Rejoinder to the reply to a comment by S.N. Semenov and M.E. Schimpf on ‘Role of the velocity frame of reference in thermodiffusion in liquid mixtures’, Philosophical Magazine vol. 92, 705 (2012), by M. Eslamian, C.G. Jian and M.Z. Saghir (original) (raw)

This rejoinder addresses the reply by Eslamian, Jian, and Saghir regarding comments made on their original work related to thermodiffusion in liquid mixtures. It refutes specific objections raised in the reply, asserting that their equations remain valid and highlighting issues with the approach taken in the response. The authors emphasize the importance of temperature dependence in chemical potentials for accurate representation of thermodiffusion, while presenting own formulations that align with established thermodynamic principles.