Political Identity and Space in Alcaeus 130b (original) (raw)
Related papers
Gender manipulation and the crisis of citizenship in Plautus' Menaechmi
IX Jornadas Filológicas 'Migración y Ciudadanía'
Paper delivered at the IX Jornadas Filológicas 'Migración y Ciudadanía' conference in 2019, held in Bogotá, Colombia. In this paper, I propose that Plautus superimposes the character of Menaechmus I onto the comic female trope of the pseudo-meretrix, in order to resolve the cultural disconnect he experiences within his Epidamnian network. I draw on passages depicting negative stereotypes about Epidamnus as a maritime city, and I identify the conventional patterns of the comic recognition plot within his storyline. A chapter is forthcoming in a peer-reviewed volume on Migration and Citizenship in the ancient Mediterranean world.
Akroterion, 2021
In the anthology of archaic elegiac poetry called the Corpus Theognideum, the poetic I often eludes traditional approaches to the 'poetic authority'. Instead of presenting itself as a citizen of a particular 'city-state' or at least a prominent member of an elitist circle who came to have a position of authority, the persona loquens situates himself as removed from the community: as impoverished, expelled from his polis, despised, embittered and thirsting for revenge. The purpose of my paper is to consider how the tension between the alienation of the poetic I and the unity of the audience might function during the act of (re)performance. Applying considerations of Edward W Said on 'diasporic temporality' to the political and economic conflict between the ideologies of polis and anti-polis in archaic and classical Greece, I show that the poetic I in the Theognidean tradition, by presenting itself as an exile and a victim of the democratic movement, expresses the temporally distant position of the so far privileged aristocracy, situated in dialectical opposition to the democratic institutions of polis.
Aristophanes and Aristocracy. Political Gender and the Hermeneutics of Desire.
This paper is concerned with the study of gender as political metaphor. It argues that in ancient Athens, or indeed in other pre-industrial societies, the aristocracy had symbolic feminine attributes, and that "political gender" was performed by the people of the time in order to allegorically signify the political relationships between different social classes; essentially this means that gender and love were perceived as mediums of political expression. His-story, the contemporary production of the past through the lens of "big men", ignores the role of symbolic women, projecting instead today's hyper masculine worldview of what it means to be part of the elite. Mostly based on capital strength and the idea that the nobility was synonymous with warlords and brute force, this view has the direct result of excluding Eros from the political conversation that residually survives in ancient texts. Eros, thus exiled to an exclusively private sphere, such as the private life of individuals, has lost nowadays its multifaceted ancient meanings, and this paper is a step towards recovering them.
This paper contributes to the study of intrageneric intertextuality, a field of growing interest in novelistic scholarship. Up to now, scholars have focused on the sharing of narrative devices, recurrent themes, and features of characterisation. This paper offers a new case study that enriches the latter focus and compares Achilles Tatius (books 5-6) and Heliodorus (books 7-8) with regard to the characterisation of the antagonists Arsace and Thersander. This new discussion of intrageneric intertextuality increases our understanding of a key virtue of the novelistic genre as a whole, as I argue that the intertextual similarities in the characterisation of Thersander and Arsace have consequences for the characterisation of the protagonists and relates to their well-known sophrosyne. Leucippe, in this very episode, exemplarily defends her chastity. In Heliodorus, Charicleia is traditionally represented as the virtuous Penelopean spouse (5.22). Theagenes too is an example of sophrosyne (cf. 10.9). First, I show that there are intertextual similarities between Thersander’s sexual proposals to Leucippe and Arsace’s to Theagenes. Thersander and Arsace, who are both antagonists to the protagonists’ couple, dispose of a go-between (Sosthenes/Cybele) who kindles his/her master’s false hopes (6.15.2, 7.19). Both Thersander and Arsace are ‘in fire’ for their beloved (6.18.2, 7.9), jealous of Clitophon/Chariclea (6.17.1, 7.26), and react violently when rejected, abusing of their power over their ‘slave’ Leucippe/Theagenes (6.20.3, 8.5). Moreover, these thematic similarities are enriched by allusions in narratorial gnomic statements (e.g., 8.6) and character-speeches. For example, when advising Theagenes to (fake) consent towards Arsace, Chariclea warns him of the possible consequences should he not fan her hopes (e.g., 7.21, 22). Whereas this warning is meaningful on an intratextual level, as De Temmerman has convincingly demonstrated, on an intertextual level, these threatening consequences may remind the readers of the outcome of the Thersander-Leucippe episode (7.1), where the latter’s obstinate refusal to the former’s desire leads Thersander to take violent action against the protagonists. The evocation of this episode from Achilles Tatius increases the readers’ suspense as they approach the Heliodorean scene, for they may fear for Theagenes’ adoption of a similar nefarious behaviour in the Arsace episode. Second, I explain that this intertextual relationship points to a new parallel between Theagenes and Leucippe, which needs further discussion. The fact that Theagenes is paralleled to Leucippe, and less to Clitophon, not only impacts on the characterisation of Theagenes but also allows for drawing conclusions on an essential aspect of the novel as a genre. I suggest that the intertextual relationship thematises a tension between male fidelity and chastity in the two novels, and that Heliodorus wittily and seriously formulates positions on Achilles Tatius’ ambiguous representation of Clitophon’s chastity.
