Capitalism and Utopia in the Social Theory of André Gorz (original) (raw)
2020, New Proposals: Journal of Marxism and Interdisciplinary Inquiry
In this essay, I seek to provide an overview of André Gorz's conception of modern capitalism, considering different moments of his intellectual production. From his initial criticism of the concept of the proletariat between the 1970s and 1980s until his last theoretical work that addresses the notion of immaterial work, we found in this author an original debate with the tradition of Marx to the present reason for intense polemics, especially when we consider aspects which involve the theory of work value, and the potential of social groups to present themselves as collective subjects capable of leading human emancipation. At the same time that the core of his criticism of capitalism has been changing over more than three decades, we realize that the utopian potential has always been on the horizon of Gorz's thought and, like the tradition of critical theory, it has a strong normative content. The possibilities of human emancipation, however, need to consider transformations that have taken place in the capitalist mode of production in the last four decades. ISSN 1715-6718
Related papers
Just haad on a minute there: a rejection of Andre Gorz's 'Farewell to the Working Class
Capital & Class, 1985
Many on the left have welcomed Gorz's book Farewell to the Working Class. This article argues that such enthusiasm is misplaced. Gorz's analysis is seen to rest on a capital-logic approach that denies the possibility of any form of collective proletarian action and hence provides only individualistic solutions. Whilst rejecting Gorz's particular Utopia, the article endorses the development of utopian proposals, where these are collective projects aimed at transforming production and reproduction.
The double character of labor in the Marxist theory of Robert Kurz
Comunicação apresentada (por videoconferência) no VIII Congresso da Associação Portuguesa de Antropologia, Évora, Universidade de Évora, 6-9/09/2022., 2022
According to Kurz, the double-edged category of concrete/abstract labor is on the basis of the modern social synthesis, denoting the ever growing contradictory opposition between material content and social form of capitalist wealth and (re)production. This communication will present the following distinctive features of labor subsumed in capital in light of Kurzian theory: i) Abstract labor is not a mental generalization, but the result of an aprioristic process of social reduction, i.e., a real abstraction; ii) As the substance of economic value, abstract labor represents an absurd end in itself; iii) This generates an indifference towards the sensible content of activities. Through a real fetishistic inversion, the multiple concrete labors are degraded to the status of carriers or forms of manifestation of abstract labor, just as use-value is converted in the phenomenal form of value; iv) Abstract labor and the tautological valorization process are at the root of the constitution of the economy as a disembedded social domain, i.e., as an abstract and dissociated space-time; v) However, concrete historical time, which is the temporal logic of the material productive forces, is constituted in parallel. Its share of non-identity with capital could be the lever of social emancipation.
Beyond Utopia: Building Socialism Within and After Capitalism
The article focuses on several figures who are particularly interesting when it comes to develop a radical critique of capitalism that does not shrink from the possibility of designing and imaging a different future. Following Michael Löwy, in our study we have identified relationships of 'elective affinity' between figures who might appear different and dissimilar, at least at first glance: the Bolshevik Alex-andra Kollontai, the German communist Paul Mattick, the Italian Socialist Rani-ero Panzieri and the French social scientist Alain Bihr. After providing some biographical information, we analyze their respective paths to a socialism based on, and achieved through, self-organization and self-government.We do not intend to build a new tradition with this review of thinkers, most of whom were also political militants; rather, more modestly, we hope to suggest a path forward for both research and political activism. In order to show how significant the questions raised by these four intellectuals-militants still are even today, in the Conclusions we analyze the social and political experiment carried out by the Movement for a Democratic Society of the Rojava region in Syrian Kurdistan.
The Dream of Dignified Work: On Good and Bad Utopias
Development & Change, 2014
To what extent are recent labour upsurges defensive struggles? This essay uses the experience of the Argentinean Movement of Unemployed Workers (also called the Piquetero movement) as the empirical basis for discussing the contribution of unemployed workers to the current reshaping of the labour question. The author offers an alternative interpretation of the Piqueteros' experience of resistance that emphasizes their critique and alternative visions, and the transformations and alternatives that the movement put forward at a time when 'labour' was said to be defeated. The struggles of the unemployed workers in Argentina during the 1990s should not be classified as a defensive struggle for inclusion in the labour market, or as a demand for social security (although these demands were significant in the Piqueteros' agenda); rather they should be seen as advancing significant changes at iden-tity/organizational, socioeconomic and political institutional levels. These changes deserve special attention in terms of their significance for the reshaping of the labour question in the twenty-first century. The Piquetero utopia of dignified work does not rely on state policy such as Universal Income Support. Instead, the state and policy are mediations of the autonomous struggle for the prefigurations of a better society.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.