Pedagogical Grammar: Learners' Beliefs Do Matter (original) (raw)
Related papers
Beliefs about grammar instruction among post-secondary second-language learners and teachers
2018
This dissertation would have not been possible without my advisers and numerous mentors. I would like to thank Dr. Per Urlaub for always believing in me. He guided me throughout the process of becoming a teacher-scholar. Our professional relationship is indescribable and our friendship long-lasting. Dr. Hans Boas has been an influential mentor throughout my graduate studies. He showed me how to successfully conduct research studies independently and write for multiple audiences. Dr. Katie Arens has guided me through various projects since day one. Her availability and honesty helped me find my niche in the ever-changing field of Germanic Studies. The work of Dr. Elaine Horwitz inspired me to dedicate my academic life to the study of individual differences of language learners. Her advice and feedback during the beginning stages of this project was crucial for the outcomes of my study. Dr. Marc Pierce has been very helpful throughout the process of writing this dissertation. His critical examination of my work pushed me to continuously improve my work. I would also like to thank Dr. Cori Crane for guiding me through graduate school and giving me feedback on my projects throughout the years. She introduced me to exploratory practice, which sparked my interests to study the effects of various grammar teaching approaches on language learners and learning outcomes. I would like to thank Dr. Janet Swaffar for showing me how to successfully conduct questionnaire studies and for always giving me advice on various projects.
Theories of grammar and their influence on teaching practice: Examining language teachers' beliefs
2010
Teacher language awareness and its relationship to pedagogical practice (Andrews, 2003) have been identified as significant contributors to the teaching of grammar. Various TESOL programs teach pedagogical and theoretical grammar in different ways and some focus on specific approaches to grammar teaching, which include systemic functional grammar, transformational grammar, traditional grammar and lexical grammar. Discussions with graduate and former teachers however indicate that they feel under-prepared to teach grammar. This paper is part of a research project that examined the current needs of English language teachers and their opinions and attitudes towards grammar teaching. Questionnaires and interviews were used to elicit data on teachers' beliefs on the importance and use of certain theories of grammar and their current English grammar practices. The results highlight the teachers' reported use of a combination of theories in grammar explanations and their belief that a variety
English as a Foreign Language Teachers' Beliefs About Grammar Teaching in Classroom
ELLTER Journal, 2020
This study investigated English as a Foreign Language teachers’ beliefs toward grammar teaching in the classroom. This research paper aimed to explore EFL teachers’ belief about grammar teaching and the factors influencing teachers in shaping their beliefs on grammar teaching. A qualitative study using a semi-structured interview with eight English as foreign language teachers of secondary schools in East Jakarta has been conducted. The result revealed that most teachers believed that grammar was essential. Explicit grammar teaching was also believed to be more effective to be implemented in teaching grammar, yet teachers still used both explicit and implicit instructions. Nonetheless, some teachers believed that implicit instruction that was suggested in the 2013 Curriculum was less effective due to the limited time of English learning in classroom practice. The factors shaping the teachers’ beliefs involved the student factor and the teacher factors which included teachers’ prior ...
Teachers' beliefs about grammar and testing grammar in second language
In relation to teaching and learning grammar in second language ,grammar is conceptualized differently. The present study is an attempt to examine the differences related to non-native EFL teachers' beliefs about grammar and testing grammar. These differences were examined in relation to teachers' work experience, workplace (governmental school vs. private institutes) and gender. A questionnaire consisting of 28 items was administered to 82 EFL English teachers. They were teaching in Iranian high schools, junior schools and private institutes. The results showed that there were significant differences between school teachers and institute language teachers related to grammar and testing grammar, that is, the teachers' characteristics affected some areas of their cognition concerning grammar and grammar testing. Key words: testing, beliefs, grammar, teachers' cognition, work setting
The Key Ingredients of an Effective Grammar Lesson: Perceptions From High School ESL Students
The history of grammar teaching is fraught with tensions especially in terms of the effectiveness of grammar teaching to students’ language development. Recently, there has been a growth in research on learner involvement in language learning and learner beliefs. Within this paradigm, this research examined students’ beliefs about grammar instruction methods in the Sri Lankan secondary ESL classrooms. Questionnaires and semi-structured interviews were conducted with students about their attitudes to grammar teaching methods and their opinions about effective grammar lessons. The results showed students’ positiveattitude to explicit grammar teaching. The lessons were judged not only in terms of the engagement of activities employed, but also in terms of the teachers’ creative presentation and the usefulness of the grammar item in extending the students’ English language repertoire. The findings have implications for language pedagogy and language teacher education in general. The study supports the idea of integration of explicit instruction in grammar teaching with authentic real life examples to increase students’ awareness of the importance of grammar
