‘What will the neighbours say?’: Legitimacy, Social Control and the Sociocultural Influence of Neighbourhoods in India (original) (raw)
Related papers
The Lives of Others : The Production and Influence of Neighbourhood Cultures in Urban India
2018
Drawing on fieldwork in Bikaner and Thalassery, this chapter discusses the tremendous influence of neighbourhoods in everyday life. Moving away from a focus on social problems and poverty in neighbourhoods, Abraham explores the implications of a proximity that allows for various kinds of face-to-face interactions and a sensorial intimacy. She discusses everyday practices that make up the web of relations that constitute the neighbourhood—social control, social approval, legitimacy and support, with a focus on how gender is produced in everyday neighbourhood life. Abraham argues that the emphasis on caste, class, ethnic or religious identity has been at the cost of other influences such as the neighbourhood, which needs to be taken seriously as a social formation crucial to social life and as an important arena of social and cultural influence.
ETHINICITY & NEIGHBOURHOOD: HOW PEOPLE & LIFESTYLE ANIMATES THE NEIGHBOURHOOD
It’s a very well-known fact that a city is one large entity of various layers assembled; layers being that of infrastructural layers, spatial layers that make the city livable and functional; and the humanitarian layers or societal layers that give a character to the city. People of different cultural and traditional backdrops come together, interact, work and exchange experiences in the city, and then they also live there. People of different backgrounds and origins come there, having various cultural and traditional roots, lifestyle, language and social conduct defines their ‘ethnicity’. People often tend to bind in groups and especially with the ones they can match up to, in terms of their lifestyle, culture and traditional background. In a country like INDIA, where there is a large spread of various cultures, traditions, races and ETHNICITIES, people from different background comes to METROPOLIS like Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata etc., in search of opportunities for a better life. As a normal tendency people tend to choose their company and friends who have similar racial, cultural and ethnic backgrounds, and in the same way they choose to place themselves in a neighbourhood where, there are more concentrations of people from similar backgrounds of ‘ethnicities’. Such setups of neighborhoods where there are more concentrations of people of similar ethnicity can also be termed as ETHNIC NEIGHBORHOOD and are somehow different than most of the social housings or neighborhoods, as the ethnic groups or people gives it a unique character through the way they live, use the space through activities and various other functions and thus they can be seen as different setups of the neighborhood. Through the discourse of the paper, the prime investigation will be to look closely at some cases of ‘ethnic neighborhoods, from cities like DELHI, MUMBAI in INDIA and try to understand the people and their way of living and its effects on the space around their neighborhood; how they adapt to the place or more appropriately how the space adapts their way of living, activities and different usages. The paper shall bring out some cases of ethnicity based either on regional and racial typecast or religion and economic criteria’s. In each case the investigation will be based on understanding the people, their roots and way of living and then their adoption of the space and the neighborhood. KEYWORDS: Neighbourhood space, culture, tradition, lifestyle, ethnicity, public space
Neighborhood - the “Outside” Space for Girls in Urban India
This study explores the perspective of adolescent girls on the neighborhood as a social space that plays a role in the formation of their identity and agency. The study applies the ‘identities’ conceptual framework, which is a global, interdisciplinary, theoretical approach to understanding female identity. The study participants were girls enrolled in grades 7–10, from five schools in a district in the Northern State of India, who participated in structured focus group discussions. The study reports on the reduced relevance of neighborhood for girls and illustrates, through quotes, the reasons for their limited interaction.
ETHNICITY & NEIGHBOURHOOD : HOW PEOPLE AND LIFESTYLE ANIMATES THE NEIGHBOURHOOD
2014
It’s a very well-known fact that a city is one large entity of various layers assembled; layers being that of infrastructural layers, spatial layers that make the city livable and functional; and the humanitarian layers or societal layers that give a character to the city. People of different cultural and traditional backdrops come together, interact, work and exchange experiences in the city, and then they also live there. People of different backgrounds and origins come there, having various cultural and traditional roots, lifestyle, language and social conduct defines their ‘ethnicity’. People often tend to bind in groups and especially with the ones they can match up to, in terms of their lifestyle, culture and traditional background. In a country like INDIA, where there is a large spread of various cultures, traditions, races and ETHNICITY, people from different background comes to METROPOLIS like Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata etc., in search of opportunities for a better life. As a normal tendency people tend to choose their company and friends who have similar racial, cultural and ethnic backgrounds, and in the same way they choose to place themselves in a neighborhood where, there are more concentrations of people from similar backgrounds of ‘ethnicity’. Such setups of neighborhoods where there are more concentrations of people of similar ethnicity can also be termed as ETHNIC NEIGHBORHOODS and are somehow different than most of the social housings or neighborhoods, as the ethnic groups or people gives it a unique character through the way they live, use the space through activities and various other functions and thus they can be seen as different setups of the neighborhood. Through the discourse of the paper, the prime investigation will be to look closely at some cases of ‘ethnic neighborhoods, from cities like DELHI, MUMBAI in INDIA and try to understand the people and their way of living and its effects on the space around their neighborhood; how they adapt to the place or more appropriately how the space adapts their way of living, activities and different usages. The paper shall bring out some cases of ethnicity based either on regional and racial typecast or religion and economic criteria’s. In each case the investigation will be based on understanding the people, their roots and way of living and then their adoption of the space and the neighborhood.
