The Apache Diaspora: Four Centuries of Displacement and Survival (original) (raw)

The Apache Diaspora: Four Centuries of Displacement and Survival by Paul Conrad (Review)

Journal of Early American History, 2022

In this sweeping, detailed study, Paul Conrad interprets four centuries of Apache history through the analytical framework of diaspora, which he argues "helps us understand Apache and North American history better" (3). Drawing from Spanish-language archival documents from Spain, Mexico, and the United States, the U.S. National Archives, oral testimony from the Morris Edward Opler Papers, and a wealth of printed primary and secondary sources, the author convincingly proves his thesis that "[t]he history of the Apache diaspora reveals the efforts of outsiders to exploit, subjugate, or eliminate Indigenous peoples across more than four centuries, and Natives' own determination to resist and survive wherever they have found themselves" (290). While scholars have recently written thorough treatments of the Apaches de paz and indigenous slavery, Conrad's book is important for being the most thorough treatment of Apache captivity and forced migration written to date. Conrad uses "diaspora" rather broadly throughout the book. He and other scholars employ diaspora interchangeably with "migration" or "dispersal" of a people from their homeland; however, the author explains that Apaches also exhibit the four other characteristics of a more nuanced definition: "collective memory of an ancestral home, a continued connection to that home, a sustained group consciousness, and a sense of kinship with group members living in different places" (2-3).

In the Land of the Mountain Gods: Ethnotrauma and Exile among the Apaches of the American Southwest

Genocide Studies and Prevention, 2016

In the mid to late nineteenth century, two Indigenous groups of New Mexico territory, the Mescalero and the Chiricahua Apaches, faced violence, imprisonment, and exile. During a century of settler influx, territorial changeovers, vigilante violence, and Indian removal, these two cousin tribes withstood an experience beyond individual pain best described as ethnotrauma. Rooted in racial persecution and mass violence, this ethnotrauma possessed layers of traumatic reaction that not only revolved around their ethnicity, but around their relationship with their home lands as well. Disconnected from the ritual resources and sacred geographies that made up every day Apache living, both groups faced a profound and uphill struggle to maintain their community and very identity in the wake of immense and collective psychological distress. This essay emphasizes the role that geography plays in both the immediate impact of exile trauma and in the healing possibilities that this sacred connection to place has to offer Indigenous communities, even in the midst of exile.

Genocide Studies and Prevention: An International Journal In the Land of the Mountain Gods: Ethnotrauma and Exile among the Apaches of the American Southwest

In the mid to late nineteenth century, two Indigenous groups of New Mexico territory, the Mescalero and the Chiricahua Apaches, faced violence, imprisonment, and exile. During a century of settler influx, territorial changeovers, vigilante violence, and Indian removal, these two cousin tribes withstood an experience beyond individual pain best described as ethnotrauma. Rooted in racial persecution and mass violence, this ethnotrauma possessed layers of traumatic reaction that not only revolved around their ethnicity, but around their relationship with their home lands as well. Disconnected from the ritual resources and sacred geographies that made up every day Apache living, both groups faced a profound and uphill struggle to maintain their community and very identity in the wake of immense and collective psychological distress. This essay emphasizes the role that geography plays in both the immediate impact of exile trauma and in the healing possibilities that this sacred connection to place has to offer Indigenous communities, even in the midst of exile.

Reclaiming Land and Spirit in the Western Apache Homeland

AMERICAN INDIAN QUARTERLY, 2001

In the Apache language ni' means both land and mind, that is, country and way of thinking. This is no accident or random convergence. For the Apache people, as for many other Native Americans--to borrow a bit recklessly from the great anthropologist, Levi-Strauss--land is good to walk and good to think. The inseparability of land and thought, of geography and memory, and of place and wisdom has long been recognized by non-Indians. For a much longer period--since time immemorial, in fact--this unity has been put to work by Ndee, Dineh, and other people who possess spirits embedded in their place of living. What is relatively new and worth emphasizing is how this concept is at last receiving the attention it deserves from resource managers, from linguistic preservationists and cultural perpetuationists, and from historians, archaeologists, astronomers, tribal advocates, and teachers, to name just a few.

How the Pueblos Became Global: Colonial Appropriations, Resistance, and Diversity in the North American Southwest

Archaeologies, 2008

Theories of colonialism and modernity often present divergent ways of understanding how indigenous populations became global, yet there are several points of intersection. These points include: (1) the heterogeneity present within indigenous groups that led to varied experiences of colonialism, (2) the diversity in colonial programs, (3) how the colonized and the colonizers appropriated goods and labor from each other, and (4) the variable practices of indigenous resistance. These intersections are illustrated through a discussion of the Pueblos of the North American Southwest, from the late ''precontact'' period (ca. AD 1400) to the present.