Death on Repeat: Violence, viral images, and questioning the rule of law in Brazilian favelas (original) (raw)
Related papers
Autoconstruction 2.0: Social Media Contestations of Racialized Violence in Complexo do Alemão
Antipode, 2017
Activists and journalists in Complexo do Alemão, Rio de Janeiro are using social media to intervene in the violence that shapes their communities. In this article I draw on critical urban and digital media theory to understand how militarized policing, the spatialization of race, and discourses of criminalization influence favela populations. I examine how these discursive and material violences are motivating residents to autoconstruct new digital communities. Through digital autoconstruction, journalists and activists are using social media technologies to safely direct mobility, to witness police violence, and to unsettle socio‐spatial imaginaries of endemic crime. As such, they are deploying digital practices to disrupt material, epistemological, and discursive mechanisms of social control. These actions show that digital technologies are always‐already embodied and take shape through material histories, such as those of racialized state violence. Journalists and activists in Co...
#sosfavelas: Digital Representations of Violence and Inequality in Rio de Janeiro
The Social Life of Economic Inequalities in Contemporary Latin America, 2017
IntroductIon …They said he was a criminal, but yet another innocent died, here we have workers and students, but for them, if you are up on the hill, you are a trafficker. 1 The above quote was published on the Facebook page of Coletivo Papo Reto (the Straight Talk Collective), a Rio de Janeiro independent journalism collective in February 2015. A few days earlier, Diego Algavez, a 24-year-old motorbike taxi driver was killed by the military police in the Penha complex of favelas. The presence of the military police in Rio's favelas is part of the policy introduced to secure the city before the 2014 FIFA World Cup and the 2016 Olympics. The aftermath of Algavez' murder was covered in real time by Coletivo Papo Reto and Jornal a Nova Democracia, a Rio-based independent newspaper. One of the photos Jornal a Nova Democracia published on their Facebook site shows Algavez' dead body stretched out over his motorbike, on a busy street, in bright sunlight. He is face up, his hips and legs on top of his toppled motorbike.
Favela Digital Activism: The Use of Social Media to Fight Oppression and Injustice in Brazil
2020
In this chapter, we analyze the role of favela digital activism as a tool to fight against oppression, injustice, and human rights violations in Rio de Janeiro. By studying “favela digital activism”, we refer to residents’ “us by us” philosophy in which they can become the narrators of their own stories. The methodological approaches are inspired by digital anthropology. We conducted the research in two stages, with netnographic observations in the first phase and offline ethnographic observations and interviews in the second phase. In order to offer an in-depth exploration of one successful initiative, we analyze the case study of a Facebook page called Mare Vive, created by residents of Mare, a large network of favelas in Rio de Janeiro. We argue that favela digital activism represents a distinctive urban media phenomenon, providing residents with tools for everyday survival in a context of conflict and social inequality.
Digital Spectacles of Violence: Film, TV and Social Media Entanglements in 2010's Brazil
International Journal of Film and Media Arts, 2022
The study of cultural industries, in particular the complex manifestations of spectacle, has produced valuable contributions that articulate capitalism, globalization and culture. The revisitation of this legacy, especially in dealing with Latin American phenomena, is this paper’s effort. Two case studies that took place in the 2010’s, in Brazil, underpin a reflection on mediated crimes in a digitalized, but still inequal society. The first tells of a prisoner’s self-recorded video, made in response to TV Globo’s news piece about a 2017 massacre; the second examines a reenactment of a 2000 crime that happened on the bridge Rio-Niterói in 2019, and referenced not only a real hijacking, but its film representations (Bus 174 and Last Stop 174). Invoking examples of exceptionality, the article aims at delineating how certain digital spectacles of violence can be understood as direct responses to cultural texts: even though practices of socialization via the internet pose questions of accelerated efficiency (in reaching wider audiences, and updating the meaning of live events), the social and aesthetic performances involving violence retrieve long-standing traditions created by modern institutions.
Online Media and Global Communication, 2022
Purpose On November 19, 2020, a man was brutally murdered by security guards of a supermarket chain located in a city in the very south of Brazil, home to the world’s largest Afro-Black community outside Africa. This killing triggered protests across the country, as a Black man was killed one day before Black Awareness Day. This large popular mobilization happened at the end of 2020 and resembled the George Floyd protests. Despite the anger resonating across communities in Brazil and abroad, the news media coverage on social media resulted in an inequitable distribution of editorial space to both the affective and critical dimensions. As users often adopt view-based practices by not clicking on social media content shared through URLs, it is essential to understand how news media portrays content in short text posted online. Study design Under the lens of news frame and social media theories, our study was built on a multi-method approach combining computational, quantitative, qualitative methods to understand how news media portrays content in a tweet. To do so, we collected 267,576 tweets. They were filtered through the case’s perspective and analyzed using frame theory. Findings Results show that Brazilian news media value different angles concerning Mr. Freitas’s death and subsequent events. While traditional media tends to be more neutral in portraying protests and the killing, digital media raised the debate on the issue and about racism in the country, highlighting protests and using supporting hashtags. Furthermore, cultural hybridity can be seen in Brazil with Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement. Practical and social implications In a media system that shares some aspects with those found in the United States, such as highly commercial media, our study demonstrates the importance of digital media for articulating racial issues and segregation in Brazil. Originality/value A long tradition of scholarship in sociology and communication studies has investigated how news media frames social movements and the impact this coverage might have on protesters and their ability to gather public support in Western-rich democracies. Less well documented is the use of news frames in Brazil. Furthermore, it shows how BLM is hybridized with local topics and has gained traction with digital media outlets. This study aims to fill this gap by becoming the first study investigating how news media frames social movements against racism in Brazil.