Community and Neighbourhood in a Colonial City: Calcutta’s Para, South Asia Research, 38 (1), 2018
This article on the history of neighbourhoods (para) of colonial Calcutta considers the processes through which this peculiar spatial unit emerged in the colonial city, where community identities were fostered as well as contested. Seen as a place, a secured, stable location which helped in forming the community in an alien atmosphere, the para was a liminal space, neither a purely affective unit nor an administrative category, and neither a purely public or private domain. Borrowing liberally from each register to generate a unique spatial experience, paras were at the same time deeply exclusionary and also starkly patriarchal zones. The article brings forth these various strands in the history of the neighbourhood to enrich the understanding of colonial urbanism, Bengali society and culture.
Communal Living: Religion, Class, and the Politics of Dwelling in Small-town Gujarat
Contributions to Indian Sociology, 2018
India witnesses a proliferation of 'Muslim' and 'Hindu' residential areas, which reflect deepening segregation along religious lines. This article explores the production of such spaces through a case study of Anand in central Gujarat. It uses the lens of 'mobilities' to critically interrogate the 'Muslim ghetto', a notion that has come to figure prominently as a conceptual framework in discussions on residential segregation in contemporary India, and proposes to consider the residential spaces of Muslims instead as 'hubs' of urban and regional connectivity. Avoiding a false dichotomy between segregation-as-seclusion and cohabitation-as-connecting, the article demonstrates how new kinds of environments reflect and facilitate new sets of social relations, and generates a fresh perspective of a Muslim area as a hub of intersecting mobilities within a context of rural and urban transformation.
People Out of Place: Pavement Dwelling in Mumbai
Economic and Political Weekly, 2018
An examination of the circumstances in which a set of pavement dwellers in Mumbai came to the city, allows one to link their imperiled urban material and political circumstances to the green revolution and the changes it wrought both in the relations of social reproduction and the form of electoral politics. Methodologically, their life stories also suggest that the space of rural poverty in India cannot be coterminous with the village border. Thus, the hinterland is not a physical location but a relational one, a configuration of historical and spatial relations that could as easily be found outside a city’s limits, as it can be found inside a city.
From the basti to the 'house': Socio-spatial readings of housing policy in India
In June, 2015, the Government of India approved a national housing programme called the Prime Minster’s Awas Yojana (PMAY; Prime Minister’s Housing Plan), the latest in a series of ‘urban missions’ that have seen the urban emerge as an object for policy intervention in a country long rurally imagined. The emergence of these missions has necessitated the construction of a new urban grammar. Concepts, categories, and classifications have sought to define, delineate, and measure different aspects of the urban landscape so that different modes of practice and intervention may emerge. This article reads this grammar. It does so not to assess policy through its design, efficacy or feasibility, but to argue that policies, at least in part, attempt to create their own objects. A policy is thus both a product and an agent of contemporary politics, simultaneously instrumental and generative, acting a means to an end but also an end unto itself. It is, in many ways, as much a site of the construction of meaning as it is the allocation of resources. This article looks at housing policy in the Indian city from a particular site: auto-constructed neighborhoods in the Indian city – referred to here as the basti in contra-distinction to the ‘slum’. In doing so, it offers a socio-spatial reading of these settlements along three lines: transversality, transparency and opacity. It then reads the proposed new national housing policy against these spatialities and argues that the policy fundamentally misrecongnises ‘housing’ in the Indian city.
Lived Reality of Elite Neighbourhoods: Geographies of Inequality in Delhi
Contemporary South Asia , 2023
This paper is an ethnographic account of elite neighbourhoods in Delhi. It unpacks the lived realities of these neighbourhoods by studying how elite-ness is both constituted and contested within gated residential areas and other public spaces of Delhi. It argues that elites extend the unequal world they inhabit outside their gated residences by identifying certain public spaces for their leisure activities, especially shopping malls, leaving the neighbourhood community centres or RWA clubs to cater to non-elite residents. It also focuses on the narratives of the domestic staff employed in elite households, who too inhabit the public spaces within these neighbourhoods, including parks, streets, and markets. In this way, the paper draws out the class contestations within elite neighbourhoods and explains how these spaces become sites of class fractions and factions as they are marked by the politics of who a ‘real’ elite is. As such, this paper is an account of how class exclusionary boundaries are drawn and subverted by elites and non-elites both in private (gated neighbourhoods) and public spaces (parks, shopping malls), thus bringing attention to the fractured realities of elite neighbourhoods.
This paper looks into South Delhi's Hauz Khas Village exploring the relation between identity constructions of young urbanites, their practices and imaginaries and the socio-spatial changes erupting within the Village's multi-layered and increasingly gentrifying spaces. Cosmopolitan inner city life reveals the distinctions emerging between the young urban middle and upper middle classes and the familiar images of Indian middle-class urbanity and Global City living. These differences are increasingly implicated in gentrification processes and the rearrangement of the city, according to the aesthetics of the neighbourhood. South Delhi's urban villages emerge as appropriate sites of tension in which the drastic changes after Delhi's economic liberalisation have become starkly visible. The paper presents a differentiated picture of middle class and elite identities and illustrates the way symbolic claims to urban space are expressed in cosmopolitan urbanity.