The Spanish-Catalan political crisis as represented in the UK, French and German press (2010-2017) (original) (raw)
Related papers
Journal of Political Marketing, 8 (1), pp. 59-69, 2009
This article uses the analysis of the 2004 European elections in the Spanish press as a case study that can be broached from the agenda building and framing theoretical frameworks. We seek to compare the media agenda in the 2004 and 1999 European elections by use of a content analysis in order to evaluate the impact of new real-world conditions (the March 11 Madrid bombings) and new strategies of political actors after the March 14 general elections concerning foreign affairs on the news coverage. The research also aims to advance framing research by identifying news frames (as the “conflict frame” and the “political game frame”) that can link this study with prior ones.
The War in Ukraine and the EU's Geopolitical Role in Spanish Media Discourses
Media and Communication, 2023
The EU's ability to protect common interests and effectively address the challenges faced by its members relating to external threats is one of the most debated questions in the European landscape. Understandably, the war in Ukraine has had a major impact on discourses regarding the EU Common Security and Defense Policy, granting them more space and thus visibility in the media and public debates. Our study examines Spanish media discourses about the EU's geopolitical role and, more specifically, to what extent such discourses foster or hamper European integration processes. To collect data and carry out this study, we selected six media outlets based on their ownership, ideological stance, consumption frequency, and impact on public opinion. Our sample includes 540 news items, collected between July 2021 and March 2022. Our discourse analysis benefits from, inter alia, a Foucauldian framework that focuses on the sayable, conservation, memory, reactivation, and appropriation. In addition, we also identify communicative strategies that are employed to promote different discourses, as well as possible policy alternatives, concerning the EU's geopolitical role and future prospects.
American Behavioral Scientist, 2017
Editorials represent a newspaper's principal means of ideological positioning and serve to identify the attitude of each newspaper and its readership to some of the main actors in any given conflict, especially those that are political in nature. Catalonia's independence movement has experienced a surge in recent years. The turning point came in July 2010, after Spain's constitutional court ruled against some aspects of Catalonia's Statute of Autonomy (the legislation regulating the relationship between the Catalan autonomous community and the Spanish state). The ruling annulled some of the articles of the statute. The demonstration in support of Catalan independence that took place on September 11, 2012, was considered the most important among several mass rallies held for this purpose over successive years on Catalonia's National Day. This article presents the results of a qualitative and quantitative analysis of editorial articles published around these two key dates, with the goal of studying each newspaper's treatment of political actors and their degree of identification with these actors. Their use of arguments aimed at persuading readers and legitimizing a given position during the specified time periods in 2010 and 2012 will also be studied. The study focuses on the editorial articles published by several newspapers in four distinct regional contexts: Catalonia, Valencia, the Basque Country, as well as the
International Journal of Communication, 2013
This article analyzes how the press in Belgium and in Spain reports on Catalonia and Flanders, respectively. Grounding our arguments in the theories of national identities and the domestication of the news, we propose the concept of the mirror effect to explain the logics of comparison of two different contexts. Combining a content analysis of eight major newspapers with a qualitative discourse approach, the article shows that reporting on political conflicts such as the ones analyzed tends to use “the other’s case” as a model to learn from that may or may not be followed. The results also indicate considerable differences between the Belgian and Spanish cases, the latter being more politicized and focused on the other’s national conflict.
Polarization in Media Discourses on Europeanization in Spain
Politics and Governance, 2023
Political and media polarization has had a detrimental impact on democratic principles and democratic processes on a global scale. In Europe, such polarization has eroded the trust in national and European institutions and has challenged the basic values that stand at the heart of the European integration project. The aim of this study is to analyze Spanish media discourses on Europeanization, with an attempt to identify key areas in which polarizing narratives related to Europeanization are more prevalent. To conduct our study, six national media outlets were selected based on four criteria: media format, ownership, ideology, and consumption. A final sample of 540 news items collected between July 2021 to March 2022 was selected for analysis. Using a qualitative methodological approach, the study was carried out in two stages. In the first phase, we conducted a content analysis to identify the main topics discussed in relation to the European Union and the actors represented in them. This led to the identification of polarizing narratives and discourses emerging in the context of the discussed topics. In the second phase, we used critical discourse analysis to analyze polarizing discourses.