Science Journal of Turkish Military Academy, 2018
Teacher cognition research has provided not only a deeper insight into the choices, decisions and practices of language teachers, but also a more comprehensive insight into the specific challenges teachers of English as a foreign language (EFL) face. In this framework, studies on grammar teaching has made great contribution to our understandings of how teachers teach grammar and of the cognitive framework behind their instructional practices. Correspondingly, this study reports on the EFL teachers' beliefs about and their conceptualizations of grammar instruction in teaching English and compares how novice and experienced teachers perceive grammar instruction, examining whether there is a significant difference in their perceptions. 70 Turkish EFL teachers who work at the Prep Class of state university participated in the study. For the data collection purposes, a five-point Likert scale questionnaire with 15 items was used. According to the results, participant teachers indicated that they preferred direct grammar teaching, where rules are presented explicitly prior to student production and highlighted the necessity to learn grammar rules explicitly for effective use of target language. In general, novice and experienced teachers showed no significant difference. However, novice teachers had respectively stronger tendency towards explicit and direct grammar teaching, especially in terms of presentation of rules deductively. Experienced teachers were more flexible when it comes to teaching grammar in that they reported occasional use of both direct and indirect grammar elements in their teaching.
Non-Native English Teachers’ Beliefs on Grammar Instruction
English Language Teaching, 2018
Research on teacher cognition, which mainly focuses on identifying what teachers think, know and believe, is essential to understanding teachers’ cognitive framework as it relates to the instructional choices they make. The aim of this study is to find out the beliefs of non-native speaker teachers of English on grammar instruction and to explain how those reported beliefs are influenced by particular demographic factors. 75 non-native speaker teachers of English participated in the study. Data was collected by a 5-Likert type questionnaire with 15 items that addressed a range of key issues in grammar instruction, particularly direct (explicit) or indirect (integrated) grammar instruction. The study has provided a number of valuable insights, particularly in relation to teachers’ beliefs about grammar instruction. The representation of grammar instruction that arises from participant teachers’ responses in this study is one characterized by systematic explicit grammar teaching with regular opportunities for grammar practice, not in isolation but in relation to skills-oriented work. Moreover, teachers with higher English proficiency levels and higher degrees (master’s/doctorate) showed stronger belief towards teaching grammar indirectly. Teachers of adult learners showed a higher tendency towards direct grammar teaching. Non-native speaker teachers preferred to use more indirect grammar instruction as they progressed academically and proficiency-wise, but they implemented more direct grammar teaching as the ages and level of their students increased.
A Teacher’s Pedagogical Belief in Teaching Grammar: A Case Study
International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences, 2019
The study was conducted to investigate the teacher's pedagogical belief in teaching grammar whether it should be taught explicitly or implicitly. The objectives of the study were to identify the teacher's own pedagogical belief when teaching grammar, to investigate the reasons for the teacher's choice of belief in teaching grammar and finally to find out the challenges faced by the teacher in implementing her selected belief. A practicum mentor at a public secondary school in Klang was selected as the participant of the study. An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis was used to analyze the data collected and to look at the pattern of the teacher's pedagogical belief in teaching grammar whether explicitly or implicitly. Data from the study revealed that the participant's pedagogical belief is fluid and it changes depending on the students' competence level in English and the environment of the classes. Nevertheless, this fluidity in the respondent's belief is also constantly being influenced by her own experiences in learning grammar during her schooling years and the pressure of finishing the mandated English syllabus with very limited time.
World Journal of English Language, 2020
This study investigated English as Foreign Language (EFL) teachers' beliefs, perceptions and declared practices of teaching grammar within a communicative language teaching (CLT) framework. Participants included 221 EFL teachers, who were teaching during the years 2013-2018 in different grades and schools throughout Israel. Participants were graduates of teacher training programs in colleges and universities and included Non-Native English Speaking Teachers (NNEST) and Native English Speaking Teachers (NEST). An on-line, self-report survey designed specifically for this study contained three closed questions and two open-ended questions. One-way ANOVA statistics, and mean scores of all the responses were performed on the quantitative data. Qualitative data were grouped, analyzed, and coded. Results show a discrepancy between EFL teachers' perceptions and declared practices of teaching grammar in classrooms. Results further reveal significant differences between NEST and NNE...