" As I Twirl This Spindle, . . . ": Ritualization and the Magical Efficacy of Household Tasks in Western Antiquity (original) (raw)
2021, Preternature
In Mediterranean antiquity the ritual acts of binding and charming were often associated with ordinary domestic tasks reoriented through accompanying incantations and sometimes the adjustment of the task’s gestures. Drawing on theories of ritualization (Bell, Humphrey and Laidlaw) and extending the classical evidence with medieval and modern comparative materials, this paper addresses how mundane economic practices are brought into service for magical performance. Ritualization highlights the process by which a domestic “agent” can isolate and transform some particular element or stage in an overall activity (clothes-making, cooking) to reflect a sense of stipulation, of traditional and efficacious action, and thus reorient the isolated domestic task for curse or binding charms.
Related papers
"The Magic of Early Medieval Ritual", Early Medieval Europe 17 (2009), pp.111-125
Whether, and how, we ought to study early medieval rituals has been much debated recently, including in the pages of this journal by Geoffrey Koziol and Philippe Buc. This paper is intended as a contribution to this debate, and argues that rituals’ written or spoken interpretations are not a simple rendering of the ritualized actions’ ‘meanings’ in words and must therefore be analysed separately, not conflated with the possible effects of performance. Ritualized acts thus had two loci: the short-term experience of the embodied performance, and the long-term struggle over interpretation in speech and writing, both of which need to be explored with appropriate methodologies. Whilst the textuality of our sources thus needs to be taken seriously, it is proposed that we can also say something about the possible or even probable characteristics of early medieval ritualized acts as the medium of bodily postures and gestures used for demonstrative public interations between power holders.
The concept of magic in late medieval Europe has long been misunderstood as a category separate from medieval religion. Medieval religious activity included a broad spectrum of rituals commonly separated from religious thought and activity and labeled “magic” or “superstition” by modern historians. While part of this re-categorization was occurring in the Church during the late medieval period, driven by increasing anxiety about heresy and the nascent development of witchcraft, popular piety continued to include unorthodox rituals that answered the needs of medieval laity. These rituals, when taken in the context of other religious behavior, expressed a nuanced understanding of the world of the medieval laity, shedding light on their concerns and anxieties, giving them agency in an uncertain world. A historical narrative about a fictional medieval family helps imagine how rituals in and out of the Church interplayed to give structure, meaning, and agency to late medieval laity.
Magic and Ritual in Iron Age Veneto, Italy
In this article I discuss the possibility that the Iron Age Veneti of Northern Italy believed in magic. By drawing on ethno-historical comparisons and contextual analysis, I suggest that items such as pierced shells, coral, amber, glass beads and bronze pendants were possibly employed as amulets by children, women and, far more rarely, by men. I also examine the placing of selected non-edible animal remains such as horns, teeth, and astragali (knucklebones) in ritual contexts, suggesting than their meaning, whether magical, religious or more mundane, can be understood only through a careful evaluation of the circumstances of deposition. I finally point out that the study of magic in prehistory has been often passed over and devalued, probably for a lack of written sources and proper evidence. On the contrary, I argue that a more holistic approach to ritual and to the several layers of meaning embedded in magical objects can offer valuable insights into wider issues such as the management of power and the construction of past individuals' social and personal identities.
Restoring the Magician: Making Room for Ritual Specialists in the Graeco-Roman World
2019
Graeco-Roman magic and magicians have been studied and theorized by classicists and historians of religion for at least a hundred years. Despite the sustained interest by the academy, magic and magicians have not, until recently, been systematically theorized as belonging to a broader pattern of cultural activity that involved coercing the gods to achieve desirable outcomes. Classicists and historians have also tended to see Graeco-Roman magicians in the ancient world as antithetical to classical Greek thought and philosophy. Practitioners of magic have seldom been taken seriously. This study reappraises the wealth of evidence for the presence practitioners of magic in the ancient world, as well as the category “magic” itself, for the purpose of understanding how a broad group of freelance ritual actors worked, operated, and rose in popularity during the first four centuries of the common era. I begin by reassessing the category magic and argue that “freelance ritual specialists” can better encompass the broad group of ritual actors who performed private coercive rituals for clients. I then examine the cultural reception of freelance ritual specialists to demonstrate their enduring presence in Roman culture and demonstrate that they were not cultural oddities or outliers. I conclude the study with a theoretical approach to understanding different types of freelance ritual specialists in the ancient world, as well as theorizing how Roman imperialism may have produced an increase in freelance ritual specialists by dislocating local specialized priests from their temples and gods.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.