‘Embarrassing the State’: The ‘Ordinary’ Prisoner Rights Movement in Ireland, 1972–6 (original) (raw)
Related papers
Political Prisoners and the Irish Conflict 100 Years On
The Howard journal of crime and justice, 2021
This article traces the impact of Irish political prisoners on the prison landscape in Ireland, north and south, over the past 100 years. For the post-1969 period in Northern Ireland, it explores three different styles of prison management: reactive containment, criminalisation, and managerialism. It also examines the ways in which political prisoners sought to resist, including through strategic use of law, dirty protests and hunger strikes, escapes and the use of violence. The article then discusses the early release of prisoners under the Good Friday Agreement and the role that ex-prisoners have played in the peace process. It concludes with some reflections on the ongoing tensions between the state and dissident republican prisoners, asking what lessons (if any) can be gleaned from the past 100 years.
Judicial Conceptions of Prisoners' Rights in Ireland: an Emerging Field
2014
I am very grateful for the invitation to speak about the role of the Irish courts in dealing with issues relating to detention and conditions of detention. I am particularly glad that Irish experiences are being shared at this conference, as prison law and prisoners' rights jurisprudence are only beginning to develop into a field of their own in Ireland.
Countering Legitimacy: Prison Protest and the Colonial Welfare State
This paper seeks to examine the history and practices of incarceration as a mechanism of the liberal state in relation to a contested and colonial domain, namely, Ireland. Commencing with the period of the formation of the modern British state and the relation between prison reform and political prisoners’ protest, I turn to look at the simultaneity of a discourse on prison architectures and on [the welfare of] prisoner’s bodies. The long-standing concern of the state with the structures of incarceration and punishment, on the one hand, and with the welfare of the “reformable” subject on the other provides a context for the prison protests of the 1970s and 1980s in Northern Ireland, of the bureaucratic opposition between the “ordinary decent criminal” [ODC] and the recalcitrant political prisoner, of the nature of a protest that deploys both the reduced “bare life” of the body and the very architecture of the prison against the logic of “criminalization” of political prisoners.
Classism and other failures of the Irish Prison System: An Abolitionist Perspective.docx
The Social and Political Review, 2015
The Irish prison system is in a state of crisis as evidenced by chronic overcrowding, budgetary cuts, high recidivism rates, endemic fear of crime, poor prisoner conditions, and in particular accusations of discrimination as elements of the crisis; yet the existence of prison remains largely unquestioned. This article, while relying on an interdisciplinary approach of critical perspectives on law, sociology, penology and criminology uses an abolitionist perspective to determine whether prison is a viable solution in dealing with offenders of the criminal law in the context of these failures, especially in terms of its arguable classist nature. More particularly, relative abolitionism seeks the abolition of prison for the majority of prisoners that pose no known physical danger to the public, while acknowledging the need to physically confine a minority of dangerous offenders but not in a prison-like system. The need to abolish prisons resides not only in its clear failure to reduce offending but also in the proposed classist nature of the Irish prison system which means the majority of prisoners are likely to come from poor socio-economic backgrounds. The article asks; what purpose does prison supposedly serve, whether this is a valid purpose, what its impacts are, and whether it actually achieves that goal, and how prison persists if it does not achieve its aims. Finally, the article considers whether partial abolitionism is a laudable and practical solution.
The academic literature on criminology in Ireland is not as well developed in comparison with that of Europe. However, there is now a steadily developing corpus of work on many areas of Irish criminal justice policy from an increasing number of academics. Nonetheless, an in-depth analysis of the development of Irish prison policy, as presented by Rogan in Prison policy in Ireland, has never been previously attempted. The book deals primarily with the adult male prison population and policies.
Judicial Studies Institute Journal, 2008
The Irish prison system is currently undergoing significant reform. Old and dilapidated prison buildings are finally being replaced with new ones at Thornton Hall in Dublin and Kilworth in Cork, and while they have many problematic elements, not least the scale and location of ...
Sowing the Seeds for Change: Prison Abolition in Overcrowded Times
Studies: An Irish Quarterly Journal , 2024
This article reflects upon questions around penal legitimacy and the importance of sowing the seeds of change in Irish penal policy. It is argued that prisons should be regarded as an inherently problematic institutional response to criminalised behaviours and that further prison reforms are an insufficient remedy to such endemic problems. In so doing it is hoped that the article will help open a space for reflections on a very a different way of approaching penal and social harms in Ireland – the idea of penal abolition. Prison abolitionists ask us to consider whether the harm and suffering created by prisons and punishment are justified. People normally think harming other people is morally wrong, and penal abolitionists argue that if the grounds for penal confinement are not morally water-tight, then we should abandon our presumption of imprisonment in response to human wrongdoing and instead develop rational alternatives that are morally justifiable
The politics of prisoner legal rights
2013
The article begins by locating human rights law within the current political context before moving on to critically review judicial reasoning on prisoner legal rights since the introduction of the Human Rights Act 1998.
The Families of Politically Motivated Prisoners in Northern Ireland
British Journal of Criminology, 1999
This article is based upon a survey of partners of politically motivated prisoners in Northern Ireland. It examines issues related to the visiting experience, the maintenance of contact through letters, home leave and release, and the provision of support from extended family, civil society and professional agencies. The authors argue that while the political ideology of prisoners and families is important, it does not insulate them from the practical and emotional difficulties of coping with imprisonment. It i also argued that despite a system of relatively well resourced support offered to prisoners' families in Northern Ireland, the failure of the families of politicals to avail themselves of these services offers important lessons for the process of prisoner release and reintegration as part of the Northern Ireland peace process.