The Ukrainian Crisis as a Case Study of Different Policymaking Styles of Russia and China (original) (raw)
Related papers
Russia Between China and Ukraine: Three Points of View
Torun International Studies, 2021
Russia can be understood in many different ways. Observation from the inside is still possible. Doing your own research is very important, but it can’t be done quickly. The fastest way to understand Russia leads through scientific texts. The level of scientific literature on Russia’s foreign policy can be examined in two ways – through an extensive and long-term analysis of the entire world publications or through a very careful study of the most representative ones. The second path is easier and more effective. Three monographs publishedby the most recognizable scientific publishing houses in the world were analysed: written by experts, scientists using International Relations (IR) paradigms and scholars representing the neo-Marxist approach. Each of the three schools of foreign policy research has significant academic achievements, and also succeeds in the legitimization or de-legitimization of political actors. Each of these schools also has weaknesses. While experts did not alwa...
China’s Approach to the Crimean Crisis: International and Regional Dimensions
For more than twenty years China has been considering Ukraine as one of its key partners in the post-Soviet area. In 2001, both states established a comprehensive partnership that had strategic content. Up to 2013, the Crimean Peninsula, alongside with other regions of Southeast Ukraine, was considered as one of the most important strongholds of the Sino-Ukrainian strategic partnership. The situation changed drastically in March 2014. As Russia and the West collided over Ukraine, China took advantage of Russia’s need to avoid broad international isolation and the US and EU’s economic sanctions against Crimea, its inhabitants, other individuals and entities. On the international arena, China follows a strategy of active neutrality on the Ukrainian issue, which prospectively could be added with active economic engagement in Crimea.
The Ukraine crisis: a multidimensional analysis in China
As one of the most serious geopolitical crisis since the end of the Cold War, the Ukraine Crisis has an impact not only on the reshaping of the Eurasian political architecture, but also on the reconstruction of the world order. This paper deploys content analysis of 45 academic papers on the " Ukraine Crisis " in Chinese core journals (CSSCI) from December 2013 to April 2015, which are further compared with 56 papers whose research subject is " Ukraine politics " in the same journal database from January 2004 to November 2013. Therefore, the current paper explores what the Chinese academia discussed about Ukraine, from a wider range of perspectives, including international political economy, politics, security and international relations over the past 10 years. The findings of the conducted research suggest that Chinese scholars offer a multidimensional analysis on the development of Ukraine Crisis. From an institutional transformation perspective, Ukraine is an important case of political failure leading to social disorders. From a geopolitical perspective, Russia, the United States and the European Union each have their specific objectives in Ukraine. From an imperial studies approach, although the " new Cold War" thesis has been overplayed, Russia seeks to double its efforts in order to look for alignment with anti-West forces, resulting in more complication among major countries. The impact of the crisis is yet to be felt globally and its warning lessons are to be learned by China.
Sino-Russian Relations in the Ukraine Crisis: Status, Multipolarity, and Soft Power
The war in Ukraine has polarized the world. Although the Ukraine conflict represents a humanitarian crisis, it also has larger economic and political implications for Russia, the West, and China. Sino-Russian relations have been complicated throughout history, dating as far back as the 13th century when the Mongol hordes invaded Kievan Rus. In the mid-19th century, Russia captured a portion of Northern China during a geostrategic and colonial competition with the West known as the Great Game, as Russia sought to control parts of Central Asia for power, wealth, and prestige.2 Nicholas II aimed to extend Russia’s influence in Asia near the turn of the 20th century, and over time, the two powers came to share some ideological perspectives in Leninism, as prominent Chinese intellectuals were attracted to the Bolshevik Revolution and its modernizing objectives, seeing the Marxist political economy to “restore national dignity.” In post-Cold War years, Sino-Russian relations have “veered between discord and cooperation,” claim Kim and Blank.4 Observers currently recognized a new strategic partnership emerging between Russia and China.
