Blaming on Westminster and building Charismatic Leaderships in the post-Devolution Scottish National Party. (original) (raw)
Related papers
Social Constituency and Ideological Profile: Scottish Nationalism in the 1990s
Political Studies, 1994
Using data from the 1992 Scottish and British Election Surveys, the authors examine various models which might explain the changes in the level and type of Scottish National Party voting. In the analysis they are also concerned with voters for other parties who support the central SNP policy: independencq for Scotland. The protest, relative deprivation, identity, and new social movement models are stated and explored. The authors conclude that a major problem for the SNP is that the basic Scottish identity, to which the Nationalists want to appeal, is felt almost as strongly by Labour'voters as by those who choose the SNP. The SNP has not been able to establish a reputation as a credible party of government which could take over the role of the spokesperson for the national community. At the same time, it is not likely to disappear as the major challenger in Scottish politics.
Politics without society: explaining the rise of the Scottish National Party
British Politics
The Scottish National Party (SNP) has emerged as one of the most successful national-regional parties in Europe. Yet the SNP was a fringe group for most of its history, with limited organization and electoral viability. What explains its ascent? Drawing on archival research and interviews with former party officials, this article argues that key developments that positioned the party for its current success took place in the 1970s, decades before its electoral climb. It was during this time the party established its organizational structure, social democratic ideology, and centre-left policy orientation, but without establishing the links to collateral organizations in Scottish society that had been crucial for winning elections. The article argues that it was, paradoxically, the absence of such linkages that served to accelerate the party's rise in the 2000s, as secularization and deindustrialization weakened the socioeconomic foundations of the Scottish Conservative Party, with its close ties to the Church of Scotland, and, more significantly, of the Labour Party, which saw its trade union base deteriorate. Under these conditions, the SNP was uniquely positioned to capture unaligned voters, recruit party leaders, and take advantage of the new constitutional environment created by the establishment of the Scottish Parliament in 1999.
The Scottish Labour Party Under Devolution
2003
Devolution in the UK provides a rare opportunity to assess the effect of devolving institutions of government on political parties. Devolution has occurred at a time when one party, Labour, holds substantive power at national and devolved levels so the effects of devolution on the party's organisation and management merits close attention.. This paper explores the impact on the Labour Party in Scotland of the new constitutional settlement.
Party Behaviour in Scotland: Issue Ownership, Contagion and Territorialisation
This paper examines the territorialisation of party behaviour in Scotland since devolution, and in particular the "contagion effect" of the national question on the positions of Scotland"s political parties. It is argued that the traditional class-based understandings of party competition have limited application in Scottish politics unless they are considered in tandem with the strength, and often pre-eminence, of a territorial dimension (in similarity to Quebec and many other substate nations where territorial concerns and demands for self-government are central). Yet, far from constituting a divisive cleavage between parties in Scotland, we argue that the national question has become more of a valence issue in Scottish politics, whereby no party would dare to speak against the political empowerment of the Scottish nation. Instead, parties have adopted a range of positions in favour of increased territorial autonomy, including support for fiscal autonomy, the creation of a cosmopolitan Scottish identity, and increased control over welfare and social services. With all of the bluster between the "yes" and the "no" campaigns in the independence referendum in 2014, it would be easy to ignore the fact that, in terms of a national yardstick, all of the parties in Scotland are moving in the same direction: towards greater selfdetermination. This has not always been the case. The "national question" has often proved a divisive issue in Scottish politics, with the leading British mainstream parties the Labour Party and the Conservative Partytaking (often bitterly) opposing positions to Scottish "home rule" at different points in time.
In recent years, the Scottish Labour Party has lost its once dominant position in Scottish politics. Its support has collapsed, and it now faces multiple political challenges, relating both to cleavages in Scottish politics over the constitution and Brexit, and to divisions within the party over its leadership and direction. Employing semi- structured elite interviews with key figures within the party hierarchy and focus groups with grassroots activists, this paper examines the causes of this crisis through an analysis of party members’ views. It identifies sources of the decline of Scottish Labour in unresolved disagreements over strategy and identity. Unable to coalesce around a distinctly Scottish strategy for competing in a multidimensional, multilevel political space with both civic nationalist challengers and conservative defenders of the constitutional status quo, in 2017, Scottish Labour reasserted a class-based identity, seeking to compete largely on the left–right economic dimension of politics. Instead of marking out a Scottish political identity, the Scottish Labour Party chose leftward national alignment with the Jeremy Corbyn leadership of the UK Labour Party. The electoral and political failure of this strategy offers important lessons for understanding the prospects of multilevel social-democratic parties.
British Politics, 2024
This article presents an original account of the strategic options available to political parties in the form of the position, salience and rhetoric framework. It builds upon existing accounts of party competition by conceiving of rhetorical justification as a distinct tool in the armoury of party strategists alongside the manipulation of policy position and issue salience. It applies that framework to the case of post-devolution Scotland via a quantitative text analysis of the written record of First Ministers Questions sessions in the Scottish Parliament. It shows how the main political parties in Scotland between them utilised all of the strategic tools contained within the PSR framework in the early twenty-first century up to the most recent 2021 election to the Holyrood parliament. It argues that the tactical choices the main Scottish parties made within this framework can help explain the differing electoral fortunes experienced by those parties in the post-devolution era.
The Irresistible Rise of Politial Nationalism in Scotland and Its Origins
Вестник Удмуртского университета. Социология. Политология. Международные отношения, 2018
The article will examine the rise of the Scottish National Party (SNP) and, consequently, the history of Scottish nationalism in the 20 th century. Established in 1934 the SNP has, in the last 50 years, moved from being a marginal conservative party to a social-democratic force which is both respected and feared, and which has defined and reshaped Scottish politics, brought the Scottish dimension at the centre stage and forced other political parties to respond in their terms. At the end of the Sixties, the party still had a rather vague political program which involved an independent Scotland within the British Commonwealth and, on the economic side, an "interclassist third way" between capitalism and socialism. During the 70's, the decline of heavy and shipbuilding industries and the closure of coal mines contributed to change social relations and political affiliations in Scotland. In this period, the SNP's politics was self-proclaimed as centreleft. With the entry into the party of an increasing number of workers (skilled and unskilled), students and members of the urban middle classes, the ideological orientation of Scottish nationalism underwent a left turn, while the party's stand on the issue of independence remained rather ambiguous. Certainly, both socialism and counter-culture had a limited impact in Scotland but, for a new generation of political activists, the Conservative and Labour parties had little to offer in the way of dynamism. The SNP recruited a new generation of activists (for instance, the so-called 79 Group) who were more in tune with some aspects of the counter-culture, while nationalism gained a new intellectual respectability with the leftist notion of anti-colonialism. In the 80's the Scottish nationalism began to become more comfortable asserting a full social democratic outlook. The party's identity became genuinely anchored to the centre-left, and the SNP replaced the Labor Party-more moderate and looking for a new center-oriented political location-in representing the interests of workers in Scotland. The paper aims to demonstrate the importance of economic factors in shaping political nationalism which, in the Scottish case, has seen the SNP increase the electoral support, undermine the territorial unity of the UK and become a true social democratic party able to challenge leftist political parties on ideological grounds.