Industrial Transformation in the West Midlands Automotive Cluster: International Networks and Co-operative Behaviour (original) (raw)
Related papers
The shifting geography of competitive advantage: clusters, networks and firms
Journal of Economic Geography, 2010
We consider the dynamics of knowledge-based sources of advantage as they move between geographical locations and multinational and other firm level networks using the specialist context of Formula 1 motor over a fifty nine year period. We suggest that shifts in competitive advantage are underpinned by the movement of both architectural and component knowledge at both the firm and cluster level, and in particular we suggest that isolated firms can both benefit from and add to cluster level knowledge. We conclude by suggesting ways in which MNEs can adapt their approach to both location and knowledge development in order to enhance their ability to create competitive advantage.
Globalisation of the automotive industry: main features and trends
This paper lays out the main features of the global automotive industry and identifies several important trends. A boom in developing country sales and production has not yet overshadowed the importance of existing markets in developed regions. Regional integration is very strong at an operational level, yet the industry has recently developed a set of global-scale value chain linkages, and retains national and local elements as well. The paper highlights how global, regional, national and local value chains are nested to create a pattern of global integration that is distinctive to the industry. We use global value chain analysis to help explain the limits of build-to-order in the industry, the role of regional and global suppliers, the shifting geography of production and how the characteristics of value chain linkages in the industry favour tight integration and regional production. We describe how industry concentration focuses power in the hands of a few large lead firms and discuss the implications of this for value chain governance and the geography of production.
Journal of Economic Geography, 2007
Recently, studies of industrial clusters and global production networks (GPNs) between large transnational corporations (TNCs) and smaller firms have focused on how power differentials shape, and sometimes undermine cluster innovation and governance. Such studies raise issues of how to conceptualize TNCs power within GPNs and some economic geographers have adopted approaches that seek to integrate the post-structural insights of actor network theory (ANT) with heterodox and Marxian value theory. Based on a case study of the Canadian automotive industry, we engage in a sympathetic critique of this perspective via a realist position that distinguishes between structural and actual power. We argue that differences in structural position derived from financial size matter, although do not necessarily determine actor network relations. Yet, TNC Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) have a tendential actual or 'power over' smaller automotive suppliers due to superior financial resources, their strategic position within GPNs and especially their relationship with state accumulation projects designed to capture those segments of GPNs, which offer the greatest potential for the creation and enhancement of value. We show that such projects were critical to the development of the Canadian automotive industry and the Kitchener and Windsor, Ontario automotive clusters. Although large firms were generally favoured by such policies, suppliers and SMEs were able to partially offset power asymmetries through innovation, often by accessing informal local networks in clusters. More recently, however, smaller component firms and the coherence of these clusters are being threatened by neo-liberal Schumpterian Competition State policies that privilege OEMs and larger firms and by the restructuring of automotive GPNs in response to overcapacity and falling profits.
2016
In recent decades the organisation of production has changed, with production and manufacturing activities no longer taking place in a single location, with lower transportation and communication costs leading to production activities geographically spread out into a global value chain. This reorganisation and fragmentation of the production process has led to increased sources of competition at the international level, with many firms from industrialised nations increasing their level of outsourcing and off-shoring of lower value activities to developing countries. Along with the increase in outsourcing activities, many industrialised nations are also now facing increasing competition from developing countries, who are steadily developing capabilities, in which industrialised nations once held a firm competitive advantage. This paper makes use of network analysis of the international trade network to analyse the competitive level of countries in the automotive industry, and to answ...
This paper explores the international spatial organisation of motor vehicle production within a cluster complexes framework. Such a framework is analyses clusters within their international economic and innovation system architecture of their core and related industries. Based on data from a series of international input-output models the paper focuses on the scale of flows and changes in spatial structure of connections between national clusters. This analysis highlights flows between national clusters are specific, significant and are arranged within international industry hierarchies. The paper draws attention to implications of the findings for innovation theory.
