Invisible threads linking phantasmal landscapes in Java: Haunted places and memory in post-authoritarian Indonesia (original) (raw)

Abstract

The nation is often 'imagined' through various elements such as the media, education, ideologies, each providing the necessary 'boundaries' for its existence. It is also a space where the landscape is constructed and utilised to shape its citizens' perception. However, the idea of a nation is not just circumscribed by what is celebrated or visible but also by what is 'silenced'. During the transitional period between the Sukarno and Suharto administrations in the mid 60's, approximately 500,000-1 million suspected leftists, communists and dissidents were incarcerated and disappeared. Thus even 20 years after the downfall of Suharto's authoritarian regime, the incident continues to be an unspeakable 'open secret'. This paper posits that beneath Indonesia's modern veneer lies 'pockets' of spaces that physically mark this hidden history. I ask how Indonesians conceive and tell of this 'unmentionable' history through narratives that surround places of death and violence. I will be looking specifically at sites where dissidents have either been interrogated, imprisoned as well as executed. This research looks at how Indonesians utilise tales of the ghostly and the spectral as a way to bypass the taboo which surrounds the event and at the same time 'narrativise' it. I state that these tales of ghosts, hauntings and the supernatural are attempts by Indonesians to comprehend better what was otherwise an 'incomprehensible' event. Also, despite the state's best efforts in creating a vacuum on the event, I state that these sites of violence, the landscapes which they inhabit and the tales they carry, are part of an invisible landscape where a counter 'imagined community' exists linking these sites as well as the past and present. With each of the sites, a hidden history is thus revealed despite efforts in suppressing this knowledge.

Loading...

Loading Preview

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

References (78)