Agents of transnational debate across Europe: The press in emerging European public sphere
Javnost the Public, 2008
This article aims at assessing the theoretical and empirical role of the national press in the emerging European public sphere. The study draws on Europeanisation as the emerging framework for transnational communication across European nation states. It assumes that the press itself may perform as a political actor and make a substantial contribution to Europeanisation by advocating European integration and by broadening its scope to include the perspectives of all EU member states and the EU itself. In order to discern the infl uence or role of the media-its "voice"-this study analysed the content of editorials of 28 newspapers in seven European countries along two dimensions. First, the receptiveness of the press towards European perspectives is investigated by measuring the degree to which its editorials feature European scopes. Second, the study examines newspapers' attitudes about European integration as a political project. The overall fi ndings point to a remarkable representation of European perspectives, and substantial support for EU integration, by the national press in Germany, France, Italy and Spain. The newspapers in the Netherlands and Switzerland were somewhat more parochial, but still supportive. We also see that the United Kingdom (UK) media deviate substantially from these patterns. This study concludes that, in contrast with the fi ndings of earlier studies, the press must be regarded as a signifi cant agent of Europeanisation fostering transnational linkages of public debate.
The Catalan political process in the leading Spanish, Catalan and British newspapers
In cases of sociopolitical conflict, such as the current political situation between Catalonia and Spain, the media play an active role in the construction and legitimation of the narrative of events. The aim of this communication is to analyse the construction of the news story about the last 27 September 2015 regional elections in Catalonia, cast as a plebiscitary vote by the pro-independence parties. The study focuses on the analysis of three leading newspapers defined by different regional and political realities: El Mundo (Spain), Ara (Catalonia) and The Daily Telegraph (United Kingdom).
Revista Latina de Comunicación Social, 2023
Introduction: Spain's gradual integration into the European Union through the development of institutions and economic and structural changes is intrinsic to the construction of a pro-European public opinion in which the media have actively participated. Objectives: This research aims to analyse the topics disseminated by the leading Spanish media to detect how the EU is represented in these themes, determine the main, adjacent and counter-discourses and find out the degree of North/South polarisation. Methodology: By content analysis and critical discourse analysis, this paper studies 543 units from the Spanish media El País, El Confidencial, ABC, El Diario.es, RTVE and Antena 3 from July 2021 to March 2022. Discussion and conclusion: Following the methodological application, the results obtained allow us to conclude that the construction of Europeanisation in the Spanish media is constructed about specific issues, and after an in-depth analysis of the energy issue, we can affirm that media coverage is neutral in general terms. Europeanisation is presented from a role with the greater weight of Spain in the common project than in previous historical stages presented in the introduction
2021
The study of nationalism and the media has thus far largely ignored the role that the media play in multi-national states and stateless nations, where nationhood is contested. This paper uncovers the role that discourses of everyday nationalism play in the Spanish press by approaching the often disregarded media portrayal of the Basque Country as a national minority in Spain. Furthermore, this study focuses on the often overlooked post-conflict representation of the Basque Country and evaluates the extent to which traditional media narratives about the Basque conflict can still be found in the post-conflict era. This paper looks at the ways in which the Basque Country is represented online and in legacy newspapers during episodes of everyday nationalism, as well as discovering the extent to which different Spanish press outlets across the political spectrum represent the Basque Country differently. This is done through a critical discourse analysis of opinion pieces published in El País, El Mundo, OkDiario and El Salto Diario about two news episodes: the 2018 Altsasu incident court case and the 2020 Basque regional elections. The findings show how Spanish nationalist discourses are employed across all four news outlets analysed. On the one hand, El Salto Diario employs a subtle form of everyday nationalism in its discourse. On the other hand, the type of nationalist discourse found in OkDiario, El Mundo and El País echoes that of the Spanish far right despite the supposed political differences between these three news outlets. The type of discourse found relies on a simplistic ‘us-vs-them’ narrative as well as a problematic narrative of ‘terrorism’ traditionally used in Spanish media. This study also concludes that the Spanish nationalist discourse of the far right permeates a wide range of apparently politically diverse news outlets.
Framing European Politics Framing European Politics: A Content Analysis of Press and Television News
We investigated the prevalence of 5 news frames identified in earlier studies on framing and framing effects: attribution of responsibility, conflict, human interest , economic consequences, and morality. We content analyzed 2,601 newspaper stories and 1,522 television news stories in the period surrounding the Amsterdam meetings of European heads of state in 1997. Our results showed that, overall, the attribution of responsibility frame was most commonly used in the news, followed by the conflict, economic consequences, human interest, and morality frames, respectively. The use of news frames depended on both the type of outlet and the type of topic. Most significant differences were not between media (television vs. the press) but between sensationalist vs. serious types of news outlets. Sober and serious newspapers and television news programs more often used the responsibility and conflict frames in the presentation of news, whereas sensationalist outlets more often used the human interest frame. Over the past 25 years, an impressive literature has contributed to our understanding of frames and framing effects (