Crime and the design of residential property – exploring the perceptions of planning professionals, burglars and other users: Part 2 (original) (raw)
2001, Property Management
This paper provides a critical review of``Defensible Space'' and traces the development of Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) in America and Canada, and Secured By Design (SBD) initiatives in the UK. It is argued that various aspects of the theory have avoided consideration and require further investigation and research. It is opined that``defensible space'' is the theoretical foundation to both CPTED and SBD and it is posited that a thorough re-examination of Newman's ideas will serve to deepen our understanding of the complex relationship between the built environment and crime. British (BS8220) and European (CEN TC/325) Standards relating to urban planning and environmental design and crime reduction are currently receiving detailed deliberation and are based firmly upon Newman's ideas. The projected need for some 4.4 million new homes in Britain (DOE, 1995) by 2016 and Lord Roger's call for improvements in urban design to reduce suburban migration from cities (DETR, 1999) reiterates the importance of the subject matter. This paper (the first of two) recognises that design per se does not represent the panacea for reducing criminogeneity, rather, that``defensible space'' CPTED and SBD should be considered as crime prevention strategies, which can, in common with all other initiatives, contribute to tackling the problem of residential crime. In conclusion, it is argued that further research concerning how``defensible space'' is perceived by various crucial stakeholders in society is the way forward in this regard. A second, forthcoming paper (PM, Vol. 19 No. 3) will present these research findings.
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
Related papers
2012
This work examines means by which the likelihood of an offender being detected may be calculated. However, the formulas presented are not meant to be applied at the individual or situational level, rather they are for estimating figures for the populous of offenders. The authors discuss "the dark figure" (i.e., the number of "crimes not detected and crimes not reported") and "the clearance rate" (i.e., "the percentage of the crimes reported which are considered cleared" by police). The authors also point out that detection at the situational level is composed of "total risk of detection" and the "primary risk of detection". The primary risk refers to being caught in the act, versus all possible means of being detected (e.g., post facto). Surprisingly, the authors do not believe that offenders have much control over getting "caught red-handed", saying that "to get caught in the act is a random occurrence."
Crime prevention through environmental design (CPTED) began to develop in the early 1970s as a response to an increase in crime and fear in urban areas. Advancing research in CPTED requires clarifying the theoretical conceptualizations and validating an integrated CPTED model. The purpose of this study is to develop and validate a hierarchical CPTED model for urban neighborhoods. Conceptually, this study extends theory by reframing CPTED as a reflective, hierarchical construct and modelling its impact on burglary victimization. Confirmatory factor analysis revealed that CPTED is a third-order, reflective construct model with four main dimensions, namely, surveillance, access control, territoriality and maintenance. The results of the structural model support the theoretical findings in the literature that associate high CPTED with low victimization. The scale can be applied for a wide range of landed residential properties. Crime prevention practitioners should take these factors into consideration to make informed decisions for future developments.
Impact of Housing Design on Crime
Encyclopedia of Quality of Life and Well-Being Research, 2014
The article provides a brief outline to the field of Crime Prevention through Environmental Design (CPTED) and explains how the application of CPTED to housing design can contribution to reductions in crime and consequent benefits to residents' quality of life. Christmann and Rogerson (2004), following a secondary analysis of a household survey data, concluded that measures to reduce crime in a neighbourhood can make an important contribution to enhanced quality of life. The following discussion describes measures to prevent crime through the manipulation of the physical environment in and around residential neighbourhoods.It should be noted that the principles can be extended to cover the prevention of crime and enhancement of quality of life across other realms of life including the work place, across public transport networks and in leisure time (Crowe, 2001).
2018
Crime Prevention through Environmental Design (CPTED) is a method of reducing crime through the design and manipulation of the built environment. Based upon the New Opportunity Theories of crime, CPTED focuses upon blocking opportunities for criminal behaviour through subtle techniques to maximise informal surveillance, territoriality and guardianship, to minimise through movement and to set standards of physical security that are proportionate to crime risk. This chapter will discuss the principles of CPTED and the theories from which it evolved, before exploring how CPTED is applied internationally in terms of policy, guidance and practice. Examples include Chile, Mexico, and Brazil, as well as countries with more established processes of implementing CPTED within the planning process (England and Wales, Netherlands and Australia). Evidence regarding effectiveness will be presented and consideration will be given to the extent to which principles, practice and procedure can be tra...
Proposed Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design: Gated Cmmunity and non-Gated Community
This working paper constitutes a research proposal through environmental design focused on residential neighbourhoods. This study is formulated as a result of the escalating crime rate in housing areas especially daytime and nocturnal house-breaking crimes that increased by as much as 2.1 percent from 2005 to 2007 in Malaysia (PDRM, 2008). Various methods to reduce crime have been adopted by both the public and private sectors. Similarly housing developers are not to be left out in taking initiatives to reduce crime through the development of gated community residences by providing a security system to protect against crime. Furthermore, the gated community concept is gaining popularity from the point of view of house buyers as it offers an additional alternative focusing on security as a main factor besides offering other facilities that could enhance comfort for the residents. These findings are based on the gated community concept of development that have been applied in western countries especially in the United States that is believed to have been able to reduce crime rate in housing areas. Following a spike in demand for such housing concept, the formulation of a gated community housing concept guideline started getting the attention of Local Authorities to ensure that its construction adheres to the provisions of the law to fulfil market demand. As such this study proposes to make a comparison between crime rate reduction in gated community housing areas and non-gated community housing areas and to study the residents' perception of their fear of crime. The findings of this study are important to produce a safe housing guideline based on crime prevention concept through environmental design.
Crime prevention in urban spaces through environmental design: A critical UK perspective
Cities, 2019
Crime Prevention through Environmental Design (CPTED) and the Defensible Space Theory have been adopted to enable the effective use of the built environment to reduce crime. The occurrence of crime is widely accepted to be context-specific. Some explanatory theories have focused on social disorder, alluding to the notion that if such disorders are eliminated from society then serious crime would be eradicated. Numerous approaches have considered the use of environmental design and spatial configuration as a possible solution to reduce crime. The main aim of this study is to gain further understanding of stakeholders' perceptions of Brixton Town Centre (BTC) in London and thus advance the discourse of CPTED. Using a mixed methodology approach, a visual audit of CPTED, a critical analysis of police crime data, questionnaire surveys and semi-structured interviews were carried out to gauge the effectiveness of key CPTED intervention principles identified in BTC. It was revealed that since the interventionary measures began in BTC in 2011, there has been an increase in the crime rates for other parts of England and Wales whilst BTC in particular has experienced a decline. A positive correlation was found between length of residency in the area and fear of crime. Lighting was critical to people's perception of feeling secure. Finally, the research findings revealed that although crime rates had fallen in BTC, stakeholders agree that further improvement was required. This research concludes with a proposal of further study that will theorize the phenomenon occurring at BTC.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.
Related papers
BAU JOURNAL: HEALTH AND WELLBEING, SPECIAL EDITION © BEIRUT ARAB UNIVERSITY, LEBANON - 1st INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON URBAN HEALTH & WELLBEING UHWB-2018 - BUILDING COLLABORATIVE INTELLIGENCE FOR BETTER LIVES IN CITIES, OCTOBER 23:25 / 2018, 2018