  1. In 2015, organizers of a panel on 1965 in the Ubud Writers Festival were 'warned' by the police not to go ahead with their event as it could 'reopen old wounds'. For more information please refer to the Jakarta Post's report 'Ubud festival banned from discussing 1965 massacre', 23 October 2015. https://www. thejakartapost.com/news/2015/10/23/ubud-festival-banned-discussing-1965-massacre.html (accessed 25 July 2019).
  2. For more information please refer to the Jakarta Post's report entitled 'Covert commies in 2019?: Prabowo warns about "latent danger" of communism', 25 November 2019. https://www.thejakartapost. com/news/2019/11/25/covert-commies-in-2019-prabowo-warns-about-latent-danger-of-communism. html (accessed 4 June 2019).
  3. One of the more significant studies of this particular episode in Indonesian history is Jemma Purdey's 'Anti-Chinese Violence in Indonesia: 1996-1999'. Honolulu: University of Hawai'i Press, 2006.
  4. It is only as recent as 2015 that a memorial was built to commemorate the violence against the ethnic Chinese in 1998. For more information please refer to the Jakarta Post's 'May 1998 monument hailed as a sign of state responsibility', 15 May 2015. https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2015/05/15/may- 1998-monument-hailed-sign-state-responsibility.html (accessed 20 August 2019).
  5. The origins of this oft quoted phrase can be found in a national day speech by president Sukarno on the 17th of August 1965. It also became the title of CJ Koch's 1978 book and was later adapted into a 1982 screen play starring Mel Gibson and Sigourney Weaver and directed by Peter Weir.
  6. The closest approximation one can come to in describing the pocong is a zombie. In the Malaysian and Indonesian spirit world, these zombies are essentially the remains of Muslims which are wrapped up in white burial cloth and then buried. Pocong are upright and skip as a form of locomotion.
  7. Please see 'GBN DIY Tolak Rencana Komnas Perempuan Alih Fungsikan Gedung Jefferson jadi Museum 65', 16 October 2016. http://www.zonasatu.co.id/2016/10/gbn-diy-tolak-rencana-komnas-per- empuan.html (accessed 20 October 2019).
  8. This issue has been extensively researched and written on by Katharine McGregor. Please refer to her article entitled 'Mass Graves and the memories of the 1965 Indonesian killings.' In: Kammen D and McGregor K (eds) Contours of Mass Violence in Indonesia, 1965-1968. Singapore: National University of Singapore, 2012, pp.234-262.
  9. Annie Pohlman refers to this as a search for the cap PKI or the PKI brand. For more information please refer to her publication entitled 'Women, Sexual Violence and the Indonesian Killings of 1965-66'. Oxford: Routledge, 2015.
  10. This information is from an interview conducted with the entrepreneur behind the site, whom added that the tourism revenue from the two caves had brought the community surrounding it out of poverty and allowing for economic diversification beyond that of agriculture.
  11. For more information please refer to a report by Tribun Jogja entitled 'Gua Grubug, Saksi Pembantaian Mengerikan PKI di Gunung Kidul'. https://jogja.tribunnews.com/2013/10/02/gua-grubug-saksi-pem- bantaian-mengerikan-pki-di-gunungkidul (accessed 3 August 2019).
  12. Sinkholes are depressions which form when the ground gives way due to some form of natural phenomenon.
  13. Mary Ida Bagus gives a detailed explanation on local concepts such as pitra madewa to describe how the Balinese 'incorporate' the killings of 1965 into a wider understanding of the event. She also refers to Toko Wong. For more information please refer to her article 'Transcending transgression with transgression: Inheriting Forsaken Souls in Bali'. In: Rao U and Hutnyk J (eds) Celebrating Transgression: Method and Politics in Anthropological Studies of Culture. New York, NY: Bergahn Books, 2006, pp.93-128.
  14. Both Jomblang and Grubug are only 10 km away from another mass grave located in the district of Wonosari where an attempted re-burial was met with great resistance in the early 2000s. For more infor- mation please refer to Katharine McGregor's 'Mass graves and the memories of the 1965 Indonesian killings'. In: Kammen D and McGregor K (eds) Contours of Mass in Indonesia, 1965-1968. Singapore: Singapore University Press, 2012, pp.234-262.
  15. For more information please refer to 'Hantu-hantu di Alas Roban, Pengendara Mobil Tanpa Kepala hingga Kuntilanak Pencari Tumbal'. https://lifestyle.okezone.com/read/2019/06/27/612/2071793/hantu- hantu-di-alas-roban-pengendara-motor-tanpa-kepala-hingga-kuntilanak-pencari-tumbal (accessed 28 July 2019).
  16. Please refer to 'Cerita mistis bikin merinding sebelum mobil guling di Grobongan'. Muria News. https:// www.murianews.com/2017/03/27/110792/cerita-mistis-bikin-merinding-sebelum-mobil-guling-di- grobogan.html (accessed 16 June 2019).
  17. For more information please refer to CNN's 'Melihat Alas Roban, Jalun Tengkorak Mudik Lebaran', 28 May 2019. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20190514203034-20-394894/melihat-alas-roban- jalur-tengkorak-mudik-lebaran/2 (accessed 6 September 2019).
