage. The arguments of this debate extend beyond the Yanomami, to general treatment of Amerindian groups and the public's interpretation of their " violent " behaviour.
Armed combative traditions of Latin America and the Caribbean: a hoplological overview
Revista Artes Marciales Asiatica, 2020
Over the last few decades, there has been a resurgent interest in New World martial art traditions. The bulk of the attention has focused on African and African diasporic traditions. Many well-researched books and articles have resulted from this focus. Yet, there is much less interest regarding other combative modalities brought to the shores of the New World. For centuries immigrant communities have brought with them sophisticated combative systems that persist to this day. As part of a broader hoplological project, this article seeks to identify and document the diverse armed combative systems still extant and practiced in South America and the Caribbean that have not transformed into solely institutionalized sports or recreational pastimes. With few exceptions these arts continue to be taught, practiced, and used in a variety of informal situations to ensure one's property or public reputation or as part of an economic strategy in the informal economy. At times paralleling and overlapping these more pragmatic goals, these arts also persist as a way of preserving older cultural moralities, ethics, and forms of masculinity. Tradiciones de combate con armas en América Latina y el Caribe: una visión hoplológica Resumen Durante las últimas décadas ha resurgido el interés por las tradiciones marciales del Nuevo Mundo. La mayor parte de esta atención se ha centrado en las tradiciones africanas y en las tradiciones africanas de la diáspora, publicándose numerosos libros y artículos bien fundamentados en la investigación. Sin embargo, ha existido un interés mucho menos respecto a otras modalidades combativas traídas a las costas del Nuevo Mundo. Durante siglos, las comunidades inmigrantes han llevado consigo sofisticados sistemas combativos que aún perviven en nuestros días. Como parte de un proyecto hoplológico más amplio, este artículo busca identificar y documentar los diversos sistemas de combate armado aún existentes y practicados en América del Sur y el Caribe, que no se han transformado en meros pasatiempos deportivos o recreativos. Con pocas excepciones, estas artes continúan siendo enseñadas, practicadas y utilizadas en diversas situaciones informales para asegurar la propiedad o la reputación pública de los individuos, o como parte de una estrategia económica de la economía informal. En ocasiones, de forma paralela y superpuesta a estos objetivos más pragmáticos, estas artes también persisten como modos de preservar formas culturales de moralidad, ética y masculinidad más antiguas. Tradições de combate com armas na América Latina e no Caribe: uma visão hoplológica Resumo Nas últimas décadas, tem havido um interesse ressurgente nas tradições de artes marciais do Novo Mundo. A maior parte da atenção se concentrou nas tradições africanas, incluindo as de diáspora. Muitos livros e artigos bem pesquisados resultaram desse foco. No entanto, há muito menos interesse em relação a outras modalidades de combate trazidas para as costas do Novo Mundo. Durante séculos, as comunidades imigrantes trouxeram consigo sistemas combativos sofisticados que persistem até hoje. Como parte de um projeto hoplológico mais amplo, este artigo procura identificar e documentar os diversos sistemas de combate armado ainda existentes e praticados na América do Sul e no Caribe que não se transformaram apenas em esportes institucionalizados ou passatempos recreativos. Com poucas exceções, essas artes continuam a ser ensinadas, praticadas e usadas em uma variedade de situações informais para garantir a propriedade ou a reputação pública ou como parte de uma estratégica econômica informal. Às vezes, paralelamente e sobrepondo-se a esses objetivos mais pragmáticos, essas artes também persistem como uma maneira de preservar moralidades culturais mais antigas, ética e formas de masculinidade.
The role of violence in the classics of Brazilian Social Thought
Ciências Sociais Unisinos, 2018
This essay had the objective of problematizing the role of violence in Brazilian social life and of discussing the relevance it poses in three classics of Brazilian Social Thought. By analyzing how the issue was treated in Casa-Grande & Senzala, Raízes do Brasil, and Formação do Brasil Contemporâneo, we aimed at defending the argument that, although the emergence of violence appears to be, to certain common sense, a new phenomenon, its widespread employment has been an integrative element of social interactions in Brazil, but is mainly used against more vulnerable segments of society. Furthermore, by taking advantage of each author’s conceptual apparatuses, we introduced a discussion not only about the role of violence in the Brazilian colonial era, but also about its continuity over time and the social-historical manifestations it has in contemporaneity. We concluded that these seminal books give support to our argument insofar as violence appears in all of them as an element that grants cohesion to society as it ensures the submission of the dominated to the dominant.