News discourse and public contention: Representations of 'favela' within an online context
Master's Thesis, 2017
This investigation is centered on the representations of the sociopolitical conflict involving police and favela communities within news discourse and online commentary on the Facebook fan page of one of Brazil's leading newspapers, Jornal O Globo. This study combines a sociocognitive approach with a crucial intertextual focus as the multidisciplinary framework for critical analysis of news coverage and online reactions to a series of highly mediated events within the Cidade de Deus community, with the aim of uncovering the ideologies and sociopolitical structures supported by this discourse. The results show a strong ideological relationship between O Globo's meditated discourse and the meta-representations within fan-page commentary. The analysis, however, also reveals a discordance amongst followers regarding depictions of the various actors and actions involved within the newsworthy events, which is fueled by neo-liberal and neo-racist ideologies favoring a more negative and criminalized representation of the favela.
From Favelas to Ferguson, Renewed Solidarities for Racial Justice Take Hold
NACLA Report on the Americas, 2017
The very articulation of Blackness by those who fight against police brutality in Brazil has been central to the politicization of the struggle. The Black movements are now calling attention to the race of the victims in social media, in ways that were uncommon in the twentieth century when those crimes committed by the police, including some horrible massacres in prisons, were denounced in more generic terms as “human rights” violations. Now, racism itself is being highlighted, along with the age and class of the victims—that is, the fact that most victims are Black, young, and poor.
The Mass-Mediated Pillory: An ethnographic account of participatory punishment in Northeast Brazil
Punishment – Negotiating Society, Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology, Halle (Saale), Germany, 2018
In this paper – based on 18 months of ethnographic research conducted inside and around a penal compound in Northeast Brazil – I address the issue of extralegal televised arrests, a phenomenon that is relatively common throughout Latin America. I approach the televised arrest as a form of punishment (“the mass-mediated pillory”) that is co-authored by a complex array of state and non- state agents, including arrestees as well as their kin and other relations (i.e. employers, pastors, neighbors, etc.). I draw on fieldwork conducted with Brazilian carceral subjects – those people most directly affected by uneven carceral expansion (i.e. male and female prisoners, ex-prisoners, visitors, and other residents of heavily penalized urban-peripheral neighborhoods). My research participants are avid viewers of local news programs featuring the televised arrest and detention of criminal suspects at the same time as they are among those Brazilians most susceptible to the harms of julgamento midiático (media trial/judgment). Thus, this paper complicates Northern theories of “penal populism” by offering a fine-grained view from the Global South which foregrounds the experiences of the criminalized poor. My analysis pivots around an account of the televised arrest of a key informant, Leleco, which occurred while I was conducting fieldwork. Leleco’s brief but consequential arrest, and carceral subjects’ diverse responses to it, provide a window onto the interaction of media, justice sector actors, and television audiences (including past and future televised-arrestees). My analysis has implications for the debate about the involvement of publics in the criminal justice system. As punishment becomes increasingly participatory and public, and as the prison’s pre-eminence as the site of punishment in the modern state is destabilized by the (re-)emergence of the “mass- mediated pillory,” unexpected agentive opportunities arise for research participants to intervene in the field of crime control. Such interventions are possible – thinkable and feasible – because Bahian carceral subjects creatively mobilize injurious televised arrests as actionable narratives (stories that incite action and involve actors in their unfolding). I conclude that televised arrests, equivocal in meaning, are often interpreted by carceral subjects in a manner that provokes immediate pragmatic action and involvement in the ongoing construction of the “criminal justice event.” Importantly this engagement does not necessarily sustain repressive populist measures. Instead, it enables marginalized subjects to govern selves and others in a manner that reduces risk and harm.
Lost Bullets: Fetishes of Urban Violence in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Anthropological Quarterly, 2011
This article contrasts how stray bullets are spoken about by residents of a poor neighborhood in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, with how they are depicted in the media and by residents of wealthier neighborhoods. In order to examine the role that stray bullets play in cultural constructions of violence and insecurity, it uses the theory of fetishism to analyze the implications of speaking of bullets as if they were alive. It argues that representations of urban violence are often centered upon concerns with transgression and often contain elements which resist fixation, thereby producing greater anxiety and fear. Analyzing how residents of Rio talk about stray bullets reveals that collective understandings of violence often contain elements which resist naturalization, producing a state of both security and insecurity, or a state of (in)security. [Keywords: Violence, Brazil, favela, fetishism]