The Geopolitics of Renewables in Kazakhstan and Russia (original) (raw)
Related papers
PONARS Eurasia Policy Memo #538, 2018
Energy and natural resource use has always been a key issue of geopolitics, but as more countries adopt "post-oil" transition policies, environmental sustainability has itself become an important geopolitical issue that is increasingly defining political relations among and within states. Leaders in both Kazakhstan and Russia-two of Eurasia's leading hydrocarbon producers-have been investing in new alternative energy infrastructures, "green economy" development, and certain forms of environmental sustainability. Among these were high-profile initiatives: Kazakhstan recently hosted EXPO-2017 with the theme of "Future Energy" and Russia had "The Year of the Environment 2017." Iconic or exceptional as many sustainability initiatives may be, these projects shed light on the region's changing energy geographies. They also raise important questions about how and why local leaders have been advancing these policies when both Kazakhstan and Russia's political economies are still so tied to traditional energy extraction. Do new alternative energy projects mark a sea change of promoting "future energy" transitions in Eurasia? Alternatively, do these projects risk further entrenching hydrocarbon dependency in both countries? Whose interests are at stake in such transitions? And how might recent renewable energy initiatives support or challenge prevailing political configurations in Kazakhstan and Russia? While some changes are underway, infrastructure challenges and networks of power-players and rent-seekers, as well as a shallow civic commitment to environmental protection, make it difficult to create new energy capacities based on renewables, despite governmental advocacy of it.
ENERGY POLITICS: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF KAZAKHSTAN
As being a young sovereign state, Kazakhstan had developed a close relationship with the U.S. ever since it gained independence from the Soviet Union. Kazakhstan consists huge deposits of oil and natural gas and bordering the Caspian Sea that attracts the interests of energy consuming countries of the world. The U.S is much interested in Kazakh's huge natural resources, therefore it promoted many U.S. companies to invest in Kazakh's energy sector. Due to the largest foreign investor in the development of Kazakh economy, the U.S tried to establish its hegemony in Kazakhstan as well as in the Caspian Sea by encouraging its economic assistance for the development of the region. On the other hand, Kazakhstan also needs the U.S assistance and investment due to its landlocked location and weak infrastructure. This article examines the role of oil and gas for determining Kazakh economic relations with the U.S. It discusses that Kazakhstan has been following the Multi-vector foreign policy due to geopolitical location and consisting huge natural resources. On the other hand, it will also evaluate the pipeline politics and Russian engagement in the region for oil and natural gas resources of Kazakhstan that hinders the flow of Kazakh-U.S relations.
Energy Research & Social Science, 2018
Against the background of a global energy transition, resource-rich Russia embarked on renewable energy policies (REPs). Having set a renewable goal of 4.5% in the electricity mix (2009), Russia's government introduced support schemes on the wholesale (2013) and retail (2015) electricity markets. This raises the question of how Russia's elite explain this rollout of REPs, as a global shift towards renewables may threaten hydrocarbon exports. Common driverssecurity of supply and ecological considerationsseem unconvincing given Russia's substantial fossil fuel reserves and limited implementation of international climate change agreements. Building on a self-compiled database of 395 Russian texts dealing with renewable energy, this article maps Russia's elite discourse through argument comparison between actors, audiences and over time. By doing so it critically assesses resource-geographic, financial, institutional and ecological enabling and constraining factors. The article concludes that the main elite arguments for REPs are as an attempt to avert the green menace by establishing a Russia-based RE industry. This would ensure that the country catches up with global technological development and allows Russia to remain an important energy power through diversification towards RE exports. Climate change arguments are mainly used abroad in order to demonstrate Russia's efforts in meeting international obligations. "Frankly speaking, in the field of innovative renewable energy technologies, we are lagging behind states that have an education level far below ours. Far below ours !" (Former president Medvedev, 2014) [1]
Central Asia and the Caucasus, vol 21 issue 2, 2020
Kazakhstan actively cooperates with Russia in the energy sector, which is directly associated with the role played by the fuel and energy complex in the functioning of all sectors of the Kazakh economy. The paper considers the main factors in the development of Kazakhstan’s fuel and energy complex, and concludes that its partnership with Russia is important in ensuring national security in a contextual sense. The article also considers the risks of Kazakhstan’s energy policy based on the geopolitical competition of regional and global actors.
