Racist and Patriarchal Justice in Argentina: the Reina Maraz case (original) (raw)
Related papers
Let justice be done! Multiple oppressions before the legal system from a case in Argentina
2021
The paper focuses on the description of an interdisciplinary intervention carried out within the framework of the arrest in 2020 of a woman accused of the murder of her newborn daughter, in a home delivery in 2005. The disciplinary framework of the intervention is the area of legal anthropology, in which it is about thinking about how the legal system should act in order to be able to resolve conflicts in situations of cultural inequalities, both material and symbolic. Those of us who participate belong to the historical / anthropological fields and the law and together we try to address the conflict in search of modifying the criminal situation the protagonist of this story who also participates in this article sharing her testimony. The methodological perspectives that articulate the work are within the universe of ethno-qualitative strategies, in which participant observation and ethnographic interviews are the main input of this cut.
Feminist Studies, 2017
This article unveils the gendered, racialized, and silent sexual dimensions at play in the criminalization of Milagro Sala, the charismatic and controversial female indigenous leader of the Organización Barrial Tupac Amaru in Argentina. It argues this organization was able to contest narrow definitions of women’s welfare used in local state bureaucracies in terms of certain redistribution and recognition, while fostering complex and controversial state-movement relations in terms of transparency and accountability. In important ways, Tupac Amaru politicized the “undeserving poor.” Women who did not conform to the moral prescriptions that patrol the conduct of poor women were the backbone and the leadership of the organization. Drawing on interviews, fieldwork materials, and documents gathered between 2009 and 2017, this paper shows that the main problems created by the criminalization of the organization were not only the arbitrary detention of Sala. Equally significant, the criminalization also brought about sudden negative changes in poor women and LGBT popular sectors’ living conditions, employment opportunities, and access to health care, alongside the overall erosion of minimal gains in social and economic rights. It ultimately undermined the legitimacy of rights-based demands of popular and indigenous sectors in a multi-ethnic society.
Argentinian Transitional Justice Process: Women Behind
In the Argentinian transitional justice process, women's issues were neglected by all the different mechanisms that attempted to redress the gross human rights violations perpetrated during the last military dictatorship. In other words, democracy failed women and relegated them to their traditional roles as keepers of the family at the time that they started to demand justice for their identities and bodily and sexual integrity. This essay analyses the significance of the sexual violence carried out against women in clandestine detention centres during the last military dictatorship. Furthermore, it explores the position of gender justice within the Argentinian transitional justice process, and the gender discrimination that has made sexual violence committed against women a taboo into the transitional justice mechanisms in Argentina.
A Quest for Justice in Cuzco, Peru:Race and Evidence in the Case of Mercedes Ccorimanya Lavilla
PoLAR: Political and Legal Anthropology Review, 2008
The life of Mercedes Ccorimanya Lavilla renders a telling portrait about the pursuit of justice in Cuzco, Peru, revealing how courts of law can be key sites in the production and negotiation of racial and gender taxonomies. Mercedes (who was gang-raped as a young woman) illustrates the near heroic efforts necessary to mount and pursue rape charges in Peruvian courts, where rape victims largely manage the construction of evidence in lieu of the state. In the following article, I reconstruct the social circumstances and legal institutional setting surrounding the rape trial of Mercedes Ccorimanya Lavilla through the use of historical and ethnographic materials. In arguing that race often defines women's sexuality in rural Peru, I show how (in order to achieve a conviction) Mercedes had to develop a strategy in which she instrumentally employed the languages of race to distance herself from her own indigeneity, as well as that of her alleged attackers. Q1 Addressing the bleakness of modern life, Hannah Arendt (1968) noted that ordinary lives often radiate the most profound light. The life of Mercedes Ccorimanya Lavilla, a self-proclaimed campesino (indigenous peasant) who was gang-raped in the province of Cuzco, Peru, as a young woman, illuminates our world in many ways. Mercedes' case is exceptional because, out of the 250 cases filed under the rubric of rape that I examined in the superior court archive of Cuzco (spanning nearly a century, from 1909 to 2001), hers was one of only five violent rapes that ended in a conviction (Bunt 2006). Additionally, Mercedes' extraordinary resolve and her personal transcendence of the crime illustrate the near-heroic efforts necessary to mount and pursue rape charges in Peruvian courts-where victims largely manage the collection of evidence, in lieu of the state. 