Uni v er si té Montesqui eu Bordeaux I V Av enue Léon Dugui t -33608 PESSA C -FRA NCE Tel : +33 (0 )5 .5 6 .84 .25.75 -Fax : +33 (0 )5 .5 6 .84 .8 6 . 47 -www.gretha.f r Entre internationalisation et proximité : le processus d'internationalisation des équipementiers automobiles de premier rang Résumé L'article cherche à analyser les stratégies d'internationalisation des équipementiers de premier rang de l'industrie automobile. Le développement de la production modulaire implique une transformation des relations verticales interfirmes dont nous cherchons à comprendre les effets sur le processus d'internationalisation des équipementiers automobiles. L'article explique les formes d'internationalisation de ces firmes par le biais d'une grille d'analyse où la contrainte de proximité est conçue comme une fonction de la complexité et du degré d'exclusivité des interactions interfirmes. L'article est structuré en trois parties. La première examine les transformations induites par la modularisation de l'automobile. La seconde présente quelques faits stylisés sur l'internationalisation des équipementiers. La troisième propose une grille d'analyse des interactions interfimes et en montre les implications en termes de choix de localisations pour les équipementiers. Abstract The paper analyses the strategies of internationalization pursued by first tier automotive suppliers (FTS). The advent of modular production in this sector implies many changes in vertical relationships, which can in turn be used to explain the causes and forms of suppliers' internationalization. The paper tries to explain internationalization patterns via an analytical grid wherein proximity needs are portrayed as a function of the complexity and exclusivity of inter-firm interactions. The argument applied in this article is broken down into three sections: the first reconsiders the transformations induced by modularization; the second presents some stylized facts about the internationalization of FTS; and the third part both presents an analytical grid and derives its implications in terms of location of suppliers. . JEL : L62; R3 ; F23 Between Internationalisation and Proximity: the internationalisation process of automotive FTS -3 -
Power of Automotive Supplier Cluster: The Case of BMW in South Carolina
The phenomenon of regional industrial concentration, or agglomerations, has been studied for more than a century. Over the past couple of decades, interest has dramatically doubled both from the aspects of academics and policy makers. However, the process of making a car requires more sophisticated and complex technology and an upper level of knowledge. The collaboration is indeed an inevitable tool. The agglomeration of the automotive industry in the upper Midwest of the US is one of the most prominent and persistent industrial clusters. Historically, automotive production in the US was dominated by the big three domestic manufacturers, namely: Ford, GM, and Chrysler. However, in the last 30 years, many foreign-owned manufacturers (e.g. Honda, BMW) have opened assembly lines in the South which is far away from the automotive industry center in Michigan (Rosenbaum, 2013). These assemblers were attracted to the South due to the lower rates of unionization and lower labor costs in those states. In this paper, the researcher focus on the competitiveness of this collaboration, if there is any, by using three star analysis and the strength of foreign trade capabilities by Vollrath Analysis.
Manufacturing Innovation in the New Urban Economy: Responses to Globalisation
This report discusses core manufacturing competitiveness in the City of Liverpool and South West Sydney, both in terms of industry specialisation and innovation intensity, in order to provide key elements for the development of an industry cluster. The study was funded by the University of Western Sydney Partnerships Program, with Liverpool City Council as the industry partner. The analysis is based on survey results, case studies of manufacturing firms, and analysis of successful manufacturing clusters.
Value chains, networks and clusters: reframing the global automotive industry
Journal of Economic Geography, 2008
In this article, we apply global value chain (GVC) analysis to recent trends in the global automotive industry, with special attention paid to the case of North America. We use the three main elements of the GVC framework-firm-level chain governance, power and institutions-to highlight some of the defining characteristics of this important industry. First, national political institutions create pressure for local content, which drives production close to end markets, where it tends to be organized nationally or regionally. Second, in terms of GVC governance, rising product complexity combined with low codifiability and a paucity of industry-level standards has driven buyer-supplier linkages toward the relational form, a governance mode that is more compatible with Japanese than American supplier relations. The outsourcing boom of the 1990s exacerbated this situation. As work shifted to the supply base, lead firms and suppliers were forced to develop relational linkages to support the exchange of complex uncodified information and tacit knowledge. Finally, the small number of hugely powerful lead firms that drive the automotive industry helps to explain why it has been so difficult to develop and set the industry-level standards that could underpin a more loosely articulated spatial architecture. This case study underlines the need for an open, scalable approach to the study of global industries.