Fuelling the New Great Game: Kazakhstan, energy policy and the EU
Asia Europe Journal, 2016
This article looks at the BNew Great Game^as the most widely used metaphor for the geopolitical dynamics of Central Asia. Its focus is on Kazakhstan and Europe with particular reference to energy policies. The European approach to Kazakhstan is conditioned by its energy security priorities with issues of democracy and human rights relegated to the margins. For Kazakhstan, the article suggests that the game is played with an eye to regime legitimacy, territorial integrity, and international recognition. Relations between Kazakhstan, China and Russia are also examined. Some of the limitations and strengths of the Great Game metaphor are analysed. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, the countries of Central Asia again became the focus of attention for competing world powers: BCentral Asia, for good or for ill, is back once more in the thick of the news, and looks like staying there for a long time to come^(Hopkirk 1992, p. xviii). This renewed awareness reflects the role played by Central Asian states in the wider interaction between the major players in world politics such as America, China, Russia and the European Union (EU). For the individual states, such as Kazakhstan, the changed focus is both a constraint and an opportunity. As Cooley (Cooley 2012a) suggests: Some commentators have referred to Washington, Moscow, and Beijing's renewed activity in the region as a modern iteration of the Great Game. But
The Energy Politics of Russia and Eurasia
Oxford Handbook of Energy Politics, 2019
[FOR INDIVIDUAL RESEARCH USE ONLY - NO COPYING OR DISTRIBUTION] As one of the world's largest fossil fuel exporters, Russia is a key player in the global energy arena. It also plays a unique role in the former Soviet Union (FSU) as the largest producer and exporter, as well as an important transit country.
Renewable energy in Kazakhstan: Challenges to policy and governance
Energy Policy, 2021
In light of sluggish progress in developing renewable energy generation in Kazakhstan, this paper aims to investigate the perceptions and opinions of actors in the field regarding policy design and effectiveness of governance for renewables. Known for its vast natural resources including oil, gas, and coal, Kazakhstan has been using fossil fuels as a principal driver of its economy since 1991, when it gained the status of an independent nation. While policy on renewables and governance has been institutionalised since 2006, progress has been slow. Based on the data from in-depth interviews, the study identified that actors viewed policy design as a preliminary, although necessary, stage, subject to adjustments. The investors were concerned with multiple gaps and inconsistencies in the governance structure, and many walked away. The paper concludes that the use of active power of central government appeared insufficient for delivering results in policy design and governance. Making changes to its policy and governance, the government also needs to use its agenda-setting and preference-shaping power to ensure the engagement of investors, interest groups, local communities, and consumers for increasing renewable energy generation.
The Role of Energy in Russian Foreign Policy towards Kazakhstan
Energy is a significant factor in the formation of Russian foreign policy, particularly towards Kazakhstan. This book seeks to isolate the role of energy amid a sea of other factors already attended to by mainstream literature in the Anglo-American and Russian traditions. What is missing from the contemporary literature, however, is a well-rounded and thorough scientific approach to the study of energy’s role in foreign policy. To begin filling this gap, the methodology of political science is supplemented here by a multi-disciplinary approach in which significant space is allocated to other areas of study relevant to energy and its repercussions on geographical, technological, legal, and economic issues. The originality of the present work is not intended to be found in its conclusions but in the uniquely scientific methods employed in drawing them. Its fresh analytic approach will be appreciated by students and scholars who are interested in new ways of looking at energy issues. (May 2011)
Relationships Between Foreign Policy and Energy Security in Central Asia: A Case Study Of Kazakhstan
Journal of the Black Sea Studies, 2021
Kazakhstan is major energy producer in Central Asia, and has been pursuing a multi-vector foreign policy since it gained independence from Soviet Union. It has played host to many multinational energy from Russia, China, the USA and Europe. Nazarbayev's multilateral and multi-vector foreign and privatization policies have had a significant impact on the country's energy [security] policy over the last three decades. Emphasizing good relations between itself with both global and regional powers, Kazakhstan has maintained a balance among Russian, Western and Chinese companies via defensive realist approach. This balance is especially visible in both the role that those companies play in exploration projects, as well as in the building of oil and gas pipelines.