  18. Please see CNN Indonesia's 'Temuan 346 Kuburan Massal Korban '65 Dilaporkan Komnas Ham'. https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20191003141934-20-436406/temuan-346-kuburan-massal- korban-65-dilaporkan-ke-komnas-ham (accessed 5 May 2019).
  19. In an area east of Semarang a forested area near the district of Pati is also said to be similarly haunted by headless spirits. This site is reputedly an execution site for PKI sympathizers. For more informa- tion please refer to Tribun Jateng's 'Lokasi Kuburan Massal Ini Dikenal Angker, Warga Sering Melihat Penampakan Tubuh Tanpa Kepala', 11 May 2016. https://jateng.tribunnews.com/2016/05/11/lokasi- kuburan-massal-ini-dikenal-angker-warga-sering-melihat-penampakan-tubuh-tanpa-kepala (accessed 8 August 2019).
  20. For more information please refer to Kar-Yen Leong's 'Filling in the Gaps: Remembering the 1965 Killings in Indonesia'. In: Kritika Kultura No.33/34 2019/2020, pp.730-760.
  21. References Adam AW (2007) Pelurusan Sejarah Indonesia. Jogjakarta: Ombak.
  22. Anderson R and O'Benedict G (2006) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and the Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso Books.
  23. Anderson R, O'Benedict G and Mcvey RT (2009) A Preliminary of the October 1, 1965 Coup in Indonesia. Singapore: Equinox Publishing.
  24. Bille M, Hastrup F and Sorenson TF (2010) Introduction: An anthropology of silence. In: Bille M, Hastrup F and Sorenson TF (eds) An Anthropology of Absence: Materialisations of Transcendence and Loss. New York, NY: Springer, pp.3-22.
  25. Bubandt N (2009) Interview with an ancestor: Spirits as informants and the politics of possession in North Maluku. Ethnography 3(10): 291-316.
  26. Bubandt N (2017) Spirits as technology: Tech-gnosis and the ambivalent politics of the invisible in Indonesia. Contemporary Islam 11(1): 1-18.
  27. Bustam M (2016) Dari Kamp Ke Kamp: Cerita Seorang Perempuan. Jakarta: Spasi.
  28. Chandra S (2017) New findings on the Indonesian killings of 1965-66. The Journal of Asian Studies 76(4): 1059-1086.
  29. Chandra S (2019) Glimpses of Indonesia's 1965 massacre through the lens of the census: The role of trucks and roads in 'crushing' the PKI in East Java. Indonesia 108: 1-21.
  30. Cribb R (2018) The Killing Season: A History of the Indonesian Massacres, 1965-66. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
  31. Dragojlovic A (2012) Materiality loss and redemptive hope in the Indonesian leftist diaspora. Indonesia and the Malay World 20(117): 160-174.
  32. Dwyer L (2009) A politics of silences: Violence, memory, and treacherous speech in Post-1965 Bali. In: Hinton AL and O'Neill K (eds) Truth, Memory, and Representations: Anthropological Approaches. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, pp.113-146.
  33. Eickhoff M, Danardono D, Rahardjo T, et al. (2017) The memory landscapes of '1965' in Semarang. Journal Genocide Research 19(4): 530-550.
  34. Ferrandiz F (2014) Subterranean autopsies: Exhumations of mass graves in contemporary Spain. In: Schindel E and Colombo P (eds) Space and the Memories of Violence: Landscapes of Erasure, Disappearance, and Exception. New York: Palgrave-Macmillan, pp.61-73.
  35. Foucault M (2018) Texts/Contexts: Of other spaces. In: Preziosi D and Farago C (eds.) Grasping the World: The Idea of the Museum. London: Routledge, pp.371-379.
  36. Goh RBH and Yeoh BS (2003) Urbanism and postcolonial nationalities: Theorising the Southeast Asian city. In: Theorising the Southeast Asian City as Text: Urban Landscapes, Cultural Documents, and Interpretative Experiences. Singapore: World Scientific, pp.1-12.
  37. Hearman V (2018) Unmarked Graves: Death and Survival in the Anti-Communist Violence in East Java, Indonesia. Singapore: NUS Press.
  38. Hitchcock M (1998) Tourism, taman mini and national identity. Indonesia and the Malay World 26(74): 124-135.
  39. Kong L and Yeoh BS (2003) The Politics of Landscapes in Singapore: Constructions of 'Nation'. Syracuse, NY: Syracuse University Press.
  40. Kusno A (2000) Behind the Postcolonial: Architecture Urban Space and Political Cultures in Indonesia. London: Routledge.
  41. Kusno A (2003) Remembering/forgetting the May riots: Architecture, violence and the making of 'Chinese cultures' in post-1998 Jakarta. Public Culture 15(1): 149-177.
  42. Kusno A (2013) After the New Order: Space, Politics and Jakarta. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
  43. Kwon H (2008) The Ghosts of War in Vietnam. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  44. Lamb K (2016) Waiting for Glodok: The ghost street haunted by Indonesia's riots. Guardian Newspaper, 22 November. Available at: https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/nov/22/glodok-jakarta-recover- indonesia-1998-riots-chinatown
  45. Lemelson R and Suryani LK (2006) The spirits, Ngeb, and the social suppression of memory: A complex clinical case from Bali. Culture, Medicine, and Psychiatry 31(2): 389-413.