Human history is full of exiles and so is theatre. Hamlet and Lear in Shakespeare, Karl Moor in Schiller’s Robbers, Grusha in Brecht’s the Caucasian Chalk Circle, the Armenian immigrant family in Kalinoski’s Beast on the Moon, the old lady in Durrenmatt’s Visit, not to mention the numerous examples we get from the classics (Medea, Oedipus, Iphighenia, among others). To understand the popularity of this idea in ancient Greek drama, one has to understand the importance of belonging,....
Making a Politic Erasmian Gentleman: Wynkyn de Worde and the first Ars amatoria in English
Making a Politic Erasmian Gentleman: The First Ars amatoria in English M. L. Stapleton The first substantial English translation of Ovid’s Ars amatoria was of a type that twenty-first-century students of classical and early modern literature would not expect to encounter. Wynkyn de Worde’s The flores of Ouide de arte amandi with theyr englysshe afore them (1513) was a Latin primer and bilingual dictionary for students and probably a teaching aid for their harried masters. It was certainly an Erasmian humanist enterprise, foretelling the pedagogical theory of double translation enunciated by Roger Ascham’s The scholemaster (1570) and Richard Mulcaster’s The First Part of the Elementarie (1581). In spite of de Worde’s stock woodcut of the magister armed with his birch rods as he presides over his pupilli. The flores in its conception and construction would seem to counsel patience and persuasion as teaching strategies rather than the brutality of corporal punishment and other modes of fear-based learning. . As a text it is a self-contained unit, with all vocabulary doubly rendered and classified, and the Latin distichs followed by renderings into idiomatic English prose: a miniature encyclopedia. The flores would seem to be a counterintuitive choice for a schoolboy reader, since the Ars was notorious from its initial circulation as a cynical and satiric primer for sexual seduction that led to its author’s banishment for immorality by his emperor. Its first two sections were prized and consulted by medieval poets and physicians attempting to understand lovesickness and women’s psychology from a male perspective. Its third book is addressed to women, and encourages them to beware of fair blandishments and to learn how men might be best managed and controlled. It concludes with a flourish: how women might adopt the positions during lovemaking that would be most flattering to them, based on bodily type. The compiler of The flores intended that it fulfill the function encoded in its title, to offer material for intermediate language study whose excerpts were intentionally devoid of context or explanation from the rest of Ovid’s poem. Yet many of its elegiac couplets nevertheless enunciate or embody conceptions of masculinity that early modern culture wished to inculcate in the adolescents for whom it was intended. I will explore the text’s embedded mores, account for the disjunction between early sixteenth-century ideas of appropriate reading matter and our own, and situate The flores in its literary milieu.
Abstract (English Version): A Greek Lawgiver in the Epitome of Pompeius Trogus: Justin’s account of Lycurgus This paper aims to explore the perception of the “other” in Latin historiography, analyzing a passage on a Greek lawgiver, Lycurgus of Sparta, in Justin's Epitome of Pompeius Trogus. The purpose is to examine how a Latin writer defines and describes an ancient lawgiver from the Greek tradition, and how Lycurgus can be relevant for the Roman readers during the Imperial Age. In his Epitome of Pompeius Trogus, Justin summarizes, in fact, some crucial information on Lycurgus and his constitution. In the account from the third book, the author provides a biographical sketch on the lawgiver and a summary of the traditional Spartan laws (such as frugal customs, land distribution, the prohibition of gold and silver coins). A closer look at Justin's exposition reveals some elements that this text has in common with Plutarch and other Greek sources. Since Trogus was presumably active during the Augustan age, it is also important to remark that Plutarch’s Life of Lycurgus is a later text than the Historiae of Trogus. A re-examination of Justin's text might, therefore, help us to clarify which traditions about Sparta's kosmos the imperial author had selected and included in his Epitome. The taste for anecdotes and moralizing contents is probably one of the reasons why Justin preserves, in the summary of the third book, not only the laws of Sparta but also biographical details on Lycurgus. Thus, this account testifies an interest in the Greek lawgiver as a moral exemplum in the imperial age, appropriate for both Trogus' and Justin's period.