2015
The present Master’s thesis seeks to develop a better understanding of the impact of the recent events in Ukraine on the relations between the Russian Federation and the Western countries. Based on a synthesis of the methodological approaches of traditionalism and positivism and the theoretical school of neorealism, this Master’s thesis examines the roots, the causes and the events of the crisis in Ukraine and subsequently focuses on establishing a comprehensive understanding on whether the impact of the crisis has been such, as to deter cooperation in issues where both the West and Russia have common interests and severely inhibit the potentialities of coordination and cooperation in areas where their interests are incompatible or conflicting. The issues that will be examined are: a) the economic and energy relations between the European Union and the Russian Federation; and b) cooperation in matters of international security, such as nuclear non-proliferation, the counterterrorism –specifically against the Islamic State- and Syria. The main conclusion of this Master’s thesis is that the West and Russia still have managed to cooperate and coordinate in issues, where their interests are aligned –energy, non-proliferation of weapons of mass destruction-; however, the increased tensions and animosity that has resulted from the events in Ukraine are creating additional obstacles and postponing cooperation in issues, where each side is seeking to further its own agenda.
What has changed in the Putin’s Foreign Policy with Ukraine Crisis 2013-2014
The Bachelor’s Thesis focuses on the impact of the Ukraine political crisis of 2013 on Vladimir Putin foreign policies into the main international relat2014 ionship. The Ukraine crisis sparked when the Ukraine government ceased political and economic association agreemen t with the European Union. This caused a crash between Russian powers interests. As a result, the nervous situation betwee and Western n Ukraine and Russia represents one of the most important and actual politic affair in international relations. This diss ertation offers a brief summary of the Russian foreign policy evolution from 1991 to 2014, with a particular closer look on the third mandate of the Russian president Vladimir Vladimirovič Putin. I would like to highlight the concepts and the factors that underlie the Russian foreign policy. In the second part I will try to understand whether the Ukrainian crisis has had an impact on the foreign policy of Putin, especially on the Eurasian integration. At last I would like to understand the reaction from the Russian side in dealing with the consequences.
Bilateral Ukraine-China Relations at the Current Stage
Politology bulletin
Foreign policy is one of the most important directions of sovereign states’ activity. An especially important place in foreign policy shaping is bilateral relations between states. For Ukraine, such vectors of foreign policy as European, Euro-Atlantic, Eurasian and Asian are traditionally important. In particular, the implementation of the Asian foreign policy vector and the establishment of effective relations with the…
The Two Faces of Russia Foreign Policy Toward China and Taiwan
Global Focus, 2021
Russia, as one of the key actors in international politics, faces problematic issues in Chinese-Taiwan Relations. As a significant player, Russia reserves a close and stable relationship with China. However, Russia could not avoid Taiwan's significant role in Northeast Asia, especially its role in allying with the West. Taiwan undoubtedly offers a promising prospect for the Russian economy, but political relations with Taiwan could not significantly contribute to Russian FP. In this paper, Russian foreign policy will be examined on both sides, Russian foreign policy toward China and Russian foreign policy toward Taiwan. The purposes of this paper are trying to analyze the Russian foreign policy dilemma toward China-Taiwan relation. The analysis of this paper will focus on President Vladimir Putin as the decision-maker and explore all circumstances that will influence the decision-making process. The level of analysis implemented in this paper is domestic politics that significantly contribute to Russian foreign policy decisionmaking. This paper will gather secondary data from the news, journal, and book as the primary sources. The paper's outcome analyzes Russian foreign policy's dilemma and explores how Russian foreign policy toward China-Taiwan relations' current dynamics.
The impact of the Ukraine crisis on China’s relations with the West
Horizon Insights, 2022
Despite appearances, it cannot be assumed that China supports Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. From Beijing’s perspective, it has been a destabilizing factor in European affairs. While from one perspective this plays into China’s hands, from another – maintaining economic growth in China amidst signs of a downturn – it does not. Europe and North America are two of China’s most important export markets.26 China still needs the West for the time being. As economies are impacted by the European energy crisis, inflation, and a possible coming downturn, it is not in China’s interests to see an even more destabilized international order.
UKRAINE CONFLICT AND RUSSIAN INVASION, AND CHINA’S CLAIM FOR A NEW STRATEGY TO INTERNATIONAL SYSTEM
A. Krymskyi Institute of Oriental Studies (National Academy of Sciences of Ukraine); Ukrainian Association of Sinologists; Helvetica Publishing House (informational support)., 2022
UKRAINE CONFLICT AND RUSSIAN INVASION, AND CHINA’S CLAIM FOR A NEW STRATEGY TO INTERNATIONAL SYSTEM Our study seeks to understand the China’s strategy for the international system in three aspects: First, what mean to Chinese leaders upholding the international system. Second, what represents to promote reform of the international governance system. And third, what is the further develop the international system for the global economy, finance, and emerging sectors and for regional cooperation mechanisms, that China defends.