  46. McGregor K, Melvin J and Pohlman A (2002) Commemoration of 1 October Hari Kesaktian Pancasila: A post-mortem analysis? Asian Studies Review 26(1): 39-72.
  47. McGregor K, Melvin J and Pohlman A (2007) History in Uniform: Military Ideology and the Construction of Indonesia's Past. Singapore: Singapore University Press.
  48. McGregor K, Melvin J and Pohlman A (2018) New interpretations of the causes, dynamics, and legacies of the Indonesian genocide. In: Mcgregor K, Melvin J and Pohlman A (eds) The Indonesian Genocide of 1965: Causes, Dynamics and Legacies. Melbourne: Palgrave-Macmillan, pp.1-26.
  49. Manning P (2012) Governing memory: Justice, reconciliation, and outreach at the extraordinary chambers in the courts of Cambodia. Memory Studies 5(2): 165-181.
  50. Marching ST (2015) A specter is haunting Indonesia, but why? Jakarta Globe. Available at: https://jakart- aglobe.id/context/commentary-specter-haunting-indonesia/ (accessed 15 May 2019).
  51. Margiyono KTY and Yulianti (2007) Neraka Rezim Orde Baru: Tempat-Tempat Penyiksaan Orde Baru. Jakarta: Spasi.
  52. May B (1978) The Indonesian Tragedy. London: Routledge and K Paul.
  53. Melvin J (2018) The Army and the Indonesian Genocide: Mechanics of Mass Murder. London: Routledge.
  54. Miller S (2018) Zombie anti-communism? Democratisation and the demons of suharto-era politics in contem- porary Indonesia. In: McGregor K, Melvin J and Pohlman A (eds) The Indonesian Genocide of 1965: Causes, Dynamics, and Legacies. Melbourne: Palgrave-Macmillan, pp.287-310.
  55. Moertopo A (1973) Some Basic Thoughts on the Acceleration and Modernisation of 25 Years' Development. Jakarta: Centre for Strategic and International Studies.
  56. Napolitano V (2015) Anthropology and traces. Anthropological Theory 15(1): 47-67.
  57. Oppenheimer J (2014) The Act of Killing. New York, NY: Drafthouse Films.
  58. Oppenheimer J (2016) The Look of Silence. New York, NY: Drafthouse Films.
  59. Paramaditha I (2011) Questions on witnessing violence. The Jakarta Post Monday, April 4. Available at: https://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2011/04/04/questions-witnessing-violence.html (accessed 6 June 2020).
  60. Pemberton J (1994) On the Subject of "Java". Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
  61. Pohlman A (2013) Telling stories about torture in Indonesia: Managing risk in a culture of impunit. Oral History Forum 33: 1-17.
  62. Pohlman A (2016) Janda PKI: Stigma and sexual violence against communist widows following the 1965- 1966 massacres in Indonesia. Indonesia and the Malay World 44(128): 68-83.
  63. Roosa J (2006) Pretext for Mass Murder: The September 30 Movement and Suharto Coup D'état in Indonesia. Madison, WI: University Of Wisconsin Press.
  64. Schindel E (2014) Ghosts and Companeros: Haunting stories and the quest for justice around Argentina's former terror sites. Rethinking History: The Journal of Theory and Practise 18(2): 244-264.
  65. Siegel JT (1998) Early thoughts on the violence of May 13 and 14 1998 in Jakarta. Indonesia 66: 74-108.
  66. Sion B (2011) Conflicting sites of memory in post-genocide Cambodia. Humanity Journal (Spring) 2: 1-16.
  67. Sopandi S (2009) Indonesian architectural culture during guided democracy (1959-1965): Sukarno and the works of Friedrich Silaban. In: Vu T and Wongsurawat W Dynamics of the Cold War in Asia: Ideology, Identity, and Culture. New York, NY: Palgrave-Macmillan, pp.53-72.
  68. Surywan IN (2007) Ladang Hitam di Pulau Dewa: Pembantaian massal 1965 di Bali. Jakarta: Buku Kita. Tempo (2012) Liputan Khusus Pengakuan Algojo 1965. Edisi 1, 7 Oktober.
  69. Triyana B (2003) Peristiwa purwodadi: Kasus pembunuhan massal anggota dan simpatisan partai komunis Indonesia di kabupaten grobongan tahun 1965-1969. Unpublished Undergraduate Thesis, University of Diponegoro, Semarang.
  70. Tyner JA (2009) Imagining genocide: Anti-geographies and the erasure of space in democratic Kampuchea. Space and Polity 13(1): 9-20.
  71. van de Kroef JM (1965) Indonesian communism's 'revolutionary gymnastics. Asian Survey 5(5): 217-232.
  72. van Doorn-Harder N (2019) Purifying women, purifying Indonesia: The national commission for women's rights and the 1965-1968 anti-communist violence. Cross Currents 69(3): 301-318.
  73. Wieringa SE (2003) Birth of the new order state in Indonesia: sexual politics and nationalism. Journal of Women's History 15(1): 70-91.
  74. Wieringa SE and Katjasungkana N (2019) Propaganda and the Genocide in Indonesia: Imagined Evil. Oxford: Routledge.
  75. Wieringa SE, Melvin J and Pohlman A (eds) (2019) The International People's Tribunal for 1965 and the Indonesian Genocide. Oxford: Routledge.
  76. Williamson T (2003) Malaysia's national expressway. Space and Culture 6(2): 110-131.
  77. Wessing R (2006) A community of spirits: People, ancestors, and nature spirits in java. Crossroads: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 18(1): 11-111.
  78. Yeoh BS (2003) Contesting Space in Colonial Singapore: Power Relations and the Urban Built Environment. Singapore: Singapore University Press.