1 Although Mercedes' victory is an historical anomaly, it fits into a broader pattern of cases concerning women and sexual crimes in late 20th-century Peru, where courts of law are key sites in the production and negotiation of racial taxonomies. I argue that the evidence constructed in Mercedes' case discerns how women's sexuality is often defined by race in Peru. In the following article, I reconstruct the social circumstances and legal institutional setting surrounding the rape trial of Mercedes Ccorimanya Lavilla through the use of historical and ethnographic materials. I show how, in order to achieve a conviction, Mercedes had to develop a strategy in which she employed the instrumental languages of race by positioning herself as less "indigenous" than her attackers. Mercedes' actual court case file and her own narrative, along with family members' sentiments,
The Argentine Supreme Court of Justice and the Equality
Latin American Human Rights Studies, 2022
The aim of this paper is to analyze a selection of arguments used by the Argentine Supreme Court to reduce the sentence of individuals convicted of crimes against humanity. The focus will be primarily centered on Muiña´s case”, in which a lenient outdated ruling was made. The questions that this work will try to answer revolve around the court´s merit in issuing this lenient ruling to Muiña´s case and its justification. First, Muiña´s case is analyzed in depth. Then, a critical analysis about the ruling and a decision concerning the existence of a true justification will be developed. Finally, we will discuss the appropriateness of the Court’s decision in Muiña´s case as opposed to the decision made in “Batalla´s case”, in which a less beneficial law was applied retroactively.
2011
Social Anthropology, vol. 19/3; pp. 305-312. This article discusses the meaning of justice in the context of cosmopolitan law and human rights movements in Argentina. Specifically, it addresses the practice of Escrache, an alternative path to justice introduced by the organisation HIJOS, and the current trials against the ‘perpetrators’ of the last military regime. In doing so, the article traces the connection between an emergent consciousness of genocide as a historical ‘truth’ and the innovative localisation of cosmopolitan law in order to meet this ‘truth’ on a juridical level. As such it offers the idea of social and legal practices to be analysed not just as local articulations of justice, but as legal theory productions with potential lessons for elsewhere.
The Legal Development of the Pursuit of Gender Equality in Argentina
The Rights of Women in Comparative Constitutional Law, 2023
The chapter comprehensively examines gender inclusion in the Argentinian constitutional and legal framework and practice. We begin with a historical account of women’s exclusion in the 1853 Constitution and their gradual incorporation from the middle of the twentieth century. Then, we continue with an analysis of the incorporation of gender equality and a gender perspective in the Argentinian constitutional framework through the constitutional reform of 1994. We also review the different administrations’ public policies in this area. Finally, the chapter seeks to approach the interpretation of gender equality clauses: what has been done and what has been lacking to incorporate and effect gender equality in Argentina.
Latin American Feminists, Gender, and the Binary System of Human Rights Protection, 2022
On March 26, 2021, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights found Honduras responsible for the killing of Vicky Hernández, a trans woman and human rights defender.1 The Vicky Hernández et al. v. Honduras judgment is the first in which an international court has protected a trans woman by applying a human rights treaty that protects women. It thus provides an opportunity to analyze the impact of feminist ideas on the system of human rights protection at the regional level, with implications for international law more generally. In this essay, I defend the Inter-American Court's majority decision against the dissenting opinions, by arguing that the political subject of human rights is dynamic and emergent and, therefore, positive law is often one step behind in the struggles for recognition. For this reason, we need interpretations of rights that are inclusive, that evolve, and that push for the destabilization of law as binary, allowing the emergence of a more egalitarian legal system that recognizes intersectionality.