Perspective: In the 'Public Interest'? - Contesting Mumbai's Coastal Road (original) (raw)
Related papers
Design of Coastal Road in Mumbai City
The Western Freeway is a transportation infrastructure project in Mumbai, India that envisions the construction of multiple bridges over the Arabian Sea to reduce traffic-congestion between the Western Suburbs and the island city. The freeway will stretch from Marine Drive in South Mumbai to Kandivli in the north, a distance of 35.6 km. This study is carried out to develop alternative roads by Coastal Routes and to increase average travel speed of vehicles in Mumbai City. This research aims to assess the influence of increase in traffic intensity in Mumbai city. In this paper we estimated the total length of coastal road to examine the various options in the construction of a coastal road including road on stilt or sea link in Mumbai and find out most economical options towards composition of coastal freeway, we also collected the data related to traffic intensities at different locations on the proposed coastal road and for that traffic intensity we design the flexible pavement.
Conference Paper, 2017
India's coastal cities and districts experience chronic flooding, even as they are among the most economically dynamic regions, attracting capital, population, and new claims over space and land use. Flood risks are exacerbated by climate change related impacts including sea level rise, coastal erosion, storm surge, and cyclonic events; urbanization and large projects along the coast, and projects upstream create problems of coastal accretion, disruptions to estuaries, and destruction of ecologies which provide disaster mitigation functions and ecosystem services. The 'cunning state' (Randeria 2003) resorts to a range of legal-scientific fictions and manipulations in promoting ever new large scale projects in coastal areas-eco-tourism, hospitality, recreation, real estate, special / coastal economic zones, ports, power plants, and industrial clusters; hard-fought battles by social movements had put in place tough environmental regulations while balancing welfare, livelihood and economic growth concerns; most of these have been rolled back, ignored, violated, or amended. This paper argues that a new kind of coastal urbanism is emerging that is neither organic nor economic, but is primarily led by short-term approaches that endanger communities, environments, and economies. India's coastal urbanism is flourishing economically and in terms of spatial spread, but requires a governance and transformation process that makes it resilient to disasters. Using a series of recent legal battles and judgements from newly sensitized communities, civil society organizations and tribunals, the paper attempts to re-imagine a future for India's coasts that is transformative rather than resilient. These battles relate to location of dumping grounds, new infrastructure projects, re-classification of coastal regulation zone categories, and management and governance of coastal ecosystems such as water bodies, mangroves, and forests. These cases show that for cities to flourish, robust and alternate urban imaginations are required which a) are rooted in practices around 'ecological regimes', and not just management or governance of environmental resources, and b) have faith in science and law as democratic strategies in conflict resolution and sustainable urban transformation.
2013
The first case study presented in this chapter is Sanjay Gandhi National Park (SGNP), which is the largest national Park within the urban sprawl of Mumbai. Illegal quarrying and heavy encroachment are threatening the Park. Mumbai High Court ordered the removal of all the encroachments but failed to achieve the desired results. The second case study; Pallikaranai Marshland (PML) is partly saline and largely freshwater marshland in Chennai. The marshland is facing massive environmental problems, such as, fragmentation and reclamation of marshland for urban development, garbage dump, disposal of partially treated sewage and loss of habitat due to reclamation and garbage dump. The Madras (Chennai) High Court directed the Chennai Corporation to establish an integrated waste management facility, remove all encroachments for the marshland and stop the municipalities from dumping garbage in the marshland area but the legal verdicts have not been able to put a complete halt to the abuse and ...
The Human Right to Water in Mumbai: From Recognition to Realization
This ruling by the Bombay High Court is a monumental achievement in the recognition of the human right to water. However, the struggle for the realization of right to water has only just begun for people living in unrecognized slums. The process of realization of the right to water will present numerous obstacles: the need to develop new water policies in accordance with the ruling, the lack of adequate infrastructure for water provision, lack of knowledge regarding the current gaps in service, the challenges of regulating the existing informal water economy, and a cultural dissonance regarding the rights of ‘slum dwellers’. The process of policy implementation will be crucial in the realization of the human right to water. This particular point in the policy process is uniquely challenging. The right to water has been recognized, and now must be enforced through action of the state. Policy to support the law must be developed and implemented within an unregulated, under-resourced environment.
Indian Urbanism and the Terrain of the Law
Economic and Political Weekly , 2015
In the controversies around, and legal and political challenges to, the Bangalore–Mysore Infrastructure Corridor being constructed by Nandi Infrastructure Corridor Enterprises, one can see signs of a new historical stage and urban form. Court judgments between 1997 and 2006 relating to land acquisition for infrastructure projects such as NICE tell us about the new urban form, which the courts feel obliged to bring into being, displaying a proselytising zeal in promoting corridor urbanism. The corridor project has seized hold of the planning, bureaucratic, and judicial imagination in ways that signal a consensus about the imperatives of rapid capitalist growth, uncontaminated by any early postcolonial notions of developmentalist growth.