Toward a Political Theory of Care: Understanding Care as "Service Provided" (original) (raw)
Related papers
The feminist argument against supporting care
The Journal of Practical Ethics, 2020
Care-supporting policies incentivise women’s withdrawal from the labour market, thereby reinforcing statistical discrimination and further undermining equality of opportunities between women and men for positions of advantage. This, I argue, is not sufficient reason against such policies. Supporting care also improves the overall condition of disadvantaged women who are care-givers; justice gives priority to the latter. Moreover, some of the most advantageous existing jobs entail excessive benefits; we should discount the value of allocating such jobs meritocratically. Further, women who have a real chance to occupy positions of advantage have most likely already enjoyed more than their fair share of opportunities; they lack a claim to more. Women can have a complaint grounded in the expressive disvalue of sexist discrimination. This gives them special claims against men occupying the vast majority of top positions and against their higher share of opportunities for positions of advantage. But their claim does not speak against care-supporting policies.
The Problems with Care: A Feminist Care Scholar Retrospective
Societies
Seeking to support qualitative researchers in the artful development of feminist care scholarship, our goal here is to ‘look back’ on how we have conceptualized the problems of care and developed research that illuminates the social organization of care in distinct ways. As part of a ‘feminist care scholar retrospective’, we present five condensed ‘reverse research proposals’, which are retrospective accounts of past research or scholarly activity. From there, we discuss how each project begins with a particular problematic for investigation and a particular conception of care (e.g., as practices, as work, as a concept) to illuminate facets of the social organization of care shaping paid and unpaid care work and its interpretations. These approaches reveal multiple and overlapping ways that care is embodied, understood and organized, as well as ways care can be transformed.
Dialogue on gender inequality: The politics of care - Conference report
The starting point of the conference organised by the Friedrich Ebert Foundation on 3 October 2016 was the idea that care for children, the sick and elderly is an integral part of human life and indispensable for social reproduction. Housework and care are not just issues of work–life balance but prerequisites of taking part in the labour market and of the functioning of the economy. It is not enough to encourage men to take their fair share in these responsibilities, we also need social systems that recognize the importance of care at their full value, and the growing pressure on our societies in relation to care.
The Ethics of Care: Valuing or Essentialising Women’s Work?
Springer eBooks, 2020
A major theme of ethics, introduced by feminist philosophers in the 1980s, concerns the role of care in human life. While the importance of care has historically been neglected by philosophy, some argue that it should be placed at the centre of our ethical systems and understood as a locus of distinctive virtues that have been wrongly devalued as feminine. Whether caring reflects a characteristically feminine set of virtues has been a source of controversy, with some arguing that women have different ethical approaches from men, while others argue this has no basis in an essential sexual or gender difference. Despite these important questions, it is valuable to explore what an ethics looks like that places central importance on relations of care.
CARE HAS LIMITS: WOMEN'S MORAL LIVES AND REVISED MEANINGS OF CARE WORK
Carleton University, 2020
What exactly keeps women ‘in’ inequitable care relationships, and how do we get ‘out’? This dissertation offers a timely response to a pressing societal problem – that of how to understand and organize care. Feminist scholarship and debates focus on the redistribution of care, considering how to shift care responsibilities from women to men or from individuals to the state. My research expands this work by critically reflecting on (shifting) relationships between women and the care economy with a focus on the moral dimensions of care work and on the narrative, intrasubjective work that women do. The research mobilizes sociological theories of care work, gender and moral worth, and uses feminist life history and arts-based, auto-ethnographic methods to contribute to a conceptual reimagining of “care.” Taking an interpretive, narrative, feminist approach, I draw on 20 in-depth life history interviews with 12 participants, as well as on my own autoethnographic experiences as a live-in care worker at L’Arche. I analyze how women narrate renegotiating care responsibilities or expectations across our lives and in different paid and unpaid care contexts in Ontario, Canada. Making links to class, gender and conditions in the caring economy, the project contextualizes women’s narratives of orienting to projects of care, negotiating moral dilemmas at the limits of care, and stepping back from or renegotiating care responsibilities. The study enriches feminist theories of care by developing a theorized account of the “relational care economy” that makes intrasubjective conditions, and the contradictions that people negotiate, central. I also contribute to a conceptual reimagining of “care” both by raising questions about whether “care as an ethic” should apply at the level of individual women’s lives, as well as by calling for a conception of care that makes limits central. Aiming to foster solidarity amongst carers in different roles, I ask tough questions about what we expect of ourselves and others, how we can stop setting women up for such intimate losses, and how our lives can be otherwise.
2013
Introduction: the importance of unpaid care 1.1 Rationale for the thematic review 1.2 Objectives and main research questions 2 Approach: theoretical perspectives and review methods 2.1 Theoretical framework 2.2 Methodology 3 Results 3.1 Social protection 3.1.1 Types of intent on unpaid care-social protection 3.1.2 The political economy of incorporating unpaid care into statements of intent-social protection 3.1.3 Evaluating implementation and outcomes of intent on unpaid care-social protection 3.2 Early childhood development (ECD) 3.2.1 Types of intent on unpaid care-ECD 3.2.2 The political economy of incorporating unpaid care into statements of intent-ECD 3.2.3 Evaluating implementation and outcomes of intent of unpaid care-ECD 4 Conclusions and future directions 4.1 Key findings 4.2 Analysing gaps in knowledge 4.3 An agenda for the future Annexe A: Methodology Annexe B: List of social protection policies covered in the review Annexe C: List of social protection policies that address unpaid care concerns Annexe D: List of early childhood (ECD) policies covered in the review Annexe E: List of ECD policies that address unpaid care concerns Annexe F: Declining trends (ECD) Annexe G: Conflicting discourse (ECD)
Feminist ethic of care: A third alternative approach
Health Care Analysis, 2004
A man with Alzheimer's who wanders around, a caregiver who disconnects the alarm, a daughter acting on het own, and a doctor who is not consulted set the stage for a feminist reflection on capacity/competence assessment. Feminist theory attempts to account for gender inequality in the political and in the epistemological realm. One of its tasks is to unravel the settings in which actual practices, i.c. capacity/competence assessment take place and offer an alternative. In this article the focus will be on a feminist ethics of care in which relationality, care, vulnerability, and responsibility are privileged concepts and attitudes. The emphasis on these notions leads to a specific view of autonomy that has consequences for both carereceivers (patients, clients) and caregivers (professional and not professional). These concepts constitute a default setting that shapes the context for capacity/competence assessment. Whereas this notion is meant to distinguish between those who need to be taken care of and those who do not, reflection on what it means to say 'those who need to be taken care of' is also required. The feminist analysis presented here emphasizes the necessity of the contextualization of assessment of competence. It sketches the multifold and complex grid that comprehends capacity assessment.
Feminist Perspectives on Care Economy
This paper seeks to Illustrate the perspective of feminist economics on care Identify the contribution and potential of feminist economic analyses to the field of care Illuminate the potential of feminist economic thought for the development of a radical reconceptualization of "the economy" and de-patriarchalizing practices